Textbook Notes (363,074)
Canada (158,173)
POL2101 (26)

DGD 3 - The Senate + Article summaries

4 Pages
Unlock Document

University of Ottawa
Political Science
Luc Turgeon

DGD 3 – The Senate Abolish the Senate instead of trying to reform it – Jan. 2010 • Prime Minister Harper takes a major step in his crusade to reform the Senate by appointing 5 new senators to the 105-seat chamber • More Conservative than Liberal senators (for the first time in decades) • Ensures control of the upper house of Parliament and swift passage of any Harper legislation (especially Senate reform) • 2 new bills proposed to the House of Commons • 1- eight-year term limit on senators • 2- senators elected in province-wide elections • Harper believes an elected Senate would be more responsive to voters, would not unduly delay bills passed by MPs, and would protect the interests of small provinces between than the House of Commons Critic  Abolish the Senate, not reform it • Costly, useless, and undemocratic joke with little power • Having elected senators won’t improve the quality of legislation, protect provincial interests, or play any relevant role in the lives of most Canadians • It retain the Senate as a high-paid debating society or research institution is ridiculous 1- No province has a Senate, so why does Ottawa need one? No one feels a chamber of “sober second thought” is needed to vet bills passed by their unicameral legistlatures. 2- The Senate isn’t needed to protect provincial interests. That’s the role of elected MPs and provincial governments. Premiers defend their province, not senators. 3- An elected Senate would not necessarily mean legislation approved by the Commons would get swift passage. Ascenario where the Commons is dominated by one party and the Senate by another is a recipe for gridlock. • Support for abolishing the Senate is fairly strong in Canada – provincial governments in ON, BC, SK, and MT and the NDP have been in favor of killing it for a long time • Abolishing the Senate would be difficult because it requires a constitutional amendment which needs provincial consent. • First step – hold a national referendum timed with a federal election to control costs • Harper is open to the idea as long as it includes reform options Senate reform bill proposes 9-year terms – June 2011 • Prime Minister Harper’s Senate ReformAct – nine-year term limit under new legislation • Currently no fixed term for senators (although they must retire at 75) • For senators appointed in 2008, limited term would start from the date the bill is passed • Senators appointed before 2008 would be exempt • Term in non-renewable (cannot run for reelection) • Bill allows for an “interruption” in the nine-year term (doesn’t have to be consecutive years) • Provinces and territories cannot be forced to hold Senate elections without changing the Constitution – voluntary scheme. Provinces and territories that hold elections will have their nominees appointed when vacancies arise. • Elections could be held in conjunction with provincial elections, province-wide municipal elections, etc. • Previously established election agencies would oversee the process. No provisions on the federal government footing the bill. • Minist
More Less

Related notes for POL2101

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.