Textbook Notes (368,558)
Canada (161,962)
Sociology (1,513)
SOC211H5 (29)


5 Pages
Unlock Document

Nicole Myers

Ch.5 Biological and Physiological Explanations of Deviance: The body Did it  Positivism (sometimes also called scientism) is based on the belief that the methods of natural science should be adapted to the study of human beings  Positivist theory assumes that knowledge can be discovered only through sensory experience, observation, and experiment. It’s early proponents claimed, sometimes only half-truthfully, that they employed the scientific method of sampling, controls, and analysis.  Positivism –and the “positive school of criminology” it gave rise to –represents what Kuhn (1970) terms a paradigm shift  It constituted a new kind of lens through which human nature and human behavior could be understood.  Positivists assume that, underlying al empirical reality, there are discoverable laws that can be used to explain everything in nature, including human behavior. Social Darwinism  The English philosopher Herbert Spencer (1820-1903) coined the phrase “survival of the fittest” to describe the implications of evolutionary theory for human society. Spencer argued that every field –industry, art, science, or human biology –reflected a pattern of development from lower to higher, from less complex to more complex, from inferior to superior.  He took from Darwin’s The Origin of Species and the Descent of Man the notion that the development in human societies followed the principles of natural selection through competition.  The more fit competitors win, survive, and procreate, while the less fit die out –unless of course, the fit commit race suicide by not breeding or the unfit (the poor, the criminal, and those with mental illnesses) are artificially supported by well-meaning but misguided people.  Adherents of this Social Darwinism believed that those living organisms –whether humans, plant or animal –best able to adapt to a particular set of living conditions were the ones with the greatest chances of survival.  Social darwinists reason that the powerful and rich are that way because they are more “fit,” not in Darwin’s original meaning of reproductive capacity but in a parallel social meaning of having health, intelligence, and good moral qualities.  Fitness became a synonym not only for healthy but also for deserving. Mendel and The Discovery of Genetic Inheritance  Gregor Mendel studied plant seeds and discovered the genetic principles whereby variations of colour and size are transmitted by heredity through predictable mutations and combinations of genes. Born Criminal Theory  The idea that criminality was not only inborn but also marked a person’s appearance was common in antiquity  The newly emerging criminal anthropology promised the possibility of using physical features to identify actual and potential criminals  The earliest researchers sought to find statistical connections between external characteristics such as facial features, skull size, and body shape Physiognomy  Physiognomy: the science of judging character on the basis of facial features, had widespread support and appeal in the late 18 and early 19 centuries  John Caspar Lavater produced a detailed four volume map of the human face, which associated various shapes and structures with specific personality traits  Criminals were characterized as tending to have shifty eyes, weak chins, and large arrogant noses. Phrenology th  Phrenology: (phrenos=mind, logos=study) was most popular in the mid 19 century  It was based on the theory that functions such as cautious ness, firmness, benevolence, mirthfulness, and intellect were located in distinct parts of the brain and that the strong the function, the larger their physical manifestations  The enlarged parts, it was held, would push the skull out so that a trained technical could feel the bumps and thus “read” the person’s character  Franz Joseph Gall and his student and colleague, Johann Caspar Spurzheim published a two volume work on phrenology, presenting it as a new science.  Brain defects might be the product of heredity, environment, or disease, or even the consequences of upbringing since the practice of certain kinds of behavior might influence the organization of the normal brain and throw it out of balance. th  In the mid 19 century, it was customary to make a cast of the head of executed criminals so that degenerate features of the skull could be recored. Craniometry  Craniometry: was a system of classifying human types on the basis of skull measurement, particularly measurement of its size.  Larger brains were believed to indicate grater brain activity (and thus the superiority of the individual), but when it was found, for example, that the largest female brain ever recorded belonged to a woman who killed her husband, the theory had to be revised.  Most craniologists held that the brain that was too large or too small could be the sign of deviance in the individual.  Craniometric data usually corroborated prevailing social, ethnic, national and gender biases. Lombroso’s “Criminal Anthropology”  Central to Lombroso’s conception of crime was his theory of biological atavism  According to this theory, the criminal (or troublemaker) was an evolutionary throwback a reversion to a more primitive stage in human evolution  Physical characteristics (stigmata) such as sloping foreheads, bushy eyebrows, and protruding jaws and cheekbones were evidence of atavism and its attendant deviant propensity.  Different kinds of criminality were indicated by head and body size, hair colour, and abnormalities of the ears, nose, arms, and body.  For example, “ravishers” have short hands, medium-sized brains, and narrow foreheads; there is a predominance of liht hair with abnormalities of the genital organs and of the nose”  Lombroso’s follower Enrico Ferri coined the term born criminal to describe the biologically determined criminal type.  In Lombroso’s terms, tattooing reflected primitive people’s love of adornment and insensitivity to pain.  Lombroso classified all criminals as “epileptoids” on a scale in which epileptic was at the top, followed by criminal moral imbecile, born criminal, criminaloid (occasional criminal), and criminal by passion.  Lombroso did not claim that all criminals were born criminals. He adjusted his argument repeatedly to meet the criticisms of other researchers.  Lombroso believed that born criminals were the most serious and chronic offenders. Eugenics and Theories of Degeneracy  The term eugenics (good birth) was coined in 1883 by Sir Francis Galton, who saw selective breeding as the antidote to the social problems produced by the dysgenic effects of the increasing numbers of citizens who were genetically unfit  Positive eugenics policies were proposed to encourage those with the best genes to reproduce  Negative eugenics involved programs to exclude inferior populations (immigration controls), compulsory sterilization programs for those identified as unfit, and in Germany, extermination programs for the ethnically, mentally, and politically unfit.  Francis Galton imagined an ideal society called “Kantsaywhere” which whould be a eugenic society.  Only be maintained in a society that had eugenics as a religion  Eugenics have tended to form close attachments with those developing new techniques of psychometrics –IQ (intelligence quotient) tests, MRI brain scanning techniques, and similar measures. Earnest Albert Hooton and The Hierarchy of Degeneration  Hooton argued that crime was the result of normal environmental stre
More Less

Related notes for SOC211H5

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.