Class Notes (905,950)
US (350,570)
UCLA (10,611)
POL SCI (320)
Lecture

# PS 171C Week 10.docx

3 Pages
152 Views

Department
Political Science
Course Code
POL SCI 171C
Professor
Tim Groseclose

This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full 3 pages of the document.
PS 171C
Week 10
Tuesday
Explain how positive or negative externalities exist in the prisoners’ dilemma
game
o If I defect => negative externality for my opponent
o If my opponent cooperates => positive externality for me
How many equilibria are there in this game? Are any Pareto inefficient?
o One defect, defect
o NE is not Pareto efficient. Pareto efficient outcome would be mutual
cooperation
One aspect of a coordination game is that there are multiple equilibria. Is
society’s choice of the arrange of the arrangement of letters on a typewriter a
coordination game?
o Yes, keyboard manufacturers design QWERTY keyboards.
o All users then learn how to type the QWERTY system
In a stag hunt game two hunters stand on either side of a path, waiting for a
stag to approach. Nearby are some rabbits. Each hunter decides whether to
abandon the stag hunt and kill a rabbit or help his or her fellow hunter kill a
stag. If both hunters choose option 2, they kill the stag and split it between
them. This is the most preferred outcome of both hunters. The second most
favored outcome of a hunter is if he chooses 1 and takes home a rabbit. The
least preferred outcome of a hunter is if he chooses 2 but his partner chooses
1. In this case he takes nothing home. What is the equilibrium or equilibria to
this game?
o Two equilibria: (rabbit, rabbit) and (stag, stag)
In what ways is a pay-raise vote in a legislature like a prisoners’ dilemma?
o A legislator voting against the pay-raise is a negative externality for
me
o A legislator voting for the pay-raise is a positive externality for me
o Incentive to defect if there is a voting coalition in favor
In what ways is a pay-raise vote like a stag hunt?
o There are multiple equilibria
o Some everyone prefer others
Suppose a legislature of 101 members is voting on a pay raise. What is the
equilibrium or equilibria to the game?
o One equilibrium: 51 yeas and 50 nays
Describe any coordination problems in this game?
o Which 51 voters support it?
In 1991 how did the Senate solve these coordination problems?
o 51 to 48 vote so it didn’t seem pivotal. But how do you pick the 51
voters?

#### Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
PS 171C Week 10 Tuesday  Explain how positive or negative externalities exist in the prisoners’ dilemma game o If I defect => negative externality for my opponent o If my opponent cooperates => positive externality for me  How many equilibria are there in this game? Are any Pareto inefficient? o One – defect, defect o NE is not Pareto efficient. Pareto efficient outcome would be mutual cooperation  One aspect of a coordination game is that there are multiple equilibria. Is society’s choice of the arrange of the arrangement of letters on a typewriter a coordination game? o Yes, keyboard manufacturers design QWERTY keyboards. o All users then learn how to type the QWERTY system  In a stag hunt game two hunters stand on either side of a path, waiting for a stag to approach. Nearby are some rabbits. Each hunter decides whether to abandon the stag hunt and kill a rabbit or help his or her fellow hunter kill a stag. If both hunters choose option 2, they kill the stag and split it between them. This is the most preferred outcome of both hunters. The second most favored outcome of a hunter is if he chooses 1 and takes home a rabbit. The least preferred outcome of a hunter is if he chooses 2 but his partner chooses 1. In this case he takes nothing home. What is the equilibrium or equilibria to this game? o Two equilibria: (rabbit, rabbit) and (stag, stag)  In what ways is a pay-raise vote in a legislature like a prisoners’ dilemma? o A legislator voting against the pay-raise is a negative externality for me o A legislator voting for the pay-raise is a positive externality for me o Incentive to defect if there is a voting coalition in favor  In what ways is a pay-raise vote like a stag hunt? o There are multiple equilibria o Some everyone prefer others  Suppose a legislature of 101 members is voting on a pay raise. What is the equilibrium or equilibria to the game? o One equilibrium: 51 yeas and 50 nays o Other: everyone votes nay  Describe any coordination problems in this game? o Which 51 voters support it?  In 1991 how did the Senate solve these coordination problems? o 51 to 48 vote so it didn’t seem pivotal. But how do you pick the 51 voters? o People not up for reelection got a free pass for the pay raise o Robert Byrd solved coordination problem o Breakfast the day of the vote to confirm votes  Did any senators not act rationally in the 1991 Senate pay raise vote? o One of the planned nay-voting senators voted yea  Left Turn - Tim Groseclose  Second Midterm Review o List six ways in which the cartoon “I’m Just a Bill” is wrong or incomplete  Bill can’t die in committee  Can be discharged  Extracted by Rules Committee  Rider tactic  Suspension of the rules calendar  Usually bill needs a rule from the Rules Committee  Might pass the Senate first  Might need a conference committee o In the actual House, how many legislators must sign a discharge petition before the bill receives a mandatory consideration on the floor?  218 o True or false? When the Rules Committee writes a “rule” for a bill, this is more of a suggestion than an order. In 1-4 sentences explain why or why not.  Must be voted on by the floor It can be ame
More Less

Only page 1 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document
Notes
Practice
Earn
Me

OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Join to view

OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.