Class Notes (807,037)
Canada (492,560)
Philosophy (111)
34-226 (26)
Falconer (11)
Lecture 8

Philosophy 34-226 Lecture 8: Lectures 8-10 on Rights of Defendants

3 Pages
Unlock Document

University of Windsor

Lecture 8-10 on Rights of Defendants The Dirty Harry Problem  Carl Klockars' (1980) uses Dirty Harry to identify what the police can do and cannot do  Dirty Harry Problem  using the means outside the law to bring them to justice  Morality is outside the law; people who aren't brought to justice but everyone knows they are guilty; thus, a dirty cop brings them to justice using means outside the law  When criminals are on the streets, anyone would feel morally mad but feelings themselves do not make a moral society  Moral justice is not about legal correctness  Law makes mistakes too  You can achieve a good end through bad means  Dirty Harry Problem  using negative means for positive ends  Art utilitarianism  goodness or badness/wrongness is based on the consequences on that act o Greatest good is for greatest number  Bentham vs. Mill o Bentham  consequences is most important o Mill  legal rules have consequences is important too  Police have a moral outrage because some criminals can't be put at justice; thus, they use wrong means to put them in jail  Carl Klockars' (1980)  The Dirty Harry Dilemma o "when and to what extent does the morally good end justify an ethically, politically, or legally dangerous means for its achievement?" o Police is put in a moral dilemma o Police is responsible for some action; they're not innocent o "when the ends to be achieved are urgent and unquestionably good and only a dirty means will work, the police officer faces a genuine moral dilemma"  When can you engage in this kind of activity?  What are the conditions to this problem?  Which actions are better or worse?  You're trained for your profession and not cross the line; you're not trained for moral issues  Police could become worse in terms of using wrong means to achieve good ends  Developed from a movie: the criminal holds a girl hostage, asking for ransom, but the girl is dead. Harry (Clint Eastwood) breaks into criminal's apartment and shoots him in the leg, wanting a confession  Is it legitimate form of outrage? It is even more outrage if the criminal gets through the system  Plot analysis: 3 questions must be asked o What are the probabilities that these wrong means will achieve the good ends? The probability has increased by breaking the criminal's apartment or shooting him in the leg. The higher degree of knowledge, the more probability for the bad mean to be more acceptable  the cops working thesis o Are there other means or ways to achieve the good end? Ex. a confession  higher moral beings have less creative than lower moral beings  How could Harry do it differently?  two forms of lying (does the criminal deserve the truth? Why? Because they broke the law in the first place, the law binds us together; thus, you can act differently to someone who is outside that relationship, or outside the law)  Factual lie  lying to someone who deserve the truth  moral lie  lying to someone who doesn't deserve the truth o Is the issue weighty? To Harry's situation, it's about a girl's life, not self-interest  Sometimes there's no alternatives to achieve the same good end; but it has to be serious enough to engage it in the first place Dirty Tricks and Nice Officers?  Will the cop become a dirty cop if engaging this kind of activity?  From the perspective of the law, are the cop corrupt if they engage in bad means?  If you are a good moral person, if you could do something but didn't, you would feel a sense of moral responsibility  You want cops to feel a sense of moral responsibility  Once the cop engages in this kind of activity, he is no longer innocent o A good cop can become a bad cop; he might be a good moral person in general o Even if bad means can achieve good ends, but we fear it changes the cop's character; thus, we don't like them to engage in dirty means  The Realities of the Dirty Harry o Does the end justify the mean? o Does the bad mean justify a goo
More Less

Related notes for 34-226

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.