Textbook Notes (367,747)
Canada (161,363)
History (109)
HIS109Y1 (16)

Seminar 2 - Renaissance Ideals and Realities.pdf

8 Pages
Unlock Document

Kenneth Bartlett

HIS109Y1 Western Civilizations: p. 373 - 391 & Vol. 1: p. 387 - 409 & Seminar 2 - Renaissance Ideals and Realities October 3rd/2012 Tutorial - humanism: defining your ideology - art: decrease in religious themes, rediscovering pagan beauty, patrons were used (competition amongst banking families caused conspicuous consumption to develop reputations, use of perspective in art, classicism - separation of Church and State - movement from feudal to mercantile economies - importance of classical texts - reform of the education system towards the humanities - inventions like the printing press allowed for the distribution of classical works - scientific developments - new social classes (mercantile class) - urban life developed - male dominance persisted despite these developments - after the creation of a new middle class, commentaries on everyday life and instruction manuals as to how to act appropriately in court life were necessary to inform new classes like the mercantile class how they should act - the station of women did change slightly for courtly ladies - some ladies of the court were educated in the Renaissance however they would not have studied the same things as men (dance and music rather than literature) Perspectives From the Past: p. 387 - 409 I Libri della Famiglia (On the Family) Leon Battista Alberti (1404 - 1474) -> he was a Renaissance man; entered the papal service -> examines the family unit and its role in rearing children - “My first consideration would only be to make my children grow up with good character and virtue” - a father should always encourage his son to be active and not idle; to try and have his son learn a noble labour skill in case misfortune strikes his family - to make a family fortunate: * the number of men must augment and not diminish * possessions must grow and not lessen *a fine reputation is precious * avoid enemies while cultivating friendships - sons must take wives to keep them from sin and produce male heirs - a wife should come from a family with a status not too great to over shadow that of the husband, but not too low to be dishonorable. Man & wife should be of equal classes - nature did not make every many equal, so finding a good job that fits each man’s skills is important - wealth can get a man esteem and praise but a man should work for honor as well Review Questions: 1) According to Alberti, the role of the father is to uphold the family and teach them how to be honorable and successful. 2) A father’s authority is similar to all authorities at the top of a hierarchy, even a monarch. They all seek to establish stability in their followers. 3) Education is important to human nature because it’s knowledge that allows you to see the importance in all people no matter what career they take. It also gives you status and power important to reputation. 4) Other authors in this series of works view education as the same mechanism for establishing a reputation and upholding personal and consequentially family honor. With the resurgence of classicalism, literature was viewed as ethical guides for living so it was essential to nobility or those who aspired to become courtiers (Castiglione). 5) Alberti’s definition of honor is that of a person who pursues noble works; accomplishing the best that they can by working hard and developing their reputation as well as their families’. 6) Family and honor are very closely linked because one man’s honor will affect that of his entire family. To Alberti who was an illegitimate son, he always felt pressure from his family for honor because his reputation brought shame to them. 7) Alberti might define family as a hierarchy of men, with the father on top, dictating practices and punishments to his son’s underneath in order to maintain propriety, honor and stability until they start their own families. The Notebooks Leonard Da Vinci (1452 - 1519) -> he was born outside of Florence; a true Renaissance man mastering both science and art -> his notebooks were filled with observations on perspective - all things transmit their image to the eye by means of a pyramid; the nearer to the eye these pyramids intersected, the smaller the image would appear - perspective makes something flat appear 3-D or in relief and vice versa - when representing perspective in your work, it is impossible for your perspective not to appear false, since someone else viewing the same subject will see something different unless standing at the exact distance/elevation you were - “the eye does not see distant objects as much diminished as they are in natural perspective” - in natural perspective, the greater the distance the smaller something would appear Review Questions: 1) The relationship between the perspective in nature and the perspective in the human eye: according to Da Vinci, the distance and the elevation of the person from the object changes the natural perspective 2) Perspective and mathematical principles are related because the convexity of the eye affected the angle that the image approaches the eye 3) Perspective is contingent upon a multitude of other factors and is not constant 4) In terms of paintings, the idea of perspective changes how the art is viewed since each observer will see something different 5) Da Vinci’s ideas on perspective and how it can alter text validates individuality and the important of studies. Therefore it does not just apply to art but to theology, philosophy and history as well. - almost an instruction manual for artists - connects to other works because his thoughts on perspective could be expanded to all people in the Renaissance (ie. perspective on life) The Book of the Courtier Baldesar Castiglione (1478 - 1529) -> this book presented the concept of a Renaissance man and worked as a guidebook to court life - generally, noble men of the courts have been born into that status and have been trained to be there - however for the new middle class that was not brought up as Court men and women, they can study to “amend their natural defects” - the true profession of the courtier should be as a soldier, this means they also need to act bold and stern in the face of their enemies but modest and reserved when dealing with others - courtiers should be well read in studies involving the humanities and well versed in poetry and verse - these guidelines apply to both noble men and women - the aim of the courtier is to serve the prince by leading him towards right and frightening him away from wrong - following these principles will result in a good courtier Review Questions: 1) When Castiglione mentions “grace” he is referring to status and prestige amongst nobles, not in the religious sense. 2) The author states that most “grace” is because of lineage since a father will train his son to be just like him, however hard work and study can move someone from “senseless folly” to a respectable estate. 3) Grace can be reached by both men and women but in different ways since the quality of a court man and a court women are very different. 4) A courtier’s status is supposed to be evident in his refined behavior. Without this he is not fit to represent the prince. 5) With the introduction of a merchant class and people from humble beginnings now reach wealth, lineage and status are less entwined. The idea of a courtier being someone of skill and refinement rather than noble birth affects how power is distributed in the social hierarchy. 6) The courtier is different from a knight because he shows restraint towards violence and different from a monk because he does not abstain from violence if necessary. 7) The courtier’s “virtue” is an expression of his cultivation, working towards a sense of nobility. Oration on the Dignity of Man Giovanni Pico Della Mirandola (1463 - 1494) -> a unique scholar in Renaissance Humanism -> this speech was written for a public philosophical debate but was never presented due to church interference - scholars often of the greatness of man because of his acute senses, reasoning skills and intelligence. - Pico notes a different reason for our superiority that changes the great chain of being - he says that God had established the Chain well before humanity, and after the creation of Adam, gave humans the capacity to change our status on the Chain. - therefore humans have an indeterminate nature and have the freedom of choice whether to degenerate to lower forms or be reborn into a high divine form. - this represents the importance of the Renaissance philosophy of individuality. Rev
More Less

Related notes for HIS109Y1

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.