Textbook Notes (369,155)
Canada (162,426)
MDSA01H3 (310)
Chapter 5

CHAPTER 5 - RHETORICAL ANALYSIS

8 Pages
136 Views

Department
Media Studies
Course Code
MDSA01H3
Professor
Michael Petit

This preview shows pages 1,2 and half of page 3. Sign up to view the full 8 pages of the document.
Description
MDSA01 INTRODUCTION TO MEDIA STUDIES CHAPTER 5 – RHETORICAL ANALYSIS  Functioning as a rhetoric o An attempt to shape and influence its viewers’ attitudes  Analyze texts for the ways they encourage audiences to inhabit certain moods, believe certain ideas, or undertake certain actions  Views text as complex webs of interrelated parts which work to influence consumers in particular ways  Signs: Basic building blocks of language and most other forms of rhetoric, and creates meaning Rhetoric: an Overview  Media messages cannot help but convey meanings. These meanings are never neutral or objective  Media is telling us to adopt certain attitudes, values, and beliefs while telling us to overlook others  All media outlets are rhetoric  Rhetoric: The ancient art of oratory or as Aristotle famously defined it, “an ability, in each particular case, to see the available means of persuasion”. o Relies on symbols to influence what (and how) audiences think and feel o The use of symbols by humans to influence and move other humans  All messages are necessarily biased  If something is a reflection of terminology, it must be a selection of reality, which therefore means it acts as a deflection of reality Theories of the Sign  Sign: Something that invites someone to think of something other than itself, such as the way an image of a person invites one to think of that personof the way the way the unique letter combination of d/o/g invites one to think of a four-legged canine  Everything has a potential, so anything can function as a sign  Shared meaning: when multiple people agree on what a sign refers to o Makes human communication possible o Allows for the existence of social structure and institutions  Communication is fragile, because there is not sign which everyone will interpret the same way o Misinterpretations  -Signs are fundamental to communication Ferdinand de Saussure (1857-1913)  Swiss linguist  Founder of modern linguistics  His unique approach to linguistics: Semiology: A science which studies the role of signs as part of social life. Studies the nature of signs and the laws which govern them  Language was a system of signs o What is a sign? o What rules does it obey?  All linguistic signs are a combination of a signifier (significant) and the signified (signifie) 1 | P a g e MDSA01 INTRODUCTION TO MEDIA STUDIES o Signifier: Sound-image, refers to the material form of a sign as perceived by the senses, such as the world “dog” as heard by the listener o Signified: Mental concept, is the idea evoked by the signifier; in this case, the idea of “dogness”  Linguistic sign has two defining traits o Arbitrary: There is no natural correspondence, no necessary relationship between signifier and signified  Not link  Languages  No fixed universal concepts or fixed universal signifiers  The signified is also arbitrary o Linearity: Auditory signifier is only one at a time. Visual signs can exploit more than one dimension simultaneously  Langue versus Parole o Langue: The linguistic system  The rules and conventions that organize the system o Parole: Individual speech acts or utterances (actual manifestations of the sign system).  Study specific uses or performances of language  Proper goal of linguistics  Synchronic versus diachronic o Synchronic Analysis: Concerns the state of language in general: linguistic system in a static state.  Illuminate the conditions for the existence of any language by examining the rules of combination and substitutability within a system o Diachronic analysis (Evolutionary Linguistics): Origins of languages and changes in sound or pronounciation over time  Changes are already found in Parole, so Saussure did not see this as a suitable method for investigating langue  Difference: Signs signigy virtue by their difference(distinctiveness) from other signs o Dog signifies, because it sounds difference than cat, mouse, horse o Distinguish one word from another allows for communication o Relations of difference also matters  Dog sounds different from red, but red is not meaningful because it diffes from dog. It is meaningful because it differs from yellow, blue, green  Differences do not have to be universal, just socially agreed upon o Replacing the bishop piece with a bottle cap as long as the players agree Charles Sanders Peirce (1839-1914)  Semiotic: the quasi-necessary, or formal, doctrine of signs  Denies arbitrariness and expands signs to include all mode of human communication(not just language) 2 | P a g e MDSA01 INTRODUCTION TO MEDIA STUDIES  Triadic relation between sign, object and interpretant  Sign (Respresentamen): Something which stands to somebody for something in some respect of capacity o To somebody it stands for something  Equivalent Sign (Interpretant): What is created in the mind by the sign  Object: Something which the sign stands for  Three Categories of Signs o Iconic Signs: Operate according to the logic of similarity or likeness; icons are representamens that structurally resemble the objects they stand for  Maps, Photographs, Diagram o Indexical Signs: Linked by cause or association to the objects they represent  Smoke indicates fire  Anything which fcuses the attention is an index o Symbols: Linked to their corresponding objects purely by social convention or agreement  Learned rather than intuited  Language o Categories are not mutually exclusive o Certain signs could function in more than one way Roland Barthes (1915-1980)  Refined and expanded the ideas of others  Signifying system  How cultural practices and beliefs are naturalized  Distinction between denotation and connotation o Denotation: First-order signification. Involves the literal or explicit meaning of words and other phenomena  Lion (Signifier) -> Mental image of a large cat (Signified) o Connotation: Second-order signification. Ideology and myth. Evokes other associations  Mental Image (Signifier) -> Pet, companion, family member, pest (Signified) 3 | P a g e MDSA01 INTRODUCTION TO MEDIA STUDIES  Meaning is never final or closed  Relationship between signifier and signified isn’t arbitrary -> unmotivated  Linguistic message (coded iconic message) to limit the meanings an image can have  Denoted image (non-coded iconic message(  Connoted image (coded iconic message)  Relay function: Words complement and reinforce images Texts and Rhetorical Structures  Signs rarely exist or function in isolation  Signs are combined with other signs to form media products or texts: Set of signs related to each other insofar as their meanings all contribute to the same set of effects or functions  Strategic structures to elicit particular responses  Rhetoric Structures: o Clusters o Form o Genre o Narrative Clusters  Most basic rhetorical structure in text  Cluster: The way individual signs are associated with and dissociated from one another  Identify key signs in a text o Repeated o Intensity o Prominence  Ask what other signs are associated with the key signs o Consider the absence of certain signs  Ask whether the clustering of signs fosters a positive, negative or ambivalent valence toward the key signs Form  Form: An arousing and fulfillment of desires  Work has form as one part of it leads a reader to antic
More Less
Unlock Document

Only pages 1,2 and half of page 3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit