Detailed notes on Ungar Reader, Ch 3

4 Pages
Unlock Document

University of Toronto Scarborough
Sheldon Ungar

Data, Denials and Confusion: The Racial Profiling Debate in Toronto Research on Racial Profiling Racial profiling: when members of certain racial or ethnic groups become subject to greater levels of criminal justice surveillance than others. Eg. Stop and search practices, racial differences in customs searches, increased police patrols in racial minority neighbourhoods, etc. - Racial profiling involves racial bias in police investigation , not racial bias in arrest decisions or racial bias in police treatment after arrest. Eg. Over-representation of blacks could mean subject to greater police surveillance. However, could also mean that blacks are simply more involved in certain criminal activities. - Data suggests blacks are 8 times more likely to be stopped and searched by police than whites. - LZ}ÁÀŒ L[š]LÀZš]2š‰ŒZL }ŒZL }Œ ]o‰Œ}]o]L2 µZÁŒL}š required to record race of people stopped or searched - However, number of field studies have uncovered evidence that racial profiling may exist o Eg. James (1998) conducted intensive interview with over 50 black youth from southern Ontario. Being stopped by the police was common to them. James concludes that these ‰}o] Zš}‰Z }LšŒ]µšZZšŒ}L2oÇš}o lÇ}µšZZ[Z}Zš]o]šÇš}wards police. o -µ2µŒ[Z~îììì]LšŒÀ]ÁZòïo lLÁZ]ššLZŒ}[email protected]}Œ}Lš}L‰Œ}µ similar results. Both white and black agreed black males are much more likely to be stopped - But above samples were rather small and not random. - A survey in 1994 of over 1200 Toronto residents found black people much more likely to report involuntary police contact than either whites or Asians. o Eg. Almost half (44%) of black male respondents reported to have been stopped by police at least once in the past 2 years and (30%) reported to have been stopped on 2 or more occasions. o Only 12% of white males and 7% of Asian males reported multiple police stops o Multivariate analyses revels šZZ]ŒL Z]L‰}o] }Lš š L[šÆ‰o]LÇ racial differences in social class, education or other demographic variables - î š}ŒZ‰Œ}š šÁZ]šKoZŒ}K‰}o] }Lš šµš}L[š}Œo lZ9and social class o In general, whites with high incomes and education less likely to be stopped than whites who score lower in social class o Blacks with high incomes and education are actually more likely to be stopped than lower-class blacks. - Recent survey with 3400 Toronto high school students provide more evidence of racial profiling: o Over 50% of black students reported they had been stopped and questioned on 2 or more occasions in the previous 2 years o Compared to 23% whites, 11% Asians, and 8% South Asians o Over 40% black students claimed to have been physically searched in previous 2 years o Compared to 17% of white, and 11% Asians. o However, data revealed students who engage more in deviance and crime receive more police attention. Eg. 81% of drug dealers in this sample reported that they had been search compared to 16% of those students who did not sell drugs - Multivariate analysis revealed racial differences in police stop and search practices actually greatest among students with low criminal behaviour. o Eg. 34% black students not engaged in criminal activity still reported to have been stopped compared to only 4% of white o Findings strongly suggest racial profile exists in Toronto - Because of this, black people much likely to be caught breaking law than whites that do similar forms of criminal activity ,ŒÀÇ[ZoL]L2}š[email protected]}Œ}Lš}ŒŒZšš - Professor Harvey argues there is no racial profiling against an article by the Toronto Star - He complains that CIPS (Toronto police arrest data set) not intended to be a research database but as long as arrest data is adequately described and subjected to appropriate analysis, there is absolutely no intrinsic problem with using them for research - Harvey claims CIPS is only a sample, but in fact CIPS data set is not supposed to be a sample. It is data designed to represent the total population of criminal charges that includes everything. - Harvey then decides to replicate the analysis. - ,šZL}ZZ}K^š oL]L2_ o He o]K]LšZoo^Kµoš]‰o}LŒZ_ from the CIPS data, eliminating over half the completed cases. He believed it would skew data and bias analytical outcomes o But black people have higher probability of being arrested on multiple occasions. o Harvey also eliminated offenders charged with more than one crime. o But black people are more likely to be charged with multiple crimes than whites (over- charging) - Harvey then decides to only focus on divisions that have a black population greater than 6%. He justifies by stating the exclusion of
More Less

Related notes for SOCA01H3

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.