GOV 1290 Chapter Notes - Chapter 12: Middle Eastern Studies, Resource Curse, Dependent And Independent Variables

56 views12 pages
!"#$%&'()*+,)-*()The$Durability$of$Revolutionary$Regimes$i
!"#$%
&
!'(%
&
)*+#,-./$#*$
&
01%$.
&
2*1-".3*1,%
&
4#,-$%5
&
6#7-*1#8%99:."%+,.;1*+,$.-"%-.-",:.8%$.7'1+#+,.<*1.5%$:.=,8%=,7.
=,7;#-,.#$-,$7,.,>-,1$%9.;1,77'1,?.;**1.,8*$*5#8.;,1<*15%$8,?.%$=.
9%1@,A78%9,.;*9#8:.<%#9'1,7
B",7,.1,@#5,7."%+,.;*7,=.7,1#*'7.%$=.;,17#7-,$-.8"%99,$@,7.-*.
C,7-,1$.=,5*81%8#,7.%$=.-",#1.<*1,#@$.;*9#8:
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.%1,.1,5%1E%(9:.='1%(9,
The$Durability$of$Revolutionary$Regimes
F
G('#9=#$@.*$.-",.C*1E.*<.)%5',9.6'$-#$@-*$.%$=.B",=%.)E*8;*9?.C,.
=,<#$,.."#/01%$/+*.()."2$3"& %7.-"*7,.C"#8".,5,1@,.*'-.*<.7'7-%#$,=?.
#=,*9*@#8%9?.%$=.+#*9,$-.7-1'@@9,.<1*5.(,9*C?.%$=.C"*7,.,7-%(9#7"5,$-.#7.
%88*5;%$#,=.(:.5%77.5*(#9#H%-#*$.%$=.7#@$#<#8%$-.,<<*1-7.-*.-1%$7<*15.
7-%-,.7-1'8-'1,7.%$=.-",.,>#7-#$@.*1=,1G.IJK
4/&%."#/1%$/+*.()5"2$3"&6)%99.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.#$.C"#8".-",.
@,$,1%-#*$.-"%-.;%1-#8#;%-,=.=#1,8-9:.#$.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7-1'@@9,."%7.=#,=.
*<<?.7'8".%7.L,>#8*.%$=.-",.)*+#,-./$#*$.%<-,1.-",.MNOPQ7
R*,7.$*-.#$89'=,.1,@#5,7.-"%-.,5,1@,.<1*5.+#*9,$-.#$=,;,$=,$8,.
7-1'@@9,7.#$.C"#8".1%=#8%9.-1%$7<*15%-#*$%9.@*%97.=*.$*-.;1,=*5#$%-,.
I0$=*$,7#%K?.8%7,7.*<.5%77A(%7,=.1,@#5,.8"%$@,.#$.C"#8".7-%-,7.%$=.7*8#%9.
7-1'8-'1,7.1,5%#$.#$-%8-.I-",.S"#9#;;#$,7.#$.MNTO?./E1%#$,.#$.UPPV?.W@:;-.#$.
UPMMK?.*1.8%7,7.*<.1%=#8%9.8"%$@,.#$#-#%-,=.(:.%8-*17.C#-"#$.-",.7-%-,.#-7,9<
7"8$9/):;<)("*.&=
>??5):@A)("*.&=
§
BC$+*):D<)("*.&)*+,)9/1+%$+2=
§
E$"%+*3):FG)("*.&)*+,)9/1+%$+2=
§
!/+2"&%)&1.#$#$+2)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)/H)%C")0*&%)9"+%1.()%C*%)I".")
J/.+)/1%)/H)#$/0"+%)."#/01%$/+
GB,$.*<.-",.-C,9+,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.-"%-.,>#7-,=.#$.
X%$'%1:.MNTN.7'1+#+,=.-"1*'@".UPMY?.8*5;%1,=.-*.(%1,9:.%.-"#1=.IUN.*<.
TUK.*<.-",.C*19=Z7.$*$1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7[.0$=,,=?.-",.
*$9:.8*55'$#7-.1,@#5,7.-"%-.;,17#7-,=.%<-,1.-",.8*99%;7,.*<.-",.)*+#,-.
/$#*$\!"#$%?.!'(%?.]%*7?.2*1-".3*1,%?.%$=.4#,-$%5\C,1,.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:[.]#E,C#7,?.#$.7'(A)%"%1%$.^<1#8%?.%5*$@.-",."%$=<'9.*<.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.-"%-.1,5%#$.#$-%8-.UV.:,%17.%<-,1.-",.<%99.*<.-",.
_,19#$.`%99.%1,.-"1,,.-"%-.C,1,.<*'$=,=.#$.+#*9,$-.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,7a.
^$@*9%?.L*H%5(#b',?.%$=.c#5(%(C,[.^$=.#$.-",.L#==9,.W%7-.%$=.2*1-".
^<1#8%?.-",.*$9:.$*$5*$%18"#,7.-"%-.C,1,.$*-.7,1#*'79:.8"%99,$@,=.='1#$@.
-",.^1%(.);1#$@\^9@,1#%.%$=.01%$\C,1,.(*1$.*<.+#*9,$-.7-1'@@9,[G.IOK
!"#$%Q7.!*55'$#7-.1,@#5,.7'1+#+,=.-",.MNTN.B#%$%$5,$.)b'%1,.
';1#7#$@
§
!'(%Q7.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,.7'1+#+,=.-",.8*99%;7,.*<.#-7.)*+#,-.
;%-1*$?.%.VPd.=,89#$,.#$.eRS?.%$=.f#=,9.!%7-1*Q7.=,;%1-'1,.<1*5.
;*C,1
§
2*1-".3*1,%.!*55'$#7-.1,@#5,.,$='1,=.%.5%77.<%5#$,.<*99*C#$@.
-",.)*+#,-.8*99%;7,?.%7.C,99.%7.-",.=,%-".*<.<*'$=#$@.9,%=,1.3#5.09.
)'$@
§
!"%99,$@,7.-*.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.#$.-",.;*7-A!*9=.`%1.;,1#*=
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.D,@#5,7
F
B",.=,7-1'8-#*$.*<.#$=,;,$=,$-.;*C,1.8,$-,17
§
!*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7
§
B#@"-.;%1-#7%$.8*$-1*9.*+,1.-",.7,8'1#-:.<*18,7
§
S*C,1<'9.8*,18#+,.%;;%1%-'7,7
§
`,.%1@',.-"%-.%15,=.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,?.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7-%-,A('#9=#$@?.
%$=.-",.+#*9,$-.8*$<9#8-7.-1#@@,1,=.(:.,<<*1-7.-*.8%11:.*'-.1%=#8%9.7*8#%9.
8"%$@,.9,%+,.<*'1.9,@%8#,7. -"%-.,$"%$8,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:a.
B",7,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.9,@%8#,7. ",9;.-*.#$*8'9%-,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.
%@%#$7-.,9#-,.=,<,8-#*$?.5#9#-%1:.8*';7?.%$=.5%77.;1*-,7-.AA -"1,,.5%g*1.
7*'18,7.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.(1,%E=*C$
)-,;",$.`%9-.7"*C7.-"%-.1,+*9'-#*$7.=1%5%-#8%99:.#$81,%7,.-",.
9#E,9#"**=.*<.#$-,17-%-,.C%1
§
R,7-1'8-#*$.*<.#$=,;,$=,$-.;*C,1.8,$-,17
4#*9,$-.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,7.%$=.-",.;*9%1#H%-#*$.@,$,1%-,=.(:.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7,#H'1,7.*<.;*C,1.;1*='8,.'$'7'%99:.=#78#;9#$,=.1'9#$@.
;%1-#,7?.5%1E,=.(:.5#9#-%1#H,=.7-1'8-'1,7?.7-1*$@.;%1-#7%$.#=,$-#-#,7?.
#$-,$7,.C#-"#$A@1*';.9*:%9-#,7?.%$=.%.<*'$=#$@.@,$,1%-#*$.*<.9,%=,17.
C#-".,>-1%*1=#$%1:.9,@#-#5%8:
§
)-1*$@.D'9#$@.S%1-#,7
!1,%-#*$.*<.$,C.%15#,7.*1.%.1%=#8%9.;'1@,.%$=.
1,8*$7-1'8-#*$.*<.,>#7-#$@.*$,7
®
/7'%99:.%88*5;%$#,=.(:.7-%-,.8*99%;7,?.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.,9#-,7.
<1,b',$-9:.1,5%E,.-",.7-%-,
&
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.%1,."#@"9:.;%1-#7%$.%$=.-"*1*'@"9:.
8*55#--,=.-*.-",.1,@#5,
&
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.%1,.7-1#E#$@9:.#$+'9$,1%(9,.-*.8*';7
§
0$+'9$,1%(#9#-:.-*.!*';7
)E*8;*9a.1,+*9'-#*$7.;1*='8,.;*C,1<'9.8*,18#+,.7-1'8-'1,7
§
D,+*9'-#*$7.<1,b',$-9:.-1#@@,1.,>-,1$%9.C%17?.*<-,$.C#-".$,#@"(*1#$@.
7-%-,7.C"*7,.@*+,1$5,$-7.<,,9.-"1,%-,$,=.(:.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.
1,@#5,.*1.;,18,#+,.%.C#$=*C.*<.*;;*1-'$#-:.#$.-",.C%E,.*<.7-%-,.
8*99%;7,[.)'8".,>#7-,$-#%9. -"1,%-7.81,%-,.;*C,1<'9.#$8,$-#+,7.<*1.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.@*+,1$5,$-7.-*.('#9=.';.-",.7-%-,Q7.8*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:
§
D,+*9'-#*$7.*<-,$.-1#@@,1.%.8"%#$.*<.;1*8,77,7.-"%-.8'95#$%-,.#$.
='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,.IMUK
§
0$=#+#='%9.8%7,7.+%1:?.('-.#$.5*7-.7'88,77<'9.1,+*9'-#*$7?.%15,=.
7-1'@@9,.,$@,$=,17.8*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7.-"%-?.';*$.7,#H#$@.;*C,1?.
1,8*$7-1'8-.%$=.-"*1*'@"9:.;,$,-1%-,.-",.8*,18#+,. %;;%1%-'7[.)'8".
;%1-:A%15:.<'7#*$.=1%5%-#8%99:.1,='8,7.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.5#9#-%1:.
8*';7[.
§
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7."%+,.(,,$.%5*$@.-",.5*7-.='1%(9,.%$=.
9*$@A9%7-#$@.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.#$.-",.5*=,1$.C*19=IMYK
§
KL&)%C")9/00*M&")/H)%C")?/#$"%)>+$/+),"3/+&%.*%",N)."#/01%$/+*.()
0"2*9$"&)*.")+/%)M".3*+"+%O)L0%C/12C)&/3")"0"3"+%&)/H)%C")
."#/01%$/+*.()0"2*9(N)&19C)*&)*+)$+&%$%1%$/+*0$P",).10$+2)M*.%()*+,)*)
&%./+2)*+,)0/(*0)9/".9$#")*MM*.*%1&N)3*()J")Q1$%")"+,1.$+2N)
/%C".&),"2.*,")/#".)%$3"N)M*.%$910*.0()I$%C)%C")M*&&$+2)/H)%C")
."#/01%$/+*.()2"+".*%$/+)ROOS)B",.,>-1%*1=#$%1:.8*",7#*$.-"%-.
8"%1%8-,1#H,7.5*7-.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.,1*=,7.C#-".@,$,1%-#*$%9.
-'1$*+,1[.^7.;%1-#7%$.#=,$-#-#,7.C,%E,$.%$=.#=,*9*@#8%9.
8*55#-5,$-.<%=,7?.%$=.%7.-",.'$#<:#$@.<*18,.*<.-",.<*'$=#$@.
@,$,1%-#*$.=#7%;;,%17?.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.@1%='%99:.h$*15%9#H,i.
#$-*.1'9#$@A;%1-:.h5%8"#$,7[i.^5(#-#*$.%$=.;%-1*$%@,.1,;9%8,.
#=,$-#-:.%$=.#=,*9*@:.%7.-",.;1#5%1:.@9',.(#$=#$@.-*@,-",1.1,@#5,.
,9#-,7[UJ.^7.#$.5*7-.,7-%(9#7",=.;%1-:.5%8"#$,7?.8*11';-#*$.%$=.
;,--:.<%8-#*$%9#75.@1*C.5*1,.*;,$.%$=.C#=,7;1,%=[.B"#7.
@,$,1%-#*$%9.8"%$@,."%=.89,%19:.-%E,$.;9%8,.#$.L,>#8*.%$=.-",.
)*+#,-./$#*$.(:.-",.MNOP7?.#-.*88'11,=.#$.!"#$%.%$=.4#,-$%5.#$.-",.
MNNP7?.%$=.C#99.7**$.-%E,.;9%8,.#$.!'(%[
§
W$"%$8,.!*,18#+,.!%;%8#-:
W>;9%#$#$@.D,+*9'-#*$%1:.R'1%(#9#-:F
!,$-1%9.-*.-"#7.-1%$7#-#*$.#7.-",.=,+,9*;5,$-.*<.#$7-#-'-#*$%9#H,=.
5,8"%$#757.*<.9,%=,17"#;.7'88,77#*$
§
^$*-",1.(%7#7.<*1.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,.7-%(#9#-:.#7.,8*$*5#8.
@1*C-"
§
^$.%9-,1$%-#+,.%$=.<%1.1#7E#,1.(%7#7.<*1.8*",7#*$.#7.1,$,C,=.8*$<9#8-
§
!*$-1%1:.-*.5%$:.1,8,$-.%$%9:7,7.*<.=#8-%-*17"#;?.C"#8".-1,%-.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.#$7-#-'-#*$7.%7.%.;1*='8-.*<.,9#-,.8"*#8,.*1.7-1%-,@:?Uj.
-",.#$7-#-'-#*$7.-"%-.'$=,19#,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:A1,@#5,.='1%(#9#-:\
8*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7?.-#@"-.;%1-#7%$.;,$,-1%-#*$.*<.-",.7,8'1#-:.
<*18,7?.=#78#;9#$,=.%$=.,<<,8-#+,.8*,18#+,.7-1'8-'1,7\8%$$*-.(,.
C#99,=.#$-*.,>#7-,$8,.(:.%5(#-#*'7.%'-*81%-7[.D%-",1?.7'88,77<'9.
%'-*81%-7.,#-",1.#$",1#-.7'8".#$7-#-'-#*$7.*1.7'88,,=.#$.('#9=#$@.
-",5.=',.-*.-",.,>#7-,$8,. *<.8*$=#-#*$7.I7'8".%7.7-%-,.(1,%E=*C$.
*1.;1*9*$@,=.+#*9,$-.8*$<9#8-K.*+,1.C"#8".-",:."%+,.9#5#-,=.8*$-1*9
§
L*7-.#5;*1-%$-9:?.*'1.<#$=#$@7.7'@@,7-.-"%-."%1=A9#$,.
8*$<1*$-%-#*$%9.7-1%-,@#,7\C"#8".=,,;,$.;*9%1#H%-#*$.%$=.-"'7.
1,#$<*18,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.8*",7#*$\5%:.(,.,>%8-9:.C"%-.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%$=.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.$,,=.-*.7'1+#+,[.IMJK
§
f*99*C#$@.-",.=#7%;;,%1%$8,.*<.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.@,$,1%-#*$?.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.5'7-.<#$=.%9-,1$%-#+,.(%7,7.<*1.7-%(#9#-:
),%18".<*1.)-%(#9#-:F
?%*%")M/I".)*+,)&%*($+2)M/I".6)$+H.*&%.19%1.*0)3"9C*+$&3&)*+,)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)
,1.*J$0$%():T*+)?0*%".)*+,)?/H$*)U"++".=
)-%-,7.%$=.1,@#5,7.%1,.;,1,$$#%9.:,-.9%1@,9:.;%1%99,9.*(7,77#*$.#$.;*9#-#8%9.
78#,$8,
F
G0$.-"#7.%1-#89,.C,.%#5.-*.(1#=@,.-",7,.;%1%99,9.8*$+,17%-#*$7.(:.%1@'#$@.-"%-.
7-%-,.;*C,1.#7.-",.7-1*$@,7-.#$7-#-'-#*$%9.<*'$=%-#*$.<*1.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.
7-%:#$@.;*C,1G
F
)-%-,.%;;%1%-'7,7.%1,.-:;#8%99:.#$",1#-,=.1%-",1.-"%$.*1#@#$%99:.8*$7-1'8-,=.(:.
-",.1,@#5,7.-"%-.1'$.-",5?.;%1-#8'9%19:.#$.-",.;*7-8*9*$#%9.C*19=[.^.7-1*$@.7-%-,.
#7.-",.(,7-."#7-*1#8%9.<*'$=%-#*$.<*1.%.='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,?.$*-.+#8,.
+,17%.IMOK
F
GR'1%-#*$.%9*$,.#7.$*-.-",.(,7-.5,%7'1,.*<.1,@#5,.='1%(#9#-:.7#$8,.#-.
-,997.'7.9#--9,.%(*'-.-",.7-%(#9#-:.*<.-",.1,@#5,?.*1.#-7.%(#9#-:.-*.5,,-.
%$=.*+,18*5,.;*-,$-#%9.81#7,7G
§
G-",.+,8-*1.*<.='1%-#*$.I-,5;*1%9.9,$@-"K.%$=.7-%(#9#-:.I8*$7-%$-.
*'-8*5,KG.IMjK
VC")10%$3*%")H/.3)/H)&%*J$0$%(),/"&)+/%)"+%*$0)3""%$+2)*+,)/#".9/3$+2)
9.$&"&N)J1%)*#/$,$+2)*+,N)IC"+)%C"()9*++/%)J")%/%*00()*#/$,",N)."&/0#$+2)
9.$&"&),"9$&$#"0()$+)%C")."2$3"W&)H*#/.
VC")3/&%)&%*J0")."2$3"&)*.")%C/&")%C*%)"$%C".)&%*()/1%)/H)%./1J0")/.)
C*#")*)M./#"+)%.*9')."9/.,)/H)M1%%$+2)%./1J0"&)J"C$+,)%C"3
`"%-.#7.='1%(#9#-:kF
D,8,$-.C*1E."%7.#=,$-#<#,=.-",.7-%-,.C#-".-",.1%C.7#H,.*<.-",.;'(9#8.
7,8-*1?.-",.8*,18#+,.%;;%1%-'7?.,>-1%8-#+,.%$=.9*8%9.@*+,1$5,$-.
*1@%$#H%-#*$7.%$=.-",.7;*$7*17"#;.*<.;1#+%-,A7,8-*1.@1*C-"
§
0$<1%7-1'8-'1%9.;*C,1.",9;7.1,@#5,.9,%=,17.<'9<#99.%99.E#$=7.*<.;*9#-#8%9.
-%7E7?.$*-.g'7-.-",.5%#$-,$%$8,.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,[.)'88,77<'9.
;,$,-1%-#*$.%$=.8**1=#$%-#*$.*<.7*8#,-:.-*.;'17',.;*9#-#8%9.
*(g,8-#+,7.=,;,$=7.';*$.-",.#$7-#-'-#*$%9.8*",1,$8,.%$=.,<<#8%8:.*<.
7-%-,.%@,$8#,7.-",57,9+,7.I<#@'1,.M?.;%@,.MNK
§
B"*'@".1,8,$-.9#-,1%-'1,.*$.1,@#5,7."%7.#$8*1;*1%-,=.-",.7-%-,.%7.%$.
#$<9',$8,.*$.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:?.-",1,.#7.$*.8*$7,$7'7.*$.C"%-.
8*$7-#-'-,7.G-",.7-%-,G
`"%-.#7.7-%-,.;*C,1kF
B",.8*1,.-%7E7.*<.7-%-,7."%+,.9*$@.(,,$.1,8*@$#H,=.-*.#$89'=,.-",.
5*$*;*9#H%-#*$.*<.8*,18#*$?.-",.8*99,8-#*$.*<.-%>,7?.-",.8*$='8-#$@.*<.
8,$7'7,7?.-",.;*9#8#$@.%$=.7'1+,#99%$8,.*<.+%1#*'7.G;'(9#8.,$,5#,7?G.-",.
78"**9#$@.%$=.7*8#%9#H%-#*$.*<.:*'$@.;,*;9,?.-",.;1*+#7#*$.*<.,8*$*5#8.
7%<,-:.$,-7.%$=.-",.9,@%9. %=g'=#8%-#*$.*<.=#7;'-,7
X+)/1.)#$"IN)%C")3/&%)$3M/.%*+%)3"9C*+$&3&)&1&%*$+$+2)&%*J$0$P$+2)
*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)$+)%C")7$,,0")Y*&%)%/)%C"$.)I"00ZH$+*+9",)9/".9$#")
*MM*.*%1&"&O)U/.)?%"#"+)!"#$%&'()*+,)!19*+)-*(N)&%*%")M/I".)$&)9/".9$#")
M/I".W)/%C".)&%*%")*2"+9$"&)3*%%".)/+0()$+&/H*.)*&)%C"()9*+)J"),"M0/(",)
H/.)9/".9$#")M1.M/&"&O)[+")&%.*+,)$+)%C")0$%".*%1.")/+)."+%$".)&%*%"&)
&122"&%&)%C*%)/$0ZH10",)&"91.$%()&M"+,$+2)C"0M&)H/."&%*00),"3/9.*%$P*%$/+O)
-")9/+91.)%C*%)%/)J")"HH"9%$#"N)9/".9$#")&%*%")*MM*.*%1&"&)31&%)J")I"00Z
H1+,",)*+,)*J0")%/)."M."&&)J./*,0()IC"+)%C")%$3")9/3"&
!*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:.8%$.,$"%$8,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:.,+,$.C",$.#-.#7.
1%1,9:.'7,=[.lmn.)-1*$@.8*,18#+,.#$7-#-'-#*$7.%99*C.%.1,@#5,.-*.5%E,.#-7.
-"1,%-7.%@%#$7-.*;;*$,$-7."#@"9:.81,=#(9,. %$=.;1,=#8-%(9,.IUPK
W>-1%8-#*$?.*1.%-.9,%7-.-",.<#$%$8#%9.1,7*'18,7.#-.:#,9=7?."%7.%97*.1,8,#+,=.
8*$7#=,1%(9,.%--,$-#*$.%7.%.;#99%1.*<.='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,.lmn.]#E,.
8*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:?.,>-1%8-#+,.8%;%8#-:.1,<9,8-7.$*-.*$9:.-",.-*-%9.%5*'$-.*<.
-%>,7.%.7-%-,.8*99,8-7.('-.-",.;1,8#7#*$.C#-".C"#8".#-.8*99,8-7.-",5
Y8%.*9%$/+)*+,)."2$&%.*%$/+)*.")M".C*M&)%C")%I/)3/&%)$+%".,"M"+,"+%)
M.*9%$9"&)%C./12C)IC$9C)&%*%")$+H.*&%.19%1.*0)M/I".)"+C*+9"&)
*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"),1.*J$0$%(
f#$%99:?.1,@#7-,1#$@.8#-#H,$7.#$.-",#1.,+,1:=%:.%8-#+#-#,7.<%8#9#-%-,7.
7-%$=%1=#H%.-#*$.*<.1'9,.%81*77.-",.$%-#*$%9.-,11#-*1:?.*<-,$.'$=,15#$#$@.
%'-*$*5*'7.(%7,7.*<.7*8#%9.7';;*1-.%$=.;*C,1.#$.-",.;1*8,77[.
)-%$=%1=#H,=.'$#-7.%$=.1,8*1=AE,,;#$@.;1%8-#8,7.%99*C.8,$-1%9.('1,%'81%-7.
-*.5%$%@,.%<<%#17.#$.;,1#;",1%9.%1,%7.C#-"*'-.1,9:#$@.*$.'$-1'7-,=.9*8%9.
#$-,15,=#%1#,7[.IUUK
0$<1%7-1'8-'1%9.L,8"%$#757F
^99.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7."%+,.7-%-,7?.('-.*$9:.7*5,."%+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7
W5;#1#8%99:?.-",.7-1*$@,7-.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.;%1-#,7.%1,.-"*7,.C"#8".%1,.%(9,.
-*.=1%C.*$.,>-,$7#+,.7-%-,.1,7*'18,7?.#$<*15%-#*$.%$=.;*9#8:.
#5;9,5,$-%-#*$.8%;%8#-#,7[.S%1-#,7.5%:.=#7-1#('-,.1,7*'18,7.I*1.;1*5#7,.
-*.=*.7*K.#$.,>8"%$@,.<*1.7';;*1-?.('-.-",:.1%1,9:.,>-1%8-.*1.;1*='8,.-",.
1,7*'18,7.-",:."%$=.*'-.*1.%=5#$#7-,1.-",.,8*$*5#8.;*9#8#,7.<*1.C"#8".
-",:.-%E,.81,=#-[.B",7,.%1,.-",.-%7E7.*<.7-%-,.%;;%1%-'7,7o.,<<,8-#+,.7-%-,.
,>-1%8-#*$.#7.-",.5*7-.7'7-%#$%(9,.(%7#7.<*1.;%1-:A=,9#+,1,=.;%-1*$%@,[.0$.
*-",1.C*1=7?.7-%-,7.5'7-.8'9-#+%-,.=,;,$=,$8,.(,<*1,.;%1-#,7.8%$.
5%$#;'9%-,.#-.IUYK
!"#$%&'()*+,)-*()&"")&%./+2)M*.%$"&)*+,)&%./+2)&%*%"&)9/+%.$J1%$+2)
"Q1*00()*+,)$+%".9C*+2"*J0()%/)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&W)K$+913J"+%)
9*M*9$%(OKA\)]1%)/1.)1+,".&%*+,$+2)$3M0$"&)%C*%)M"*')M*.%()&%."+2%C)$&)
/+0()*9C$"#*J0")$+)9*&"&)/H)&%./+2)&%*%")M/I".N)*+,)%C*%)%/)0*J"0)*)M*.%()
K&%./+2K)$+)%C")*J&"+9")/H)*)&%./+2)&%*%")$&)J/.,".0$+")
)-%-,7.+7[.S%1-#,7F
^99.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7."%+,.7-%-,7?.('-.-",:.=*.$*-.%99."%+,.7-%-,.
;*C,1[.`",$.%$%9:7-7.%--,5;-.-*.-1%8,."*C.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.#$7-#-'-#*$7.
7"%;,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:?.-",:.7"*'9=.(,.%7.%--,$-#+,.-*.+%1#%-#*$.#$.
7-%-,.;*C,1.%7.-",:."%+,.-:;#8%99:.(,,$.I,7;,8#%99:.1,8,$-9:K.-*.5*1,.
=,5*81%-#8A9**E#$@.#$7-#-'-#*$7.9#E,.;%1-#,7?.,9,8-#*$7.%$=.;%19#%5,$-7.IUJK
`,.7"*'9=.;,1"%;7.8*$89'=,.(:."#@"9#@"-#$@.-",.5*7-.9#(,1%-#$@.9,77*$.
*<<,1,=.(:.*'1.@'#=#$@.5,-%;"*1[.W+,$.-",.5*7-."#@"9:.=,+,9*;,=.
8*,18#+,.%$=.%=5#$#7-1%-#+,.#$7-#-'-#*$7.=*.$*-.<'$8-#*$.C#-"*'-.-",.
@'#=%$8,.%$=.,<<*1-7.*<."'5%$.%@,$-7?.g'7-.%7.,+,$.-",.5*7-.7*;"#7-#8%-,=.
%'-*5*(#9,.8%$$*-.;1*;,9.%$=.7-,,1.#-7,9<[.],%=,17"#;.,11*1.#7.%.8"1*$#8.
=,7-%(#9#H#$@.;*77#(#9#-:.#$.%99.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7[.`"%-.#7.$,,=,=.#7.%$.
%;;1*%8".-*.%'-"*1#-%1#%$#75.-"%-.#7.%--,$-#+,.(*-".-*.-",.5%8"#$,1:.*<.
-",.7-%-,.%$=.#-7.*;,1%-*17.)#$8,.-",.5%8"#$,1:.%95*7-.%9C%:7."%7.=,,;,1.
"#7-*1#8%9.1**-7.-"%$.-",.5,$.C"*.8*55%$=.#-?.<'-'1,.7-'=#,7.*<.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:.%$=.=:$%5#87.7"*'9=.%=*;-.%.5'8".=,,;,1.
"#7-*1#8%9.;,17;,8-#+,.-"%$.9,%=#$@.C*1E7."%+,.IUOK
!*$89'7#*$F
Does$Oil$Hinder$Democracy$(Michael$Ross)
)*5,.78"*9%17.#5;9:.-",1,.#7.%$.,>8,;-#*$.AA $H).$&$+2)$+9/3"&)9*+)J")
%.*9",)%/)*)9/1+%.(W&)/$0)I"*0%CN)%C"()&122"&%N)%C$&),"3/9.*%$P$+2)"HH"9%)
I$00)&C.$+')/.),$&*MM"*.
L%$:.7-'=#,7.7"*C.-"%-.C",$.#$8*5,7.1#7,?.@*+,1$5,$-7.-,$=.-*.(,8*5,.5*1,.
=,5*81%-#8
F
2#@,1#%?.0$=*$,7#%?.4,$,H',9%?.%$=.-",.*#9A1#8".7-%-,7.*<.!,$-1%9.^7#%
§
B",.89%#5.-"%-.*#9.%$=.=,5*81%8:.=*.$*.-5#>.#7.*<-,$.'7,=.(:.%1,%.
7;,8#%9#7-7.-*.,>;9%#$.C":.-",."#@"A#$8*5,.7-%-,7.*<.-",.^1%(.L#==9,.W%7-.
"%+,.$*-.(,8*5,.=,5*81%-#8
0.%97*."%+,.-C*.(1*%=,1.%#57[.B",.<#17-.#7.-*.,$8*'1%@,.78"*9%17.C"*.7-'=:.
=,5*81%8:.-*.#$8*1;*1%-,.-",.L#==9,.W%7-.#$-*.-",#1.%$%9:7,7.lmn.B",1,.#7?.
"*C,+,1?.$*.7*'$=.%$%9:-#8%9.1,%7*$.<*1.78"*9%17.*<.=,5*81%8:.-*.,>89'=,.
-",7,.7-%-,7.<1*5.-",#1.1,7,%18"?.%$=.=*#$@.7*.8%$.*$9:..C,%E,$.%$:.
@,$,1%9.<#$=#$@7[.0-.%97*.-,$=7.-*.5%1@#$%9#H,.-",.<#,9=.*<.L#==9,.W%7-.
7-'=#,7[.
L:.7,8*$=.%#5.#7.-*.%==1,77.-",.9#-,1%-'1,.*$.-",.G1,7*'18,.8'17,[G.L%$:.
*<.-",.;**1,7-.%$=.5*7-.-1*'(9,=.7-%-,7.#$.-",.=,+,9*;#$@.C*19=."%+,?.
;%1%=*>#8%99:?."#@".9,+,97.*<.$%-'1%9.1,7*'18,.C,%9-"[.B",1,.#7.%.@1*C#$@.
(*=:.*<.,+#=,$8,.-"%-.1,7*'18,.C,%9-".#-7,9<.5%:."%15.%.8*'$-1:Q7.
;1*7;,8-7.<*1.=,+,9*;5,$-
/$0)*+,)3$+".*0)I"*0%C)%"+,&)%/)3*'")&%*%"&)0"&&),"3/9.*%$9O :<^;=
Y8M0*+*%$/+F
^1,%.7;,8#%9#7-7.*<-,$.=,781#(,.5*7-.*<.-",.@*+,1$5,$-7.*<.-",.L#=,%7-.
%$=.2*1-".^<1#8%.%7.G1,$-#,1.7-%-,7?G.7#$8,.-",:.=,1#+,.%.9%1@,.<1%8-#*$.*<.
-",#1.1,+,$',7.<1*5.,-,1$%9.1,$-7[.L*1,.-"%$."%9<.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Q7.
1,+,$',7.#$.)%'=#.^1%(#%?._%"1%#$?.-",./$#-,=.^1%(.W5#1%-,7?.p5%$?.
3'C%#-?.q%-%1?.%$=.]#(:%."%+,?.%-.-#5,7?.8*5,.<1*5.-",.7%9,.*<.*#9
B",.<*1,#@$.%#=.-"%-.<9*C7.-*.071%,9?.W@:;-?.%$=.X*1=%$.5%:.%97*.(,.
8*$7#=,1,=.%.-:;,.*<.,8*$*5#8.1,$-
_,(9%C#.9%-,1. 1,<#$,=.-"#7.=,<#$#-#*$?.7'@@,7-#$@.-"%-.%.1,$-#,1.7-%-,.#7.*$,.
C",1,.-",.1,$-7.%1,.;%#=.(:.<*1,#@$.%8-*17?.C",1,.-",:.%881',.=#1,8-9:.-*.
-",.7-%-,?.%$=.C",1,.rr*$9:.%.<,C.%1,.,$@%@,=.#$.-",.@,$,1%-#*$.*<.-"#7.
1,$-.IC,%9-"K?.-",.5%g*1#-:.(,#$@.*$9:.#$+*9+,=.#$.-",.=#7-1#('-#*$.*1.
'-#9#H%-#*$.*<.#-[ZZ.IYUNK
B",.89%#5.-"%-.*#9.C,%9-".;,1.7,.#$"#(#-7.=,5*81%-#H%-#*$."%7.$*-.(,,$.
7'(g,8-,=.-*.8%1,<'9.7-%-#7-#8%9.-,7-7?."*C,+,1?.%7.5*7-.b'%$-#-%-#+,.
7-'=#,7.*<.=,5*81%8:.7#5;9:.*+,19**E.#-.%7.%$.,>;9%$%-*1:.+%1#%(9,[
B",.!*$8,;-.*<.-",.D,$-#,1.)-%-,F
B%>%-#*$.,<<,8-&
);,$=#$@.,<<,8-.&
e1*';.<*15%-#*$&
0$.@,$,1%9.-",:.%1@',.-"%-.@*+,1$5,$-7.'7,.-",#1.*#9.1,+,$',7.-*.
1,9#,+,. 7*8#%9.;1,77'1,7.-"%-.5#@"-.*-",1C#7,.9,%=.-*.=,5%$=7.<*1.
@1,%-,1.%88*'$-%(#9#-:[.!%7,.7-'=#,7.=,781#(,.-"1,,.C%:7..-"#7.5%:.
*88'1[
§
V/2"%C".)%C"()$3M0()%C*%)*)&%*%"_&)H$&9*0)M/0$9$"&)$+H01"+9")$%&)
."2$3")%(M"6)2/#".+3"+%&)%C*%)H1+,)%C"3&"0#"&)%C./12C)/$0)
."#"+1"&)*+,)C*#")0*.2".)J1,2"%&)*.")3/.")0$'"0()%/)J")
*1%C/.$%*.$*+`)2/#".+3"+%&)%C*%)H1+,)%C"3&"0#"&)%C./12C)%*8"&)
*+,)*.")."0*%$#"0()&3*00)*.")3/.")0$'"0()%/)J"9/3"),"3/9.*%$9O
§
GD,$-#,1.W<<,8-G
S'1,.7,9<A#$-,1,7-a.@#+,$.-",.*;;*1-'$#-:.-*.(,--,1.%15.#-7,9<.
%@%#$7-.;*;'9%1.;1,77'1,7?.%$.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.@*+,1$5,$-.C#99.
1,%=#9:.=*.7*
&
0<.#-."%;;,$7.-*.(,.%.8*$8,$-1%-,=.#$.%.1,@#*$.;*;'9%-,=.
(:.%$.,-"$#8.*1.1,9#@#*'7.5#$*1#-:?.1,7*'18,.,>-1%8-#*$.
5%:.;1*5*-,.*1.,>%8,1(%-,.,-"$#8.-,$7#*$7?.%7.<,=,1%9?.
1,@#*$%9?.%$=.9*8%9.%8-*17.8*5;,-,.<*1.5#$,1%9.1#@"-7.
IYYOK
®
D,7*'18,.C,%9-".8%'7,7.,-"$#8.*1.1,@#*$%9.8*$<9#8-a.%.9%1@,1.
5#9#-%1:.5#@"-.1,<9,8-.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Q7.1,7;*$7,
&
B",7,.=#7;'-,7.9,%=.-*.9%1@,1.5#9#-%1:.<*18,7.%$=.9,77.
=,5*81%8:.#$.1,7*'18,A1#8"?.,-"$#8%99:.<1%8-'1,7.7-%-,7.7'8".%7.
^$@*9%?._'15%?.-",.R,5*81%-#8.D,;'(9#8.*<.!*$@*?.0$=*$,7#%?.
2#@,1#%?.S%;'%.$,C.e'#$,%?.)#,11%.],*$,?.%$=.)*'-".^<1#8%
&
`":.8%$.1,7*'18,.C,%9-".9,%=.-*.9%1@,1.5#9#-%1:.<*18,7k
§
5"M."&&$/+)YHH"9%
=,5*81%8:.#7.8%'7,=.(:.%.8*99,8-#*$.*<.7*8#%9.%$=.8'9-'1%9.
8"%$@,7AAAA#$89'=#$@.*88';%-#*$%9.7;,8#%9#H%-#*$?.'1(%$#H%-#*$?.%$=.
"#@",1.9,+,97.*<.,='8%-#*$AAAAA-"%-.#$.-'1$.%1,.8%'7,=.(:.,8*$*5#8.
=,+,9*;5,$-[
§
B",.1,$-#,1?.1,;1,77#*$?.%$=.5*=,1$#H%-#*$.,<<,8-7.%1,.9%1@,9:.
8*5;9,5,$-%1:[.B",.1,$-#,1.,<<,8-.<*8'7,7.*$.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Z7.'7,.
*<.<#78%9.5,%7'1,7.-*.E,,;.-",.;'(9#8.;*9#-#8%99:.=,5*(#9#H,=o.-",.
1,;1,77#*$.,<<,8-.7-1,77,7.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Z7.'7,.*<.<*18,.-*.E,,;.-",.
;'(9#8.=,5*(#9#H,=o.%$=.-",.5*=,1$#H%-#*$.,<<,8-.9**E7.%-.7*8#%9.
<*18,7.-"%-.5%:.E,,;.-",.;'(9#8.=,5*(#9#H,=[.^99.-"1,,.,>;9%$%-#*$7?.
*1.%$:.8*5(#$%-#*$.*<.-",5?.5%:.(,.7#5'9-%$,*'79:.+%9#=[
§
L*=,1$#H%-#*$.W<<,8-
!%'7%9.L,8"%$#757F
B"#7.%1-#89,. "%7.<*'1.5%#$.<#$=#$@7[.f#17-?.-",.*#9A#5;,=,7A=,5*81%8:.89%#5.
#7.(*-".+%9#=.%$=.7-%-#7-#8%99:.1*('7-o.#$.*-",1.C*1=7?.*#9.=*,7."'1-.
=,5*81%8:[.L*1,*+,1?.*#9.=*,7.@1,%-,1.=%5%@,.-*.=,5*81%8:.#$.;**1.
7-%-,7.-"%$.#$.1#8".*$,7?.%$=.%.@#+,$.1#7,.#$.*#9.,>;*1-7.C#99.=*.5*1,."%15.
#$.*#9A;**1.7-%-,7.-"%$.#$.*#9A1#8".*$,7[.6,$8,?.*#9.#$"#(#-7.=,5*81%8:.,+,$.
C",$.,>;*1-7.%1,.1,9%-#+,9:.75%99?.;%1-#8'9%19:.#$.;**1.7-%-,7.IYJOK
),8*$=?.-",."%15<'9.#$<9',$8,.*<.*#9.#7.$*-.1,7-1#8-,=.-*.-",.L#==9,.W%7-[.
p#9.C,%9-"."%7.;1*(%(9:.5%=,.=,5*81%-#H%-#*$."%1=,1.#$.7-%-,7.9#E,.
0$=*$,7#%?.L%9%:7#%?.L,>#8*?.%$=.2#@,1#%o.#-.5%:.C,99."%+,.-",.7%5,.
%<<,8-.*$.-",.*#9A1#8".7-%-,7.*<.!,$-1%9.^7#%
B",.-"#1=.<#$=#$@.#7.-"%-.$*$<',9.5#$,1%9.C,%9-".%97*.#5;,=,7.
=,5*81%-#H%-#*$[.`"#9,.-",.5%g*1.*#9.,>;*1-,17.%1,.8*$8,$-1%-,=.#$.-",.
L#=,%7-?.5%g*1.5#$,1%9.,>;*1-,17.%1,.78%--,1,=.%81*77.^<1#8%?.^7#%?.%$=.
-",.^5,1#8%7o.-"#7.@1*';.#$89'=,7.5%$:.7-%-,7.C",1,.;1*@1,77.-*C%1=.
=,5*81%8:."%7.(,,$."%9-#$@.*1.,9'7#+,?.#$89'=#$@.^$@*9%?.!"#9,?.-",.
R,5*81%-#8.D,;'(9#8.*<.!*$@*?.!%5(*=#%?.%$=.S,1'
Y*9C)/H)%C"&")H$+,$+2&).1+&)9/1+%".)%/)%C")*&&13M%$/+&)/H)"*.0$".)
&9C/0*.&)%C*%)%C")*+%$,"3/9.*%$9)"HH"9%&)/H)/$0)ZZ $H)%C"()"8$&%",)ZZ I".")
."&%.$9%",)%/)%C")7$,,0")Y*&%N)%C*%)%C"()$+H01"+9",)/+0()&%*%"&)%C*%)I".")
*03/&%)IC/00(),"M"+,"+%)/+)/$0N)*+,)%C*%)%C"(),$,)+/%)"8%"+,)%/)%C")
3$+".*0Z.$9C)&%*%"&
B",.<*'1-".<#$=#$@.#7.-"%-.-",1,.#7.%-.9,%7-.-,$-%-#+,.7';;*1-.<*1.-"1,,.
8%'7%9.5,8"%$#757.-"%-.9#$E.*#9.%$=.%'-"*1#-%1#%$#75a.%.1,$-#,1.,<<,8-?.
-"1*'@".C"#8".@*+,1$5,$-7.'7,.9*C.-%>.1%-,7.%$=."#@".7;,$=#$@.-*.
=%5;,$.;1,77'1,7.<*1.=,5*81%8:o.%.1,;1,77#*$.,<<,8-?.(:.C"#8".
@*+,1$5,$-7.('#9=.';.-",#1.#$-,1$%9.7,8'1#-:.<*18,7.-*.C%1=.*<<.=,5*81%-#8.
;1,77'1,7o.%$=.%.5*=,1$#H%-#*$.,<<,8-?.#$.C"#8".-",.<%#9'1,.*<.-",.
;*;'9%-#*$.-*.5*+,.#$-*.#$='7-1#%9.%$=.7,1+#8,.7,8-*1.g*(7.1,$=,17.-",5.
9,77.9#E,9:.-*.;'7".<*1.=,5*81%8:[
f#$%99:?.-",7,.<#$=#$@7."%+,.#5;9#8%-#*$7.<*1.-",.<%-,.*<.1,7*'18,A1#8".
7-%-,7.%81*77.-",.=,+,9*;#$@.C*19=[.L%$:.*<.-",.C*19=Z7.5*7-.-1*'(9,=.
7-%-,7."%+,."#@".9,+,97.*<.*#9.%$=.5#$,1%9.C,%9-"[.W%19#,1.7-'=#,7."%+,.
7"*C$.-"%-.1,7*'18,.C,%9-".-,$=7.-*.1,='8,.,8*$*5#8.@1*C-".%$=.-*.
#$81,%7,.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.8#+#9. C%1[.B"#7.%1-#89,.7'@@,7-7.-",1,.#7.%.-"#1=.
8*5;*$,$-.-*.rr1,7*'18,.8'17,ZZa.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,[
!*$89'7#*$F
All$in$the$Family:$Absolutism,$Revolution,$and$Democracy$in$the$Middle$Eastern$
Monarchies$(7$9C*"0)a".J=
p#9.-1%$7<*15,=.-",.1'9#$@.<%5#9#,7.*<.^1%(#%.#$-*.7-%-,.,9#-,7.-"%-."%+,.
7"*C$.%$.,$*15*'7.1,7#9#,$8,[.B",.7*'18,7.*<.-"#7.1,7#9#,$8,. %1,.-*.(,.
<*'$=?.#$.-",.<#17-.#$7-%$8,.#$.-",.$%-'1,.%$=.#$-,1$%9.*1@%$#H%-#*$.*<.-",7,.
=:$%7-#,7?.%$=.$*-.#$.*-",1.8"%1%8-,1#7-#87.*<.-",.;*9#-#8%9.*1.7*8#%9.
7-1'8-'1,.*<.-",7,.5*$%18"#,7[.B",.<%5#9#,7."%+,.=,+,9*;,=.%.7-%(9,.
5,-"*=.*<.=#7-1#('-#$@.;*C,1.%5*$@.-",#1.5,5(,17.%$=."%+,.C*1E,=.*'-.
%.7-%(9,.7'88,77#*$.5,8"%$#75[.B",.=:$%7-#,7."%+,.5%#$-%#$,=.%.-#@"-.
@1#;.*$.7-%-,.;*C,1.-"1*'@".-",#1.5*$*;*9:.*<.-",.E,:.8%(#$,-.;*7-7.%$=.
-",.=#7-1#('-#*$.*<.*-",1.<%5#9:.5,5(,17.-"1*'@"*'-.-",.7-%-,.%;;%1%-'7[.
B",.1,7'9-.#7.%.1'9#$@.,9#-,. -"%-.#7.+,1:.=#<<#8'9-.-*.*+,1-"1*Ca.$*.L#==9,.
W%7-,1$.=:$%7-#8.5*$%18"#,7."%+,.<%99,$.-*.1,+*9'-#*$[.0-.#7.=:$%7-#8.
5*$%18"#75.5*1,.-"%$.*#9?.*1.-",.1*9,.*<.-",.-1#(,7?.*1.%.9%8E.*<.,='8%-#*$?.
-"%-.,>;9%#$7."*C.-",.*#9.5*$%18"7."%+,.%+*#=,=.1,+*9'-#*$[.
!"%;-,1.UaF
0-.#7.-",.%(#9#-:.*<.-",.1'9#$@.,9#-,7.*<.-",.^1%(#%$.5*$%18"#,7.-*.7*9+,.
#$-,1$%9.=#7;'-,7.C#-"*'-.-"1,%-,$#$@.-",#1.8*$-1*9.*<.-",.7-%-,.-"%-.5%E,7.
-",5.7-%(9,[.
!"%;-,1.NaF
-C*%),/)I")'+/I)*J/1%),"3/9.*%$P*%$/+)*H%".)^\)("*.&b):]*.J*.*)c",,"&=
^7.-",.-C,$-#,-".8,$-'1:.,$=7?.,9,8-,=.*<<#8#%97.@*+,1$.5*1,.8*'$-1#,7.-"%$.%-.
%$:.;1,+#*'7.-#5,.#$."'5%$."#7-*1:
F
)-1*$@.,+#=,$8,.7';;*1-7.-",.%1@'5,$-.-"%-.,8*$*5#8.=,+,9*;5,$-.
#$81,%7,7.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.=,5*81%-#8.;*9#-#87[.^+%#9%(9,.,+#=,$8,.%97*.
7';;*1-7.-",.89%#5.-"%-.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.%1,.5*1,.9#E,9:.-*.(1,%E.
=*C$.='1#$@.,8*$*5#8.81#7#7?.-"*'@".7*5,.<*157.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$#75.%1,.
5*1,.7'78,;-#(9,.-*.,8*$*5#8.=*C$-'1$7.-"%$.*-",17.IMVP
0.<*'$=.9#--9,.,+#=,$8,.#$.%.7,-.*<.MOY.-1%$7#-#*$7?."*C,+,1?.<*1.-",.89%#5.
-"%-.;%8-7.#$81,%7,.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.=,5*81%8:[.
!*$89'7#*$F
The$Politics$of$Authoritarian$Rule IL#9%$.)+*9#EK
0.%1@',.-"%-.-C*.8*$<9#8-7.<'$=%5,$-%99:.7"%;,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.;*9#-#87[.B",.<#17-.#7.
(,-C,,$.-"*7,.C"*.1'9,.%$=.-"*7,.C"*.%1,.1'9,=[.^99.=#8-%-*17.<%8,.-"1,%-7.<1*5.
-",.5%77,7?.%$=.0.8%99.-",.;*9#-#8%9.;1*(9,5.*<.(%9%$8#$@.%@%#$7-.-",.5%g*1#-:.
,>89'=,=.<1*5.;*C,1.-",.;1*(9,5.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.8*$-1*9[.s,-?.=#8-%-*17.1%1,9:.
8*$-1*9.,$*'@".1,7*'18,7.-*.;1,89'=,.7'8".8"%99,$@,7.*$.-",#1.*C$.AA -",:.
-",1,<*1,.-:;#8%99:.1'9,.C#-".%.$'5(,1.*<.%99#,7?.C",-",1.-",:.(,.-1%=#-#*$%9.
,9#-,7?.;1*5#$,$-.;%1-:.5,5(,17?.*1.@,$,1%97.#$.8"%1@,.*<.1,;1,77#*$[.^.7,8*$=?.
7,;%1%-,.;*9#-#8%9.8*$<9#8-.%1#7,7.C",$.=#8-%-*17.8*'$-,1.8"%99,$@,7.<1*5.-"*7,.
C#-".C"*5.-",:.7"%1,.;*C,1[.B"#7.#7.-",.;1*(9,5.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.;*C,1A
7"%1#$@.IUK
F
0$.(1#,<?.-",.8,$-1%9.89%#5.*<.-",.(**E.#7.-"#7a.'"()H"*%1."&)/H)*1%C/.$%*.$*+$&3)ZZ
$+901,$+2)$+&%$%1%$/+&N)M/0$9$"&N)*&)I"00)*&)%C")&1.#$#*0)/H)0"*,".&)*+,)."2$3"&)ZZ
*.")&C*M",)J()%C")%I$+)M./J0"3&)/H)M/I".Z&C*.$+2)*+,)9/+%./0)*2*$+&%)%C")
J*9',./M)/H)%C"),$&3*0)9/+,$%$/+&)1+,".)IC$9C)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)M/0$%$9&)%*'"&)
M0*9"O)VC"()"8M0*$+)IC()&/3"),$9%*%/.&N)0$'")?*,,*3)a1&&"$+N)"&%*J0$&C)
M".&/+*0)*1%/9.*9()*+,)&%*()$+)M/I".)H/.),"9*,"&`)IC()0"*,".&C$M)9C*+2"&)
"0&"IC".")*.")."210*.)*+,)$+&%$%1%$/+*0$P",N)*&)$+)9/+%"3M/.*.()BC$+*`)IC()
&/3")*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)*.").10",)J()&/0,$".&N)*&)>2*+,*)I*&)1+,".)X,$)
L3$+`)IC()3*+(),$9%*%/.&C$M&N)0$'")45XZ".*)7"8$9/N)3*$+%*$+)."2$3"Z
&*+9%$/+",)M/0$%$9*0)M*.%$"&`)*+,)IC()*)9/1+%.(W&)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)M*&%)9*&%&)*)
0/+2)&C*,/I)/#".)$%&)M./&M"9%&)H/.),"3/9.*9(O)
F
0$.=#8-%-*17"#;7?.%(*'-.*$,.-"#1=.*<.9,%=,17"#;.8"%$@,7.#$+*9+,.*+,1-.+#*9,$8,.
%$=.%(*'-.-C*A-"#1=7.*<.-",5.%1,.$*$8*$7-#-'-#*$%9.AA -",:.=,;%1-.<1*5.*<<#8#%9.
;1*8,='1,7.*1.,7-%(9#7",=.8*$+,$-#*$7
F
Week$12
L*$=%:?.^;1#9.N?.UPMT
MUaJV.SL
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-3 of the document.
Unlock all 12 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in
!"#$%&'()*+,)-*()The$Durability$of$Revolutionary$Regimes$i
!"#$%&
!'(%&
)*+#,-./$#*$&
01%$.&
2*1-".3*1,%&
4#,-$%5&
6#7-*1#8%99:."%+,.;1*+,$.-"%-.-",:.8%$.7'1+#+,.<*1.5%$:.=,8%=,7.
=,7;#-,.#$-,$7,.,>-,1$%9.;1,77'1,?.;**1.,8*$*5#8.;,1<*15%$8,?.%$=.
9%1@,A78%9,.;*9#8:.<%#9'1,7
§
B",7,.1,@#5,7."%+,.;*7,=.7,1#*'7.%$=.;,17#7-,$-.8"%99,$@,7.-*.
C,7-,1$.=,5*81%8#,7.%$=.-",#1.<*1,#@$.;*9#8:
§
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.%1,.1,5%1E%(9:.='1%(9,
The$Durability$of$Revolutionary$RegimesF
G('#9=#$@.*$.-",.C*1E.*<.)%5',9.6'$-#$@-*$.%$=.B",=%.)E*8;*9?.C,.
=,<#$,.."#/01%$/+*.()."2$3"& %7.-"*7,.C"#8".,5,1@,.*'-.*<.7'7-%#$,=?.
#=,*9*@#8%9?.%$=.+#*9,$-.7-1'@@9,.<1*5.(,9*C?.%$=.C"*7,.,7-%(9#7"5,$-.#7.
%88*5;%$#,=.(:.5%77.5*(#9#H%-#*$.%$=.7#@$#<#8%$-.,<<*1-7.-*.-1%$7<*15.
7-%-,.7-1'8-'1,7.%$=.-",.,>#7-#$@.*1=,1G.IJK
4/&%."#/1%$/+*.()5"2$3"&6)%99.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.#$.C"#8".-",.
@,$,1%-#*$.-"%-.;%1-#8#;%-,=.=#1,8-9:.#$.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7-1'@@9,."%7.=#,=.
*<<?.7'8".%7.L,>#8*.%$=.-",.)*+#,-./$#*$.%<-,1.-",.MNOPQ7
R*,7.$*-.#$89'=,.1,@#5,7.-"%-.,5,1@,.<1*5.+#*9,$-.#$=,;,$=,$8,.
7-1'@@9,7.#$.C"#8".1%=#8%9.-1%$7<*15%-#*$%9.@*%97.=*.$*-.;1,=*5#$%-,.
I0$=*$,7#%K?.8%7,7.*<.5%77A(%7,=.1,@#5,.8"%$@,.#$.C"#8".7-%-,7.%$=.7*8#%9.
7-1'8-'1,7.1,5%#$.#$-%8-.I-",.S"#9#;;#$,7.#$.MNTO?./E1%#$,.#$.UPPV?.W@:;-.#$.
UPMMK?.*1.8%7,7.*<.1%=#8%9.8"%$@,.#$#-#%-,=.(:.%8-*17.C#-"#$.-",.7-%-,.#-7,9<
7"8$9/):;<)("*.&=
>??5):@A)("*.&=
BC$+*):D<)("*.&)*+,)9/1+%$+2=
E$"%+*3):FG)("*.&)*+,)9/1+%$+2=
!/+2"&%)&1.#$#$+2)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)/H)%C")0*&%)9"+%1.()%C*%)I".")
J/.+)/1%)/H)#$/0"+%)."#/01%$/+
GB,$.*<.-",.-C,9+,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.-"%-.,>#7-,=.#$.
X%$'%1:.MNTN.7'1+#+,=.-"1*'@".UPMY?.8*5;%1,=.-*.(%1,9:.%.-"#1=.IUN.*<.
TUK.*<.-",.C*19=Z7.$*$1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7[.0$=,,=?.-",.
*$9:.8*55'$#7-.1,@#5,7.-"%-.;,17#7-,=.%<-,1.-",.8*99%;7,.*<.-",.)*+#,-.
/$#*$\!"#$%?.!'(%?.]%*7?.2*1-".3*1,%?.%$=.4#,-$%5\C,1,.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:[.]#E,C#7,?.#$.7'(A)%"%1%$.^<1#8%?.%5*$@.-",."%$=<'9.*<.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.-"%-.1,5%#$.#$-%8-.UV.:,%17.%<-,1.-",.<%99.*<.-",.
_,19#$.`%99.%1,.-"1,,.-"%-.C,1,.<*'$=,=.#$.+#*9,$-.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,7a.
^$@*9%?.L*H%5(#b',?.%$=.c#5(%(C,[.^$=.#$.-",.L#==9,.W%7-.%$=.2*1-".
^<1#8%?.-",.*$9:.$*$5*$%18"#,7.-"%-.C,1,.$*-.7,1#*'79:.8"%99,$@,=.='1#$@.
-",.^1%(.);1#$@\^9@,1#%.%$=.01%$\C,1,.(*1$.*<.+#*9,$-.7-1'@@9,[G.IOK
!"#$%Q7.!*55'$#7-.1,@#5,.7'1+#+,=.-",.MNTN.B#%$%$5,$.)b'%1,.
';1#7#$@
!'(%Q7.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,.7'1+#+,=.-",.8*99%;7,.*<.#-7.)*+#,-.
;%-1*$?.%.VPd.=,89#$,.#$.eRS?.%$=.f#=,9.!%7-1*Q7.=,;%1-'1,.<1*5.
;*C,1
2*1-".3*1,%.!*55'$#7-.1,@#5,.,$='1,=.%.5%77.<%5#$,.<*99*C#$@.
-",.)*+#,-.8*99%;7,?.%7.C,99.%7.-",.=,%-".*<.<*'$=#$@.9,%=,1.3#5.09.
)'$@
!"%99,$@,7.-*.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.#$.-",.;*7-A!*9=.`%1.;,1#*=
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.D,@#5,7F
B",.=,7-1'8-#*$.*<.#$=,;,$=,$-.;*C,1.8,$-,17
!*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7
B#@"-.;%1-#7%$.8*$-1*9.*+,1.-",.7,8'1#-:.<*18,7
S*C,1<'9.8*,18#+,.%;;%1%-'7,7
`,.%1@',.-"%-.%15,=.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,?.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7-%-,A('#9=#$@?.
%$=.-",.+#*9,$-.8*$<9#8-7.-1#@@,1,=.(:.,<<*1-7.-*.8%11:.*'-.1%=#8%9.7*8#%9.
8"%$@,.9,%+,.<*'1.9,@%8#,7. -"%-.,$"%$8,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:a.
B",7,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.9,@%8#,7. ",9;.-*.#$*8'9%-,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.
%@%#$7-.,9#-,.=,<,8-#*$?.5#9#-%1:.8*';7?.%$=.5%77.;1*-,7-.AA -"1,,.5%g*1.
7*'18,7.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.(1,%E=*C$
)-,;",$.`%9-.7"*C7.-"%-.1,+*9'-#*$7.=1%5%-#8%99:.#$81,%7,.-",.
9#E,9#"**=.*<.#$-,17-%-,.C%1
R,7-1'8-#*$.*<.#$=,;,$=,$-.;*C,1.8,$-,17
4#*9,$-.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,7.%$=.-",.;*9%1#H%-#*$.@,$,1%-,=.(:.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7,#H'1,7.*<.;*C,1.;1*='8,.'$'7'%99:.=#78#;9#$,=.1'9#$@.
;%1-#,7?.5%1E,=.(:.5#9#-%1#H,=.7-1'8-'1,7?.7-1*$@.;%1-#7%$.#=,$-#-#,7?.
#$-,$7,.C#-"#$A@1*';.9*:%9-#,7?.%$=.%.<*'$=#$@.@,$,1%-#*$.*<.9,%=,17.
C#-".,>-1%*1=#$%1:.9,@#-#5%8:
)-1*$@.D'9#$@.S%1-#,7
!1,%-#*$.*<.$,C.%15#,7.*1.%.1%=#8%9.;'1@,.%$=.
1,8*$7-1'8-#*$.*<.,>#7-#$@.*$,7
®
/7'%99:.%88*5;%$#,=.(:.7-%-,.8*99%;7,?.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.,9#-,7.
<1,b',$-9:.1,5%E,.-",.7-%-,
&
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.%1,."#@"9:.;%1-#7%$.%$=.-"*1*'@"9:.
8*55#--,=.-*.-",.1,@#5,
&
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.%1,.7-1#E#$@9:.#$+'9$,1%(9,.-*.8*';7
§
0$+'9$,1%(#9#-:.-*.!*';7
)E*8;*9a.1,+*9'-#*$7.;1*='8,.;*C,1<'9.8*,18#+,.7-1'8-'1,7
§
D,+*9'-#*$7.<1,b',$-9:.-1#@@,1.,>-,1$%9.C%17?.*<-,$.C#-".$,#@"(*1#$@.
7-%-,7.C"*7,.@*+,1$5,$-7.<,,9.-"1,%-,$,=.(:.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.
1,@#5,.*1.;,18,#+,.%.C#$=*C.*<.*;;*1-'$#-:.#$.-",.C%E,.*<.7-%-,.
8*99%;7,[.)'8".,>#7-,$-#%9. -"1,%-7.81,%-,.;*C,1<'9.#$8,$-#+,7.<*1.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.@*+,1$5,$-7.-*.('#9=.';.-",.7-%-,Q7.8*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:
§
D,+*9'-#*$7.*<-,$.-1#@@,1.%.8"%#$.*<.;1*8,77,7.-"%-.8'95#$%-,.#$.
='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,.IMUK
§
0$=#+#='%9.8%7,7.+%1:?.('-.#$.5*7-.7'88,77<'9.1,+*9'-#*$7?.%15,=.
7-1'@@9,.,$@,$=,17.8*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7.-"%-?.';*$.7,#H#$@.;*C,1?.
1,8*$7-1'8-.%$=.-"*1*'@"9:.;,$,-1%-,.-",.8*,18#+,. %;;%1%-'7[.)'8".
;%1-:A%15:.<'7#*$.=1%5%-#8%99:.1,='8,7.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.5#9#-%1:.
8*';7[.
§
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7."%+,.(,,$.%5*$@.-",.5*7-.='1%(9,.%$=.
9*$@A9%7-#$@.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.#$.-",.5*=,1$.C*19=IMYK
§
KL&)%C")9/00*M&")/H)%C")?/#$"%)>+$/+),"3/+&%.*%",N)."#/01%$/+*.()
0"2*9$"&)*.")+/%)M".3*+"+%O)L0%C/12C)&/3")"0"3"+%&)/H)%C")
."#/01%$/+*.()0"2*9(N)&19C)*&)*+)$+&%$%1%$/+*0$P",).10$+2)M*.%()*+,)*)
&%./+2)*+,)0/(*0)9/".9$#")*MM*.*%1&N)3*()J")Q1$%")"+,1.$+2N)
/%C".&),"2.*,")/#".)%$3"N)M*.%$910*.0()I$%C)%C")M*&&$+2)/H)%C")
."#/01%$/+*.()2"+".*%$/+)ROOS)B",.,>-1%*1=#$%1:.8*",7#*$.-"%-.
8"%1%8-,1#H,7.5*7-.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.,1*=,7.C#-".@,$,1%-#*$%9.
-'1$*+,1[.^7.;%1-#7%$.#=,$-#-#,7.C,%E,$.%$=.#=,*9*@#8%9.
8*55#-5,$-.<%=,7?.%$=.%7.-",.'$#<:#$@.<*18,.*<.-",.<*'$=#$@.
@,$,1%-#*$.=#7%;;,%17?.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.@1%='%99:.h$*15%9#H,i.
#$-*.1'9#$@A;%1-:.h5%8"#$,7[i.^5(#-#*$.%$=.;%-1*$%@,.1,;9%8,.
#=,$-#-:.%$=.#=,*9*@:.%7.-",.;1#5%1:.@9',.(#$=#$@.-*@,-",1.1,@#5,.
,9#-,7[UJ.^7.#$.5*7-.,7-%(9#7",=.;%1-:.5%8"#$,7?.8*11';-#*$.%$=.
;,--:.<%8-#*$%9#75.@1*C.5*1,.*;,$.%$=.C#=,7;1,%=[.B"#7.
@,$,1%-#*$%9.8"%$@,."%=.89,%19:.-%E,$.;9%8,.#$.L,>#8*.%$=.-",.
)*+#,-./$#*$.(:.-",.MNOP7?.#-.*88'11,=.#$.!"#$%.%$=.4#,-$%5.#$.-",.
MNNP7?.%$=.C#99.7**$.-%E,.;9%8,.#$.!'(%[
§
W$"%$8,.!*,18#+,.!%;%8#-:
W>;9%#$#$@.D,+*9'-#*$%1:.R'1%(#9#-:
F
!,$-1%9.-*.-"#7.-1%$7#-#*$.#7.-",.=,+,9*;5,$-.*<.#$7-#-'-#*$%9#H,=.
5,8"%$#757.*<.9,%=,17"#;.7'88,77#*$
§
^$*-",1.(%7#7.<*1.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,.7-%(#9#-:.#7.,8*$*5#8.
@1*C-"
§
^$.%9-,1$%-#+,.%$=.<%1.1#7E#,1.(%7#7.<*1.8*",7#*$.#7.1,$,C,=.8*$<9#8-
§
!*$-1%1:.-*.5%$:.1,8,$-.%$%9:7,7.*<.=#8-%-*17"#;?.C"#8".-1,%-.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.#$7-#-'-#*$7.%7.%.;1*='8-.*<.,9#-,.8"*#8,.*1.7-1%-,@:?Uj.
-",.#$7-#-'-#*$7.-"%-.'$=,19#,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:A1,@#5,.='1%(#9#-:\
8*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7?.-#@"-.;%1-#7%$.;,$,-1%-#*$.*<.-",.7,8'1#-:.
<*18,7?.=#78#;9#$,=.%$=.,<<,8-#+,.8*,18#+,.7-1'8-'1,7\8%$$*-.(,.
C#99,=.#$-*.,>#7-,$8,.(:.%5(#-#*'7.%'-*81%-7[.D%-",1?.7'88,77<'9.
%'-*81%-7.,#-",1.#$",1#-.7'8".#$7-#-'-#*$7.*1.7'88,,=.#$.('#9=#$@.
-",5.=',.-*.-",.,>#7-,$8,. *<.8*$=#-#*$7.I7'8".%7.7-%-,.(1,%E=*C$.
*1.;1*9*$@,=.+#*9,$-.8*$<9#8-K.*+,1.C"#8".-",:."%+,.9#5#-,=.8*$-1*9
§
L*7-.#5;*1-%$-9:?.*'1.<#$=#$@7.7'@@,7-.-"%-."%1=A9#$,.
8*$<1*$-%-#*$%9.7-1%-,@#,7\C"#8".=,,;,$.;*9%1#H%-#*$.%$=.-"'7.
1,#$<*18,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.8*",7#*$\5%:.(,.,>%8-9:.C"%-.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%$=.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.$,,=.-*.7'1+#+,[.IMJK
§
f*99*C#$@.-",.=#7%;;,%1%$8,.*<.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.@,$,1%-#*$?.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.5'7-.<#$=.%9-,1$%-#+,.(%7,7.<*1.7-%(#9#-:
),%18".<*1.)-%(#9#-:F
?%*%")M/I".)*+,)&%*($+2)M/I".6)$+H.*&%.19%1.*0)3"9C*+$&3&)*+,)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)
,1.*J$0$%():T*+)?0*%".)*+,)?/H$*)U"++".=
)-%-,7.%$=.1,@#5,7.%1,.;,1,$$#%9.:,-.9%1@,9:.;%1%99,9.*(7,77#*$.#$.;*9#-#8%9.
78#,$8,
F
G0$.-"#7.%1-#89,.C,.%#5.-*.(1#=@,.-",7,.;%1%99,9.8*$+,17%-#*$7.(:.%1@'#$@.-"%-.
7-%-,.;*C,1.#7.-",.7-1*$@,7-.#$7-#-'-#*$%9.<*'$=%-#*$.<*1.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.
7-%:#$@.;*C,1G
F
)-%-,.%;;%1%-'7,7.%1,.-:;#8%99:.#$",1#-,=.1%-",1.-"%$.*1#@#$%99:.8*$7-1'8-,=.(:.
-",.1,@#5,7.-"%-.1'$.-",5?.;%1-#8'9%19:.#$.-",.;*7-8*9*$#%9.C*19=[.^.7-1*$@.7-%-,.
#7.-",.(,7-."#7-*1#8%9.<*'$=%-#*$.<*1.%.='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,?.$*-.+#8,.
+,17%.IMOK
F
GR'1%-#*$.%9*$,.#7.$*-.-",.(,7-.5,%7'1,.*<.1,@#5,.='1%(#9#-:.7#$8,.#-.
-,997.'7.9#--9,.%(*'-.-",.7-%(#9#-:.*<.-",.1,@#5,?.*1.#-7.%(#9#-:.-*.5,,-.
%$=.*+,18*5,.;*-,$-#%9.81#7,7G
§
G-",.+,8-*1.*<.='1%-#*$.I-,5;*1%9.9,$@-"K.%$=.7-%(#9#-:.I8*$7-%$-.
*'-8*5,KG.IMjK
VC")10%$3*%")H/.3)/H)&%*J$0$%(),/"&)+/%)"+%*$0)3""%$+2)*+,)/#".9/3$+2)
9.$&"&N)J1%)*#/$,$+2)*+,N)IC"+)%C"()9*++/%)J")%/%*00()*#/$,",N)."&/0#$+2)
9.$&"&),"9$&$#"0()$+)%C")."2$3"W&)H*#/.
VC")3/&%)&%*J0")."2$3"&)*.")%C/&")%C*%)"$%C".)&%*()/1%)/H)%./1J0")/.)
C*#")*)M./#"+)%.*9')."9/.,)/H)M1%%$+2)%./1J0"&)J"C$+,)%C"3
`"%-.#7.='1%(#9#-:kF
D,8,$-.C*1E."%7.#=,$-#<#,=.-",.7-%-,.C#-".-",.1%C.7#H,.*<.-",.;'(9#8.
7,8-*1?.-",.8*,18#+,.%;;%1%-'7?.,>-1%8-#+,.%$=.9*8%9.@*+,1$5,$-.
*1@%$#H%-#*$7.%$=.-",.7;*$7*17"#;.*<.;1#+%-,A7,8-*1.@1*C-"
§
0$<1%7-1'8-'1%9.;*C,1.",9;7.1,@#5,.9,%=,17.<'9<#99.%99.E#$=7.*<.;*9#-#8%9.
-%7E7?.$*-.g'7-.-",.5%#$-,$%$8,.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,[.)'88,77<'9.
;,$,-1%-#*$.%$=.8**1=#$%-#*$.*<.7*8#,-:.-*.;'17',.;*9#-#8%9.
*(g,8-#+,7.=,;,$=7.';*$.-",.#$7-#-'-#*$%9.8*",1,$8,.%$=.,<<#8%8:.*<.
7-%-,.%@,$8#,7.-",57,9+,7.I<#@'1,.M?.;%@,.MNK
§
B"*'@".1,8,$-.9#-,1%-'1,.*$.1,@#5,7."%7.#$8*1;*1%-,=.-",.7-%-,.%7.%$.
#$<9',$8,.*$.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:?.-",1,.#7.$*.8*$7,$7'7.*$.C"%-.
8*$7-#-'-,7.G-",.7-%-,G
`"%-.#7.7-%-,.;*C,1kF
B",.8*1,.-%7E7.*<.7-%-,7."%+,.9*$@.(,,$.1,8*@$#H,=.-*.#$89'=,.-",.
5*$*;*9#H%-#*$.*<.8*,18#*$?.-",.8*99,8-#*$.*<.-%>,7?.-",.8*$='8-#$@.*<.
8,$7'7,7?.-",.;*9#8#$@.%$=.7'1+,#99%$8,.*<.+%1#*'7.G;'(9#8.,$,5#,7?G.-",.
78"**9#$@.%$=.7*8#%9#H%-#*$.*<.:*'$@.;,*;9,?.-",.;1*+#7#*$.*<.,8*$*5#8.
7%<,-:.$,-7.%$=.-",.9,@%9. %=g'=#8%-#*$.*<.=#7;'-,7
X+)/1.)#$"IN)%C")3/&%)$3M/.%*+%)3"9C*+$&3&)&1&%*$+$+2)&%*J$0$P$+2)
*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)$+)%C")7$,,0")Y*&%)%/)%C"$.)I"00ZH$+*+9",)9/".9$#")
*MM*.*%1&"&O)U/.)?%"#"+)!"#$%&'()*+,)!19*+)-*(N)&%*%")M/I".)$&)9/".9$#")
M/I".W)/%C".)&%*%")*2"+9$"&)3*%%".)/+0()$+&/H*.)*&)%C"()9*+)J"),"M0/(",)
H/.)9/".9$#")M1.M/&"&O)[+")&%.*+,)$+)%C")0$%".*%1.")/+)."+%$".)&%*%"&)
&122"&%&)%C*%)/$0ZH10",)&"91.$%()&M"+,$+2)C"0M&)H/."&%*00),"3/9.*%$P*%$/+O)
-")9/+91.)%C*%)%/)J")"HH"9%$#"N)9/".9$#")&%*%")*MM*.*%1&"&)31&%)J")I"00Z
H1+,",)*+,)*J0")%/)."M."&&)J./*,0()IC"+)%C")%$3")9/3"&
!*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:.8%$.,$"%$8,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:.,+,$.C",$.#-.#7.
1%1,9:.'7,=[.lmn.)-1*$@.8*,18#+,.#$7-#-'-#*$7.%99*C.%.1,@#5,.-*.5%E,.#-7.
-"1,%-7.%@%#$7-.*;;*$,$-7."#@"9:.81,=#(9,. %$=.;1,=#8-%(9,.IUPK
W>-1%8-#*$?.*1.%-.9,%7-.-",.<#$%$8#%9.1,7*'18,7.#-.:#,9=7?."%7.%97*.1,8,#+,=.
8*$7#=,1%(9,.%--,$-#*$.%7.%.;#99%1.*<.='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,.lmn.]#E,.
8*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:?.,>-1%8-#+,.8%;%8#-:.1,<9,8-7.$*-.*$9:.-",.-*-%9.%5*'$-.*<.
-%>,7.%.7-%-,.8*99,8-7.('-.-",.;1,8#7#*$.C#-".C"#8".#-.8*99,8-7.-",5
Y8%.*9%$/+)*+,)."2$&%.*%$/+)*.")M".C*M&)%C")%I/)3/&%)$+%".,"M"+,"+%)
M.*9%$9"&)%C./12C)IC$9C)&%*%")$+H.*&%.19%1.*0)M/I".)"+C*+9"&)
*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"),1.*J$0$%(
f#$%99:?.1,@#7-,1#$@.8#-#H,$7.#$.-",#1.,+,1:=%:.%8-#+#-#,7.<%8#9#-%-,7.
7-%$=%1=#H%.-#*$.*<.1'9,.%81*77.-",.$%-#*$%9.-,11#-*1:?.*<-,$.'$=,15#$#$@.
%'-*$*5*'7.(%7,7.*<.7*8#%9.7';;*1-.%$=.;*C,1.#$.-",.;1*8,77[.
)-%$=%1=#H,=.'$#-7.%$=.1,8*1=AE,,;#$@.;1%8-#8,7.%99*C.8,$-1%9.('1,%'81%-7.
-*.5%$%@,.%<<%#17.#$.;,1#;",1%9.%1,%7.C#-"*'-.1,9:#$@.*$.'$-1'7-,=.9*8%9.
#$-,15,=#%1#,7[.IUUK
0$<1%7-1'8-'1%9.L,8"%$#757F
^99.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7."%+,.7-%-,7?.('-.*$9:.7*5,."%+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7
W5;#1#8%99:?.-",.7-1*$@,7-.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.;%1-#,7.%1,.-"*7,.C"#8".%1,.%(9,.
-*.=1%C.*$.,>-,$7#+,.7-%-,.1,7*'18,7?.#$<*15%-#*$.%$=.;*9#8:.
#5;9,5,$-%-#*$.8%;%8#-#,7[.S%1-#,7.5%:.=#7-1#('-,.1,7*'18,7.I*1.;1*5#7,.
-*.=*.7*K.#$.,>8"%$@,.<*1.7';;*1-?.('-.-",:.1%1,9:.,>-1%8-.*1.;1*='8,.-",.
1,7*'18,7.-",:."%$=.*'-.*1.%=5#$#7-,1.-",.,8*$*5#8.;*9#8#,7.<*1.C"#8".
-",:.-%E,.81,=#-[.B",7,.%1,.-",.-%7E7.*<.7-%-,.%;;%1%-'7,7o.,<<,8-#+,.7-%-,.
,>-1%8-#*$.#7.-",.5*7-.7'7-%#$%(9,.(%7#7.<*1.;%1-:A=,9#+,1,=.;%-1*$%@,[.0$.
*-",1.C*1=7?.7-%-,7.5'7-.8'9-#+%-,.=,;,$=,$8,.(,<*1,.;%1-#,7.8%$.
5%$#;'9%-,.#-.IUYK
!"#$%&'()*+,)-*()&"")&%./+2)M*.%$"&)*+,)&%./+2)&%*%"&)9/+%.$J1%$+2)
"Q1*00()*+,)$+%".9C*+2"*J0()%/)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&W)K$+913J"+%)
9*M*9$%(OKA\)]1%)/1.)1+,".&%*+,$+2)$3M0$"&)%C*%)M"*')M*.%()&%."+2%C)$&)
/+0()*9C$"#*J0")$+)9*&"&)/H)&%./+2)&%*%")M/I".N)*+,)%C*%)%/)0*J"0)*)M*.%()
K&%./+2K)$+)%C")*J&"+9")/H)*)&%./+2)&%*%")$&)J/.,".0$+")
)-%-,7.+7[.S%1-#,7F
^99.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7."%+,.7-%-,7?.('-.-",:.=*.$*-.%99."%+,.7-%-,.
;*C,1[.`",$.%$%9:7-7.%--,5;-.-*.-1%8,."*C.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.#$7-#-'-#*$7.
7"%;,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:?.-",:.7"*'9=.(,.%7.%--,$-#+,.-*.+%1#%-#*$.#$.
7-%-,.;*C,1.%7.-",:."%+,.-:;#8%99:.(,,$.I,7;,8#%99:.1,8,$-9:K.-*.5*1,.
=,5*81%-#8A9**E#$@.#$7-#-'-#*$7.9#E,.;%1-#,7?.,9,8-#*$7.%$=.;%19#%5,$-7.IUJK
`,.7"*'9=.;,1"%;7.8*$89'=,.(:."#@"9#@"-#$@.-",.5*7-.9#(,1%-#$@.9,77*$.
*<<,1,=.(:.*'1.@'#=#$@.5,-%;"*1[.W+,$.-",.5*7-."#@"9:.=,+,9*;,=.
8*,18#+,.%$=.%=5#$#7-1%-#+,.#$7-#-'-#*$7.=*.$*-.<'$8-#*$.C#-"*'-.-",.
@'#=%$8,.%$=.,<<*1-7.*<."'5%$.%@,$-7?.g'7-.%7.,+,$.-",.5*7-.7*;"#7-#8%-,=.
%'-*5*(#9,.8%$$*-.;1*;,9.%$=.7-,,1.#-7,9<[.],%=,17"#;.,11*1.#7.%.8"1*$#8.
=,7-%(#9#H#$@.;*77#(#9#-:.#$.%99.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7[.`"%-.#7.$,,=,=.#7.%$.
%;;1*%8".-*.%'-"*1#-%1#%$#75.-"%-.#7.%--,$-#+,.(*-".-*.-",.5%8"#$,1:.*<.
-",.7-%-,.%$=.#-7.*;,1%-*17.)#$8,.-",.5%8"#$,1:.%95*7-.%9C%:7."%7.=,,;,1.
"#7-*1#8%9.1**-7.-"%$.-",.5,$.C"*.8*55%$=.#-?.<'-'1,.7-'=#,7.*<.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:.%$=.=:$%5#87.7"*'9=.%=*;-.%.5'8".=,,;,1.
"#7-*1#8%9.;,17;,8-#+,.-"%$.9,%=#$@.C*1E7."%+,.IUOK
!*$89'7#*$F
Does$Oil$Hinder$Democracy$(Michael$Ross)
)*5,.78"*9%17.#5;9:.-",1,.#7.%$.,>8,;-#*$.AA $H).$&$+2)$+9/3"&)9*+)J")
%.*9",)%/)*)9/1+%.(W&)/$0)I"*0%CN)%C"()&122"&%N)%C$&),"3/9.*%$P$+2)"HH"9%)
I$00)&C.$+')/.),$&*MM"*.
L%$:.7-'=#,7.7"*C.-"%-.C",$.#$8*5,7.1#7,?.@*+,1$5,$-7.-,$=.-*.(,8*5,.5*1,.
=,5*81%-#8
F
2#@,1#%?.0$=*$,7#%?.4,$,H',9%?.%$=.-",.*#9A1#8".7-%-,7.*<.!,$-1%9.^7#%
§
B",.89%#5.-"%-.*#9.%$=.=,5*81%8:.=*.$*.-5#>.#7.*<-,$.'7,=.(:.%1,%.
7;,8#%9#7-7.-*.,>;9%#$.C":.-",."#@"A#$8*5,.7-%-,7.*<.-",.^1%(.L#==9,.W%7-.
"%+,.$*-.(,8*5,.=,5*81%-#8
0.%97*."%+,.-C*.(1*%=,1.%#57[.B",.<#17-.#7.-*.,$8*'1%@,.78"*9%17.C"*.7-'=:.
=,5*81%8:.-*.#$8*1;*1%-,.-",.L#==9,.W%7-.#$-*.-",#1.%$%9:7,7.lmn.B",1,.#7?.
"*C,+,1?.$*.7*'$=.%$%9:-#8%9.1,%7*$.<*1.78"*9%17.*<.=,5*81%8:.-*.,>89'=,.
-",7,.7-%-,7.<1*5.-",#1.1,7,%18"?.%$=.=*#$@.7*.8%$.*$9:..C,%E,$.%$:.
@,$,1%9.<#$=#$@7[.0-.%97*.-,$=7.-*.5%1@#$%9#H,.-",.<#,9=.*<.L#==9,.W%7-.
7-'=#,7[.
L:.7,8*$=.%#5.#7.-*.%==1,77.-",.9#-,1%-'1,.*$.-",.G1,7*'18,.8'17,[G.L%$:.
*<.-",.;**1,7-.%$=.5*7-.-1*'(9,=.7-%-,7.#$.-",.=,+,9*;#$@.C*19=."%+,?.
;%1%=*>#8%99:?."#@".9,+,97.*<.$%-'1%9.1,7*'18,.C,%9-"[.B",1,.#7.%.@1*C#$@.
(*=:.*<.,+#=,$8,.-"%-.1,7*'18,.C,%9-".#-7,9<.5%:."%15.%.8*'$-1:Q7.
;1*7;,8-7.<*1.=,+,9*;5,$-
/$0)*+,)3$+".*0)I"*0%C)%"+,&)%/)3*'")&%*%"&)0"&&),"3/9.*%$9O :<^;=
Y8M0*+*%$/+F
^1,%.7;,8#%9#7-7.*<-,$.=,781#(,.5*7-.*<.-",.@*+,1$5,$-7.*<.-",.L#=,%7-.
%$=.2*1-".^<1#8%.%7.G1,$-#,1.7-%-,7?G.7#$8,.-",:.=,1#+,.%.9%1@,.<1%8-#*$.*<.
-",#1.1,+,$',7.<1*5.,-,1$%9.1,$-7[.L*1,.-"%$."%9<.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Q7.
1,+,$',7.#$.)%'=#.^1%(#%?._%"1%#$?.-",./$#-,=.^1%(.W5#1%-,7?.p5%$?.
3'C%#-?.q%-%1?.%$=.]#(:%."%+,?.%-.-#5,7?.8*5,.<1*5.-",.7%9,.*<.*#9
B",.<*1,#@$.%#=.-"%-.<9*C7.-*.071%,9?.W@:;-?.%$=.X*1=%$.5%:.%97*.(,.
8*$7#=,1,=.%.-:;,.*<.,8*$*5#8.1,$-
_,(9%C#.9%-,1. 1,<#$,=.-"#7.=,<#$#-#*$?.7'@@,7-#$@.-"%-.%.1,$-#,1.7-%-,.#7.*$,.
C",1,.-",.1,$-7.%1,.;%#=.(:.<*1,#@$.%8-*17?.C",1,.-",:.%881',.=#1,8-9:.-*.
-",.7-%-,?.%$=.C",1,.rr*$9:.%.<,C.%1,.,$@%@,=.#$.-",.@,$,1%-#*$.*<.-"#7.
1,$-.IC,%9-"K?.-",.5%g*1#-:.(,#$@.*$9:.#$+*9+,=.#$.-",.=#7-1#('-#*$.*1.
'-#9#H%-#*$.*<.#-[ZZ.IYUNK
B",.89%#5.-"%-.*#9.C,%9-".;,1.7,.#$"#(#-7.=,5*81%-#H%-#*$."%7.$*-.(,,$.
7'(g,8-,=.-*.8%1,<'9.7-%-#7-#8%9.-,7-7?."*C,+,1?.%7.5*7-.b'%$-#-%-#+,.
7-'=#,7.*<.=,5*81%8:.7#5;9:.*+,19**E.#-.%7.%$.,>;9%$%-*1:.+%1#%(9,[
B",.!*$8,;-.*<.-",.D,$-#,1.)-%-,F
B%>%-#*$.,<<,8-&
);,$=#$@.,<<,8-.&
e1*';.<*15%-#*$&
0$.@,$,1%9.-",:.%1@',.-"%-.@*+,1$5,$-7.'7,.-",#1.*#9.1,+,$',7.-*.
1,9#,+,. 7*8#%9.;1,77'1,7.-"%-.5#@"-.*-",1C#7,.9,%=.-*.=,5%$=7.<*1.
