The government is considering paving a highway with a newly developed "wear-proof" material. Paving the highway the traditional way would cost $1 billion today, but the annual projected maintenance is $400 million in each of the next 10 years. Paving the highway using the newly developed wear-proof material would cost $4 billion today, but using the new wear-proof material means there are no maintenance costs for the next 10 years. Only consider the current cost and maintenance costs for the next 10 years when evaluating this project.
(a) Use the concept of present value to determine which method is best if the government can borrow at an interest rate of 4%.
(b) Is it worth it if the interest rate is 0%?
(c) Is it worth it if the interest rate is 8%?
(d) A politician says to you, " don't care what the interest rate is. The new wear-proof material is clearly a good investment: it more than pays for itself in only 8 years, and all the rest is money in the bank." What's wrong with this argument, and why does the interest rate matter?
The government is considering paving a highway with a newly developed "wear-proof" material. Paving the highway the traditional way would cost $1 billion today, but the annual projected maintenance is $400 million in each of the next 10 years. Paving the highway using the newly developed wear-proof material would cost $4 billion today, but using the new wear-proof material means there are no maintenance costs for the next 10 years. Only consider the current cost and maintenance costs for the next 10 years when evaluating this project.
(a) Use the concept of present value to determine which method is best if the government can borrow at an interest rate of 4%.
(b) Is it worth it if the interest rate is 0%?
(c) Is it worth it if the interest rate is 8%?
(d) A politician says to you, " don't care what the interest rate is. The new wear-proof material is clearly a good investment: it more than pays for itself in only 8 years, and all the rest is money in the bank." What's wrong with this argument, and why does the interest rate matter?