Textbook Notes (368,242)
Canada (161,733)
GS221 (4)

GS221 Tutorial Response Week 7.docx

3 Pages
Unlock Document

Global Studies
Edmund Pries

GS221-T2 Tutorial Week 7 Response Van Hooft Chapter 2 Ashley Stratton 110110900 In this chapter Van Hooft focuses on what human rights are, who should have them and how they are justified. In this chapter human rights are rights that are given to humans from each other to ensure respect and dignity. The Declaration of Human Rights is an example of human rights as a policy. Many countries aren’t about to provide their citizens with basic human rights because of their poverty level. In hopes of changing this wealthy, more developed countries often provide aid to poorer countries. This however creates an interesting relationship. The donor country often feels like they are doing the receiving country owes them something in return for this favour. This can be avoided though if the aid is seen as a right for the receiving country rather than a favour. If it is provided as a right it becomes the donor country’s duty to provide the aid, this eliminates the relationship of mutual expectations between the donor and receiving countries. I found this point especially interesting, I have never differentiated aid as a human right that needs to be provided from aid that isn’t deemed a necessity. I had always lumped aid as always being needed in poorer countries until they are able to ensure safety and basic human needs to the entire population. I understand that corruption changes the path of the donated funds but I don’t think it is fair to expect favours in return from a country that can’t properly govern,, but I also don’t think it is far to take the much needed funding from the citizens of the receiving country. Giving foreign aid is even more complicated than I had already thought. But on the other hand I understand why expectations would develop if the donor country feels as though they are doing a favour for the receiving country. The same thing happens more often than not between individuals. Happening between two countries has much greater potential for favour returns. This connects to grievances through the differentiation between not receiving something you wanted in comparison to something you are entitled to. If a country is entitled to the funding as a human right it needs to be provided but if they wanted it as a favour it changes the relationship as described above. Later in the chapter the idea is presented by JSM that items are usually given the title of a right when they are being taken away. This is when the majority of people affected by the loss of this item realize how much they desire the item. The text describes changing gun laws in Australia but it could also be applied to the USA. E
More Less

Related notes for GS221

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.