@1,%-,1.%88*'$-%(#9#-:[.!%7,.7-'=#,7.=,781#(,.-"1,,.C%:7..-"#7.5%:.
*88'1[
§
V/2"%C".)%C"()$3M0()%C*%)*)&%*%"_&)H$&9*0)M/0$9$"&)$+H01"+9")$%&)
."2$3")%(M"6)2/#".+3"+%&)%C*%)H1+,)%C"3&"0#"&)%C./12C)/$0)
."#"+1"&)*+,)C*#")0*.2".)J1,2"%&)*.")3/.")0$'"0()%/)J")
*1%C/.$%*.$*+`)2/#".+3"+%&)%C*%)H1+,)%C"3&"0#"&)%C./12C)%*8"&)
*+,)*.")."0*%$#"0()&3*00)*.")3/.")0$'"0()%/)J"9/3"),"3/9.*%$9O
§
GD,$-#,1.W<<,8-G
S'1,.7,9<A#$-,1,7-a.@#+,$.-",.*;;*1-'$#-:.-*.(,--,1.%15.#-7,9<.
%@%#$7-.;*;'9%1.;1,77'1,7?.%$.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.@*+,1$5,$-.C#99.
1,%=#9:.=*.7*
&
0<.#-."%;;,$7.-*.(,.%.8*$8,$-1%-,=.#$.%.1,@#*$.;*;'9%-,=.
(:.%$.,-"$#8.*1.1,9#@#*'7.5#$*1#-:?.1,7*'18,.,>-1%8-#*$.
5%:.;1*5*-,.*1.,>%8,1(%-,.,-"$#8.-,$7#*$7?.%7.<,=,1%9?.
1,@#*$%9?.%$=.9*8%9.%8-*17.8*5;,-,.<*1.5#$,1%9.1#@"-7.
IYYOK
®
D,7*'18,.C,%9-".8%'7,7.,-"$#8.*1.1,@#*$%9.8*$<9#8-a.%.9%1@,1.
5#9#-%1:.5#@"-.1,<9,8-.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Q7.1,7;*$7,
&
B",7,.=#7;'-,7.9,%=.-*.9%1@,1.5#9#-%1:.<*18,7.%$=.9,77.
=,5*81%8:.#$.1,7*'18,A1#8"?.,-"$#8%99:.<1%8-'1,7.7-%-,7.7'8".%7.
^$@*9%?._'15%?.-",.R,5*81%-#8.D,;'(9#8.*<.!*$@*?.0$=*$,7#%?.
2#@,1#%?.S%;'%.$,C.e'#$,%?.)#,11%.],*$,?.%$=.)*'-".^<1#8%
&
`":.8%$.1,7*'18,.C,%9-".9,%=.-*.9%1@,1.5#9#-%1:.<*18,7k
§
5"M."&&$/+)YHH"9%
=,5*81%8:.#7.8%'7,=.(:.%.8*99,8-#*$.*<.7*8#%9.%$=.8'9-'1%9.
8"%$@,7AAAA#$89'=#$@.*88';%-#*$%9.7;,8#%9#H%-#*$?.'1(%$#H%-#*$?.%$=.
"#@",1.9,+,97.*<.,='8%-#*$AAAAA-"%-.#$.-'1$.%1,.8%'7,=.(:.,8*$*5#8.
=,+,9*;5,$-[
§
B",.1,$-#,1?.1,;1,77#*$?.%$=.5*=,1$#H%-#*$.,<<,8-7.%1,.9%1@,9:.
8*5;9,5,$-%1:[.B",.1,$-#,1.,<<,8-.<*8'7,7.*$.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Z7.'7,.
*<.<#78%9.5,%7'1,7.-*.E,,;.-",.;'(9#8.;*9#-#8%99:.=,5*(#9#H,=o.-",.
1,;1,77#*$.,<<,8-.7-1,77,7.-",.@*+,1$5,$-Z7.'7,.*<.<*18,.-*.E,,;.-",.
;'(9#8.=,5*(#9#H,=o.%$=.-",.5*=,1$#H%-#*$.,<<,8-.9**E7.%-.7*8#%9.
<*18,7.-"%-.5%:.E,,;.-",.;'(9#8.=,5*(#9#H,=[.^99.-"1,,.,>;9%$%-#*$7?.
*1.%$:.8*5(#$%-#*$.*<.-",5?.5%:.(,.7#5'9-%$,*'79:.+%9#=[
§
L*=,1$#H%-#*$.W<<,8-
!%'7%9.L,8"%$#757F
B"#7.%1-#89,. "%7.<*'1.5%#$.<#$=#$@7[.f#17-?.-",.*#9A#5;,=,7A=,5*81%8:.89%#5.
#7.(*-".+%9#=.%$=.7-%-#7-#8%99:.1*('7-o.#$.*-",1.C*1=7?.*#9.=*,7."'1-.
=,5*81%8:[.L*1,*+,1?.*#9.=*,7.@1,%-,1.=%5%@,.-*.=,5*81%8:.#$.;**1.
7-%-,7.-"%$.#$.1#8".*$,7?.%$=.%.@#+,$.1#7,.#$.*#9.,>;*1-7.C#99.=*.5*1,."%15.
#$.*#9A;**1.7-%-,7.-"%$.#$.*#9A1#8".*$,7[.6,$8,?.*#9.#$"#(#-7.=,5*81%8:.,+,$.
C",$.,>;*1-7.%1,.1,9%-#+,9:.75%99?.;%1-#8'9%19:.#$.;**1.7-%-,7.IYJOK
),8*$=?.-",."%15<'9.#$<9',$8,.*<.*#9.#7.$*-.1,7-1#8-,=.-*.-",.L#==9,.W%7-[.
p#9.C,%9-"."%7.;1*(%(9:.5%=,.=,5*81%-#H%-#*$."%1=,1.#$.7-%-,7.9#E,.
0$=*$,7#%?.L%9%:7#%?.L,>#8*?.%$=.2#@,1#%o.#-.5%:.C,99."%+,.-",.7%5,.
%<<,8-.*$.-",.*#9A1#8".7-%-,7.*<.!,$-1%9.^7#%
B",.-"#1=.<#$=#$@.#7.-"%-.$*$<',9.5#$,1%9.C,%9-".%97*.#5;,=,7.
=,5*81%-#H%-#*$[.`"#9,.-",.5%g*1.*#9.,>;*1-,17.%1,.8*$8,$-1%-,=.#$.-",.
L#=,%7-?.5%g*1.5#$,1%9.,>;*1-,17.%1,.78%--,1,=.%81*77.^<1#8%?.^7#%?.%$=.
-",.^5,1#8%7o.-"#7.@1*';.#$89'=,7.5%$:.7-%-,7.C",1,.;1*@1,77.-*C%1=.
=,5*81%8:."%7.(,,$."%9-#$@.*1.,9'7#+,?.#$89'=#$@.^$@*9%?.!"#9,?.-",.
R,5*81%-#8.D,;'(9#8.*<.!*$@*?.!%5(*=#%?.%$=.S,1'
Y*9C)/H)%C"&")H$+,$+2&).1+&)9/1+%".)%/)%C")*&&13M%$/+&)/H)"*.0$".)
&9C/0*.&)%C*%)%C")*+%$,"3/9.*%$9)"HH"9%&)/H)/$0)ZZ $H)%C"()"8$&%",)ZZ I".")
."&%.$9%",)%/)%C")7$,,0")Y*&%N)%C*%)%C"()$+H01"+9",)/+0()&%*%"&)%C*%)I".")
*03/&%)IC/00(),"M"+,"+%)/+)/$0N)*+,)%C*%)%C"(),$,)+/%)"8%"+,)%/)%C")
3$+".*0Z.$9C)&%*%"&
B",.<*'1-".<#$=#$@.#7.-"%-.-",1,.#7.%-.9,%7-.-,$-%-#+,.7';;*1-.<*1.-"1,,.
8%'7%9.5,8"%$#757.-"%-.9#$E.*#9.%$=.%'-"*1#-%1#%$#75a.%.1,$-#,1.,<<,8-?.
-"1*'@".C"#8".@*+,1$5,$-7.'7,.9*C.-%>.1%-,7.%$=."#@".7;,$=#$@.-*.
=%5;,$.;1,77'1,7.<*1.=,5*81%8:o.%.1,;1,77#*$.,<<,8-?.(:.C"#8".
@*+,1$5,$-7.('#9=.';.-",#1.#$-,1$%9.7,8'1#-:.<*18,7.-*.C%1=.*<<.=,5*81%-#8.
;1,77'1,7o.%$=.%.5*=,1$#H%-#*$.,<<,8-?.#$.C"#8".-",.<%#9'1,.*<.-",.
;*;'9%-#*$.-*.5*+,.#$-*.#$='7-1#%9.%$=.7,1+#8,.7,8-*1.g*(7.1,$=,17.-",5.
9,77.9#E,9:.-*.;'7".<*1.=,5*81%8:[
f#$%99:?.-",7,.<#$=#$@7."%+,.#5;9#8%-#*$7.<*1.-",.<%-,.*<.1,7*'18,A1#8".
7-%-,7.%81*77.-",.=,+,9*;#$@.C*19=[.L%$:.*<.-",.C*19=Z7.5*7-.-1*'(9,=.
7-%-,7."%+,."#@".9,+,97.*<.*#9.%$=.5#$,1%9.C,%9-"[.W%19#,1.7-'=#,7."%+,.
7"*C$.-"%-.1,7*'18,.C,%9-".-,$=7.-*.1,='8,.,8*$*5#8.@1*C-".%$=.-*.
#$81,%7,.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.8#+#9. C%1[.B"#7.%1-#89,.7'@@,7-7.-",1,.#7.%.-"#1=.
8*5;*$,$-.-*.rr1,7*'18,.8'17,ZZa.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,[
!*$89'7#*$F
All$in$the$Family:$Absolutism,$Revolution,$and$Democracy$in$the$Middle$Eastern$
Monarchies$(7$9C*"0)a".J=
p#9.-1%$7<*15,=.-",.1'9#$@.<%5#9#,7.*<.^1%(#%.#$-*.7-%-,.,9#-,7.-"%-."%+,.
7"*C$.%$.,$*15*'7.1,7#9#,$8,[.B",.7*'18,7.*<.-"#7.1,7#9#,$8,. %1,.-*.(,.
<*'$=?.#$.-",.<#17-.#$7-%$8,.#$.-",.$%-'1,.%$=.#$-,1$%9.*1@%$#H%-#*$.*<.-",7,.
=:$%7-#,7?.%$=.$*-.#$.*-",1.8"%1%8-,1#7-#87.*<.-",.;*9#-#8%9.*1.7*8#%9.
7-1'8-'1,.*<.-",7,.5*$%18"#,7[.B",.<%5#9#,7."%+,.=,+,9*;,=.%.7-%(9,.
5,-"*=.*<.=#7-1#('-#$@.;*C,1.%5*$@.-",#1.5,5(,17.%$=."%+,.C*1E,=.*'-.
%.7-%(9,.7'88,77#*$.5,8"%$#75[.B",.=:$%7-#,7."%+,.5%#$-%#$,=.%.-#@"-.
@1#;.*$.7-%-,.;*C,1.-"1*'@".-",#1.5*$*;*9:.*<.-",.E,:.8%(#$,-.;*7-7.%$=.
-",.=#7-1#('-#*$.*<.*-",1.<%5#9:.5,5(,17.-"1*'@"*'-.-",.7-%-,.%;;%1%-'7[.
B",.1,7'9-.#7.%.1'9#$@.,9#-,. -"%-.#7.+,1:.=#<<#8'9-.-*.*+,1-"1*Ca.$*.L#==9,.
W%7-,1$.=:$%7-#8.5*$%18"#,7."%+,.<%99,$.-*.1,+*9'-#*$[.0-.#7.=:$%7-#8.
5*$%18"#75.5*1,.-"%$.*#9?.*1.-",.1*9,.*<.-",.-1#(,7?.*1.%.9%8E.*<.,='8%-#*$?.
-"%-.,>;9%#$7."*C.-",.*#9.5*$%18"7."%+,.%+*#=,=.1,+*9'-#*$[.
!"%;-,1.UaF
0-.#7.-",.%(#9#-:.*<.-",.1'9#$@.,9#-,7.*<.-",.^1%(#%$.5*$%18"#,7.-*.7*9+,.
#$-,1$%9.=#7;'-,7.C#-"*'-.-"1,%-,$#$@.-",#1.8*$-1*9.*<.-",.7-%-,.-"%-.5%E,7.
-",5.7-%(9,[.
!"%;-,1.NaF
-C*%),/)I")'+/I)*J/1%),"3/9.*%$P*%$/+)*H%".)^\)("*.&b):]*.J*.*)c",,"&=
^7.-",.-C,$-#,-".8,$-'1:.,$=7?.,9,8-,=.*<<#8#%97.@*+,1$.5*1,.8*'$-1#,7.-"%$.%-.
%$:.;1,+#*'7.-#5,.#$."'5%$."#7-*1:
F
)-1*$@.,+#=,$8,.7';;*1-7.-",.%1@'5,$-.-"%-.,8*$*5#8.=,+,9*;5,$-.
#$81,%7,7.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.=,5*81%-#8.;*9#-#87[.^+%#9%(9,.,+#=,$8,.%97*.
7';;*1-7.-",.89%#5.-"%-.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.%1,.5*1,.9#E,9:.-*.(1,%E.
=*C$.='1#$@.,8*$*5#8.81#7#7?.-"*'@".7*5,.<*157.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$#75.%1,.
5*1,.7'78,;-#(9,.-*.,8*$*5#8.=*C$-'1$7.-"%$.*-",17.IMVP
0.<*'$=.9#--9,.,+#=,$8,.#$.%.7,-.*<.MOY.-1%$7#-#*$7?."*C,+,1?.<*1.-",.89%#5.
-"%-.;%8-7.#$81,%7,.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.=,5*81%8:[.
!*$89'7#*$F
The$Politics$of$Authoritarian$Rule IL#9%$.)+*9#EK
0.%1@',.-"%-.-C*.8*$<9#8-7.<'$=%5,$-%99:.7"%;,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.;*9#-#87[.B",.<#17-.#7.
(,-C,,$.-"*7,.C"*.1'9,.%$=.-"*7,.C"*.%1,.1'9,=[.^99.=#8-%-*17.<%8,.-"1,%-7.<1*5.
