Textbook Notes (369,036)
Canada (162,360)
York University (12,903)
MODR 1770 (26)
Chapter 3

MODR 1770-CH3 Notes.docx

6 Pages
148 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Modes Of Reasoning
Course
MODR 1770
Professor
Glen Hoffman
Semester
Fall

Description
MODR 1770 Oct 15/12 CH 3 – Making Sense of Arguments Lecture + Notes D EVISING AN ARGUMENT  To show that a statement/claim is worthy of acceptance © E VALUATING AN ARGUMENT  To see whether the argument shows that the statement (conclusion) is worthy of acceptance 2 forms of arguments DEDUCTIVE  Provides logically conclusive, absolute support for conclusion  Valid: if premises are true, conclusion must be true o Deductively valid arguments are truth-preserving; conclusion follows logically, order of premises makes no difference  Sound: premises are true.  Invalid: conclusion doesn’t follow logically from the premises (regardless of order of premises) o Argument w/ true conclusion can be invalid if conclusion isn’t supported by the premises  Valid deductive argument; conclusion is false; thus 1 of the premises is false INDUCTIVE Provides probable (not conclusive) support for conclusion Cogent: has true premises LOGICAL STRUCTURE Refers to the construction of an argument; the way the premises and conclusion fit together *Persuading is not the same as reasoning with crit. thinking; persuading: influence opinions by using words to appeal to their ego, gullibility, greed, anger, etc; emotional language, psychological ploys, lies, etc. Does not show that a belief is true/warranted. Crit. thinking reasoning can be psychologically compelling but the 2 have different functions. MODR 1770 Oct 15/12 Judging arguments 1. Find conclusion then premises of argument. 2. If the premises are true, the conclusion MUST be true? (Yes: deductive) a. Check to see if it’s sound (valid). 3. If the premises are true, is the conclusion PROBABLY true? (Yes: inductive) a. Check to see if it’s cogent (strong). 4. Is the argument intended to offer conclusive/probable support but fails? (Invalid/weak argument; determine what kind of argument is intended) a. If form shows it’s inductive/deductive, assume it’s intended b. If indicator words (form shows no clues) shows it’s inductive/deductive, assume it’s intended i. Deductive: absolutely, necessarily, certainly ii. Inductive: plausible that, probably, odds/chances are F INDING MISSING PARTS  Some premises are implicit/assumed and left out  Often these are controversial and must be examined  Find an unstated premise when something essential is missing that’s not a common sense generally accepted assumption.  Usually left out/downplayed to make an argument seem stronger. T O MAKE SURE INVESTIGATION OF IMPLICIT PREMISES IS THOROUGH & REASONABLE 1. Search for credible premise that would make argument valid & provide link between premise(s) & conclusion. a. Is the most plausible & best fits with author’s intent (Principle of Charity (in interpretation) b. When we find someone’s meaning unclear, should attempt to interpret it in a way that makes sense 2. (If step 1 doesn’t work) Search for credible premise that would make argument as strong as possible & fits with the principle of charity 3. Evaluate reconstructed argument. MODR 1770 Oct 15/12 Deductive Argument Patterns INVOLVE 2 KINDS OF STATEMENTS : Conditional {if-then}  If p, then q  Compound statements composed of 2 parts: o Antecedent – follows “if” o Consequent – follows “then” Disjunctive statement  Either p or q  Compound statement composed of 2 disjuncts A FFIRMING THE A NTECEDENT (M ODUS PONENS )  Valid; deductive, conditional. If p then q. P. Therefore q.  Not necessarily sound (premises could be false) D ENYING
More Less

Related notes for MODR 1770

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit