Class Notes (811,143)
Canada (494,518)
LAW 724 (44)

Chapter 11 Settlement of Internation Business Disputes.docx

9 Pages
Unlock Document

Ryerson University
Law and Business
LAW 724
Alyssa Brierley

Chapter 11: Settlement of International Business Disputes Auctions in Domestic Court: Suing and being sued Choice of law: - The parties are free to specify the choice of law clause that their contract will be governed by law of a particular jurisdiction as long as their selection is made in good faith and NOT for avoiding the public policy of a country that has a connection to the contract. - The choice is unlikely to be respected and enforced by a court if a legal system is expressly chosen for the purpose of evading the provisions of the legal system with which the transaction is most closely connected to. - Law only applies to terms in contract and It does not affect the parties to continue obliging the laws of any jurisdiction in which they carry business. Proof of foreign law: - Judges in most common law country have no obligation to ascertain foreign law - In the event, where a contract must be governed by the foreign law, it must be proved by an expert witness or similar admissible evidence. - The law of the jurisdiction will be used if a party wishing to benefit from foreign law fails to plead or bring evidence. The Proper law of contract: - If parties haven’t made a choice of law, the proper law of contract must be determined. - A transaction may have several different aspects, and it is possible that different laws are applicable to different aspects of the same transactions. - F parties have not made express selection of law they wish to apply, courts will choose legal system that has closest and most real connection. To determine the proper legal system the court looks at: • The place the contract was made • The place contract is performed • The place of business of parties • The language, form and terminology used in the contract • The contract’s connection with any preceding transaction - Sometimes the parties have not made an express choice of law but they have made inferences by other clauses in contract e.g. designating arbitration place or stating certain country’s courts have jurisdiction. EU Convention on Contractual Law: - This convention states two basic principles: • 1 preserves right of choice of law nd • 2 provides that where parties have not chosen, the law of contract will be the law having closest connection with the contract - Concept of Characterise Performance: Law of domicile (place of residence: the country a person treats as their permanent home) of performing party, not the law of place where performance is carried out. Choice of Forum: - The parties may also stipulate in advance where (in what jurisdiction’s court or forum) a case relating to their transaction will be heard. These clauses are honoured by most countries subject to the following conditions: • The choice of forum must not violate the public policy of country having a genuine connection with the contract • The forum must not be seriously inconvenient for one or more of the parties of the court itself - Choice of Forum – Clauses: maybe ‘exclusive’ or ‘non-exclusive’. - A ‘non-exclusive’ clause is a statement by the parties that they submit to a particular court, but the clause does not specify that all the disputes must be decided by that court. - For ‘exclusive’ clause, parties should each appoint an agent resident in the chosen jurisdiction for service of any relevant documents. - The usual way ‘choice of forum’ occurs is, once a dispute has arisen, one party begins an action in the country (jurisdiction) of its choice. However, the court in which the action is initiated may not always agree to accept the jurisdiction. Who can Sue or be Sued in Canadian Courts? - The most practical rule to follow when deciding where to sue is to choose the jurisdiction in which the defendant’s assets are located. - Ontario courts will assume jurisdiction if either of the following has occurred: • The defendant was served while he/she/it was within Ontario • The defendant was served outside Ontario but there’s a ‘connection to Ontario’ - The Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure provides that ‘a connection to Ontario’ exists when: • The contract was made in Ontario • The contract provides that it is to be governed by or interpreted in accordance with the law of Ontario • The parties to the contract have agreed that the courts of Ontario are to have jurisdiction over legal proceedings in respect of the contract • The breach of contract has been committed in Ontario • Damage was sustained in Ontario as a result of a breach of contract wherever committed If none of these connecting factors is present, the plaintiff must obtain permission of the court to start and action. This requires a preliminary motion before a motion court (hearing before a judge to obtain decisions on matters relating to a lawsuit, which must be dealt with before or after trial) - Once a plaintiff has brought an action in its chosen jurisdiction, the defendant may be able to object to the jurisdiction and have the action stayed or dismissed. The defendant’s argument in these cases is usually: • The case did not fall within the rules for service without leave • If leave was granted, the leave of the court to serve outside the jurisdiction should not have been granted • The court is not a convenient or appropriate forum for hearing (forum non conveniens) - If the defendant is successful in any of these arguments, the court will stay or stop the action Forum Non-Conveniens: A court that has a jurisdiction over a defendant under national laws declines to exercise it and stays the action because it’s not appropriate venue for action and considerations of justice require that the plaintiff litigate in another jurisdiction. This situation arises when a defendant served ex juris (outside jurisdiction) The Anti-suit Injunction: An action in which the foreign defendant asks the court to enjoin or prevent plaintiff’s residence in the court’s jurisdiction from proceeding with their foreign action against the foreign defendant. Enforcement of Foreign Judgements Enforcing a Foreign Judgement in Canada: - Even when the decision is made in the favour of plaintiff, the real reason for lawsuit is recovery of damages. For this reason, the action should, whenever possible, be brought into a jurisdiction where defendant has assets against which the judgement can be enforced. - If the judgment is obtained in one jurisdiction and the defendant’s assets are in another, the plaintiff must obtain recognition in the second jurisdiction and attempt to enforce the decision there. - If a plaintiff has obtained foreign judgement against a defendant in Canada, plaintiff must then enforce its foreign judgement here. This will require a court proceeding in Canadian province in which judgement is to be enforced. - Canadian courts are increasingly prepared to enforce judgments by US courts and by respected courts in other jurisdictions, provided the following conditions are met: • There was a proper subject matter jurisdiction over the Canadian parties • The judgement is not fraudulent or contrary to public policy or natural justice • There is a real and substantial connection between the deciding court and the action Provisions for Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgements: - Canada provides legislation for reciprocal enforcement of judgements between the provinces - Only provision for reciprocal enforcement of judgments outside Canada is with United Kingdom Actions Involving Foreign States - Sovereign Immunity is immunity from prosecution or suit claimed by a nation state. - There are two states of immunity – absolute immunity and restrictive immuni
More Less

Related notes for LAW 724

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.