-",.5%77,7?.%$=.0.8%99.-",.;*9#-#8%9.;1*(9,5.*<.(%9%$8#$@.%@%#$7-.-",.5%g*1#-:.
,>89'=,=.<1*5.;*C,1.-",.;1*(9,5.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.8*$-1*9[.s,-?.=#8-%-*17.1%1,9:.
8*$-1*9.,$*'@".1,7*'18,7.-*.;1,89'=,.7'8".8"%99,$@,7.*$.-",#1.*C$.AA -",:.
-",1,<*1,.-:;#8%99:.1'9,.C#-".%.$'5(,1.*<.%99#,7?.C",-",1.-",:.(,.-1%=#-#*$%9.
,9#-,7?.;1*5#$,$-.;%1-:.5,5(,17?.*1.@,$,1%97.#$.8"%1@,.*<.1,;1,77#*$[.^.7,8*$=?.
7,;%1%-,.;*9#-#8%9.8*$<9#8-.%1#7,7.C",$.=#8-%-*17.8*'$-,1.8"%99,$@,7.<1*5.-"*7,.
C#-".C"*5.-",:.7"%1,.;*C,1[.B"#7.#7.-",.;1*(9,5.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.;*C,1A
7"%1#$@.IUK
F
0$.(1#,<?.-",.8,$-1%9.89%#5.*<.-",.(**E.#7.-"#7a.'"()H"*%1."&)/H)*1%C/.$%*.$*+$&3)ZZ
$+901,$+2)$+&%$%1%$/+&N)M/0$9$"&N)*&)I"00)*&)%C")&1.#$#*0)/H)0"*,".&)*+,)."2$3"&)ZZ
*.")&C*M",)J()%C")%I$+)M./J0"3&)/H)M/I".Z&C*.$+2)*+,)9/+%./0)*2*$+&%)%C")
J*9',./M)/H)%C"),$&3*0)9/+,$%$/+&)1+,".)IC$9C)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)M/0$%$9&)%*'"&)
M0*9"O)VC"()"8M0*$+)IC()&/3"),$9%*%/.&N)0$'")?*,,*3)a1&&"$+N)"&%*J0$&C)
M".&/+*0)*1%/9.*9()*+,)&%*()$+)M/I".)H/.),"9*,"&`)IC()0"*,".&C$M)9C*+2"&)
"0&"IC".")*.")."210*.)*+,)$+&%$%1%$/+*0$P",N)*&)$+)9/+%"3M/.*.()BC$+*`)IC()
&/3")*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)*.").10",)J()&/0,$".&N)*&)>2*+,*)I*&)1+,".)X,$)
L3$+`)IC()3*+(),$9%*%/.&C$M&N)0$'")45XZ".*)7"8$9/N)3*$+%*$+)."2$3"Z
&*+9%$/+",)M/0$%$9*0)M*.%$"&`)*+,)IC()*)9/1+%.(W&)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)M*&%)9*&%&)*)
0/+2)&C*,/I)/#".)$%&)M./&M"9%&)H/.),"3/9.*9(O)
F
0$.=#8-%-*17"#;7?.%(*'-.*$,.-"#1=.*<.9,%=,17"#;.8"%$@,7.#$+*9+,.*+,1-.+#*9,$8,.
%$=.%(*'-.-C*A-"#1=7.*<.-",5.%1,.$*$8*$7-#-'-#*$%9.AA -",:.=,;%1-.<1*5.*<<#8#%9.
;1*8,='1,7.*1.,7-%(9#7",=.8*$+,$-#*$7
F
Week$12
L*$=%:?.^;1#9.N?.UPMT MUaJV.SL
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-3 of the document.
Unlock all 12 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in
!"#$%&'()*+,)-*()The$Durability$of$Revolutionary$Regimes$i
!"#$%&
!'(%&
)*+#,-./$#*$&
01%$.&
2*1-".3*1,%&
4#,-$%5&
6#7-*1#8%99:."%+,.;1*+,$.-"%-.-",:.8%$.7'1+#+,.<*1.5%$:.=,8%=,7.
=,7;#-,.#$-,$7,.,>-,1$%9.;1,77'1,?.;**1.,8*$*5#8.;,1<*15%$8,?.%$=.
9%1@,A78%9,.;*9#8:.<%#9'1,7
§
B",7,.1,@#5,7."%+,.;*7,=.7,1#*'7.%$=.;,17#7-,$-.8"%99,$@,7.-*.
C,7-,1$.=,5*81%8#,7.%$=.-",#1.<*1,#@$.;*9#8:
§
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.%1,.1,5%1E%(9:.='1%(9,
The$Durability$of$Revolutionary$RegimesF
G('#9=#$@.*$.-",.C*1E.*<.)%5',9.6'$-#$@-*$.%$=.B",=%.)E*8;*9?.C,.
=,<#$,.."#/01%$/+*.()."2$3"& %7.-"*7,.C"#8".,5,1@,.*'-.*<.7'7-%#$,=?.
#=,*9*@#8%9?.%$=.+#*9,$-.7-1'@@9,.<1*5.(,9*C?.%$=.C"*7,.,7-%(9#7"5,$-.#7.
%88*5;%$#,=.(:.5%77.5*(#9#H%-#*$.%$=.7#@$#<#8%$-.,<<*1-7.-*.-1%$7<*15.
7-%-,.7-1'8-'1,7.%$=.-",.,>#7-#$@.*1=,1G.IJK
4/&%."#/1%$/+*.()5"2$3"&6)%99.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.#$.C"#8".-",.
@,$,1%-#*$.-"%-.;%1-#8#;%-,=.=#1,8-9:.#$.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7-1'@@9,."%7.=#,=.
*<<?.7'8".%7.L,>#8*.%$=.-",.)*+#,-./$#*$.%<-,1.-",.MNOPQ7
R*,7.$*-.#$89'=,.1,@#5,7.-"%-.,5,1@,.<1*5.+#*9,$-.#$=,;,$=,$8,.
7-1'@@9,7.#$.C"#8".1%=#8%9.-1%$7<*15%-#*$%9.@*%97.=*.$*-.;1,=*5#$%-,.
I0$=*$,7#%K?.8%7,7.*<.5%77A(%7,=.1,@#5,.8"%$@,.#$.C"#8".7-%-,7.%$=.7*8#%9.
7-1'8-'1,7.1,5%#$.#$-%8-.I-",.S"#9#;;#$,7.#$.MNTO?./E1%#$,.#$.UPPV?.W@:;-.#$.
UPMMK?.*1.8%7,7.*<.1%=#8%9.8"%$@,.#$#-#%-,=.(:.%8-*17.C#-"#$.-",.7-%-,.#-7,9<
7"8$9/):;<)("*.&=
§
>??5):@A)("*.&=
§
BC$+*):D<)("*.&)*+,)9/1+%$+2=
§
E$"%+*3):FG)("*.&)*+,)9/1+%$+2=
§
!/+2"&%)&1.#$#$+2)*1%C/.$%*.$*+)."2$3"&)/H)%C")0*&%)9"+%1.()%C*%)I".")
J/.+)/1%)/H)#$/0"+%)."#/01%$/+
GB,$.*<.-",.-C,9+,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.-"%-.,>#7-,=.#$.
X%$'%1:.MNTN.7'1+#+,=.-"1*'@".UPMY?.8*5;%1,=.-*.(%1,9:.%.-"#1=.IUN.*<.
TUK.*<.-",.C*19=Z7.$*$1,+*9'-#*$%1:.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7[.0$=,,=?.-",.
*$9:.8*55'$#7-.1,@#5,7.-"%-.;,17#7-,=.%<-,1.-",.8*99%;7,.*<.-",.)*+#,-.
/$#*$\!"#$%?.!'(%?.]%*7?.2*1-".3*1,%?.%$=.4#,-$%5\C,1,.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:[.]#E,C#7,?.#$.7'(A)%"%1%$.^<1#8%?.%5*$@.-",."%$=<'9.*<.
%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.-"%-.1,5%#$.#$-%8-.UV.:,%17.%<-,1.-",.<%99.*<.-",.
_,19#$.`%99.%1,.-"1,,.-"%-.C,1,.<*'$=,=.#$.+#*9,$-.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,7a.
^$@*9%?.L*H%5(#b',?.%$=.c#5(%(C,[.^$=.#$.-",.L#==9,.W%7-.%$=.2*1-".
^<1#8%?.-",.*$9:.$*$5*$%18"#,7.-"%-.C,1,.$*-.7,1#*'79:.8"%99,$@,=.='1#$@.
-",.^1%(.);1#$@\^9@,1#%.%$=.01%$\C,1,.(*1$.*<.+#*9,$-.7-1'@@9,[G.IOK
!"#$%Q7.!*55'$#7-.1,@#5,.7'1+#+,=.-",.MNTN.B#%$%$5,$.)b'%1,.
';1#7#$@
§
!'(%Q7.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,.7'1+#+,=.-",.8*99%;7,.*<.#-7.)*+#,-.
;%-1*$?.%.VPd.=,89#$,.#$.eRS?.%$=.f#=,9.!%7-1*Q7.=,;%1-'1,.<1*5.
;*C,1
§
2*1-".3*1,%.!*55'$#7-.1,@#5,.,$='1,=.%.5%77.<%5#$,.<*99*C#$@.
-",.)*+#,-.8*99%;7,?.%7.C,99.%7.-",.=,%-".*<.<*'$=#$@.9,%=,1.3#5.09.
)'$@
§
!"%99,$@,7.-*.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.#$.-",.;*7-A!*9=.`%1.;,1#*=
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.D,@#5,7F
B",.=,7-1'8-#*$.*<.#$=,;,$=,$-.;*C,1.8,$-,17
§
!*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7
§
B#@"-.;%1-#7%$.8*$-1*9.*+,1.-",.7,8'1#-:.<*18,7
§
S*C,1<'9.8*,18#+,.%;;%1%-'7,7
§
`,.%1@',.-"%-.%15,=.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,?.;*7-1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7-%-,A('#9=#$@?.
%$=.-",.+#*9,$-.8*$<9#8-7.-1#@@,1,=.(:.,<<*1-7.-*.8%11:.*'-.1%=#8%9.7*8#%9.
8"%$@,.9,%+,.<*'1.9,@%8#,7. -"%-.,$"%$8,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.='1%(#9#-:a.
B",7,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.9,@%8#,7. ",9;.-*.#$*8'9%-,.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.
%@%#$7-.,9#-,.=,<,8-#*$?.5#9#-%1:.8*';7?.%$=.5%77.;1*-,7-.AA -"1,,.5%g*1.
7*'18,7.*<.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.(1,%E=*C$
)-,;",$.`%9-.7"*C7.-"%-.1,+*9'-#*$7.=1%5%-#8%99:.#$81,%7,.-",.
9#E,9#"**=.*<.#$-,17-%-,.C%1
§
R,7-1'8-#*$.*<.#$=,;,$=,$-.;*C,1.8,$-,17
4#*9,$-.9#(,1%-#*$.7-1'@@9,7.%$=.-",.;*9%1#H%-#*$.@,$,1%-,=.(:.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.7,#H'1,7.*<.;*C,1.;1*='8,.'$'7'%99:.=#78#;9#$,=.1'9#$@.
;%1-#,7?.5%1E,=.(:.5#9#-%1#H,=.7-1'8-'1,7?.7-1*$@.;%1-#7%$.#=,$-#-#,7?.
#$-,$7,.C#-"#$A@1*';.9*:%9-#,7?.%$=.%.<*'$=#$@.@,$,1%-#*$.*<.9,%=,17.
C#-".,>-1%*1=#$%1:.9,@#-#5%8:
)-1*$@.D'9#$@.S%1-#,7
!1,%-#*$.*<.$,C.%15#,7.*1.%.1%=#8%9.;'1@,.%$=.
1,8*$7-1'8-#*$.*<.,>#7-#$@.*$,7
®
/7'%99:.%88*5;%$#,=.(:.7-%-,.8*99%;7,?.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.,9#-,7.
<1,b',$-9:.1,5%E,.-",.7-%-,
&
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.;%1-#,7.%1,."#@"9:.;%1-#7%$.%$=.-"*1*'@"9:.
8*55#--,=.-*.-",.1,@#5,
&
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7.%1,.7-1#E#$@9:.#$+'9$,1%(9,.-*.8*';7
0$+'9$,1%(#9#-:.-*.!*';7
)E*8;*9a.1,+*9'-#*$7.;1*='8,.;*C,1<'9.8*,18#+,.7-1'8-'1,7
D,+*9'-#*$7.<1,b',$-9:.-1#@@,1.,>-,1$%9.C%17?.*<-,$.C#-".$,#@"(*1#$@.
7-%-,7.C"*7,.@*+,1$5,$-7.<,,9.-"1,%-,$,=.(:.-",.1,+*9'-#*$%1:.
1,@#5,.*1.;,18,#+,.%.C#$=*C.*<.*;;*1-'$#-:.#$.-",.C%E,.*<.7-%-,.
8*99%;7,[.)'8".,>#7-,$-#%9. -"1,%-7.81,%-,.;*C,1<'9.#$8,$-#+,7.<*1.
1,+*9'-#*$%1:.@*+,1$5,$-7.-*.('#9=.';.-",.7-%-,Q7.8*,18#+,.8%;%8#-:
D,+*9'-#*$7.*<-,$.-1#@@,1.%.8"%#$.*<.;1*8,77,7.-"%-.8'95#$%-,.#$.
='1%(9,.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1'9,.IMUK
0$=#+#='%9.8%7,7.+%1:?.('-.#$.5*7-.7'88,77<'9.1,+*9'-#*$7?.%15,=.
7-1'@@9,.,$@,$=,17.8*",7#+,.1'9#$@.;%1-#,7.-"%-?.';*$.7,#H#$@.;*C,1?.
1,8*$7-1'8-.%$=.-"*1*'@"9:.;,$,-1%-,.-",.8*,18#+,. %;;%1%-'7[.)'8".
;%1-:A%15:.<'7#*$.=1%5%-#8%99:.1,='8,7.-",.9#E,9#"**=.*<.5#9#-%1:.
8*';7[.
D,+*9'-#*$%1:.1,@#5,7."%+,.(,,$.%5*$@.-",.5*7-.='1%(9,.%$=.
9*$@A9%7-#$@.%'-"*1#-%1#%$.1,@#5,7.#$.-",.5*=,1$.C*19=IMYK
KL&)%C")9/00*M&")/H)%C")?/#$"%)>+$/+),"3/+&%.*%",N)."#/01%$/+*.()
0"2*<