JSB171 Week 1 Study Guide Summary.docx

3 Pages
Unlock Document


Week 1 Study Guide Summary Introduction  A number of concepts surround the notion of ‘Justice’, for example: fairness, equality, harm, and inclusion/exclusion.  These related concepts will be discussed, and will provide a broad overview of what ‘Justice’ actually refers to, and how it relates to social institutions and the criminal justice system.  Despite our efforts and commitment to equality and justice, inequality and injustice still occur, and do so in ways that are not always individual in character.  Will explore how inequality arises and whether or not social inequality impacts the criminal justice system. Justice  Barcalow (2004) suggests three parameters of justice: 1. That we treat equals equally 2. That we treat people the way they deserve to be treated 3. That we treat people as they have a right to be treated  This way of thinking involves the moral idea that humans have inherent and deserved equality – an idea that has formed the basis of modern understandings about human rights.  Justice is thus connected with the moral question of how people should act, and also definitions of ‘good’.  Plato, Kant, Marx, Rousseau, and Rawls are philosophers who have all thought and written extensively about these issues.  However, our ability to define what is ‘good’ and ‘bad’ is limited, as the problem of finding a universal definition has arisen.  What may be defined as ‘good’ in our culture may not actually reflect in that of another culture, therefore, how are we supposed to define them?  The dictionary associates justice with treating others fairly and rightly. We think of this in a legal, criminal, and retributive justice context. Retributive Justice: ‘let the punishment fit the crime’. A theory that considers punishment, if proportionate, is a morally acceptable and beneficial response to crime.  Retributive justice is related to how the courts are expected to deal with a crime in an appropriate and consistent manner. The punishment should fit the crime.  There is a strong expectation that justice should be impartial, meaning that factors such as wealth and social status should play no part in how the penalty if found and imposed.  Variations and inconsistency in sentencing, when dealing with similar or same crimes, raises suspicions of injustice.  However, aggravating and mitigating factors must be considered when examining a sentence. In many cases, these factors may mean the difference between a lesser or more harsh penalty. Aggravating Factors: are any relevant circumstances which support the evidence presented in the trial, that make the harshest penalty more appropriate in the eyes of the jury. Mitigating Factors: are any relevant evidence presented regarding the defendant’s character or circumstances surrounding the crime, which would make a lesser sentence more appropriate.  Generally in society, justice assumes a fairness of the distribution of resources, whether economical, material, or emotional in nature, which satisfies the basic needs of people. This form of justice is coined distributive justice, because it is concerned with the allocation of goods based on individual need. Distributive Justice: concerned with the socially just allocation of goods to members of a society, usually based on individual needs. This is reflected in tax brackets depending on income.  This does not necessarily conform to notion of treating everyone the same, however, as it requires differentiation between people based on relevant issues of difference. Equality  The idea of equality plays a key role in our ideas of justice. In our society, it is generally assumed that all people are equal, and we demand proof for any claims made that there are inequalities which hold relev
More Less

Related notes for JSB171

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.