Class Notes (1,100,000)
CA (620,000)
Dal (4,000)
SOSA (200)
Lecture 8

SOSA 3006 Lecture Notes - Lecture 8: Brian Peckford, Commuter Town, Oil Sands

by

Department
Soc & Social Anthropology
Course Code
SOSA 3006
Professor
katieharris
Lecture
8

This preview shows pages 1-2. to view the full 6 pages of the document.
!"#$%&%%'()*
+#%$,-./01%2(%304"50%6-7
89"5:0-)$3%50;<9"(<%
=>"#:0-''?.()*0:%57$0;&%.0:%57()"?"*.@0#$%0'5"'%5?.0()05%$'")$%0:"0-)$3%5$0
+9#5$,-./0A6-7
=)<%$:"5$0-),0:9%(50'"3%50()0?(4%
B"7%)0-5%09-2()*0:5"#>?%0()0:9%(50?(4%
B5(:%0'-'%50")0:9($C
D-7>",(-0E-<:"5(%$0-5:(<?%0
B9-:0($0-08:-:%0-),0!"30F"%$0(:0B"5&C
Governmentality
=<<"#):->(?(:.0"40'"'#?-:(")$0;<"#):@07%-$#5%@0:-60'%"'?%0
!"303%0$9-'%09"30'%"'?%0-<:0
D#?:(2-:(")0"409->(:$0"50G:9%0<"),#<:0"40<"),#<:0HE"#<-#?:I0
A,#<-:(")0$.$:%7@0(,%-$0->"#:0*%),%5@0)":(")$0"4039-:0-04-7(?.0$9"#?,0
?""&0?(&%
D-:%*"5(%$0"<<#55%,@0:9($09-''%)%,0-:0$-7%0:(7%0;,(2(,()*0'"'#?-:(")$04"50
#),%5$:-),()*J7-)-*%7%):0
K-5:0"40:9%0<#?:#5-?05%2"?#:(")$0"<<#55()*0:"0<5%-:%0$'-<%04"50,(44%5%):0:.'%$0"40
%<")"7(%$03-$0:9%05%<"*)(:(")0"40'%"'?%0-$0-0L'"'#?-:(")L039(<90<"#?,0>%07-)-*%,0
:95"#*90,(5%<:0-<:(")0
M("?%)<%0<9-)*%,0;)":0:9%07-()03-.0:"0*%:0'%"'?%0:"04-??0()0?()%0-).7"5%0
E"#<-#?:0;'-()0-),02("?%)<%0
1#?%0($0->"#:0<"%5<(")0-),0<")$%):0
1%<"*)(N%0<-'-<(:.0-$0-*%):$0-),045%%0<9"(<%0;<5%-:%0"5,%50:9-:04-<(?(:-:%$039-:0
<9"(<%$0."#07-&%0
L+"0,"7()-:%0($0:"0(*)"5%0"50:"0-::%7':0:"0<5#$90:9%0<-'-<(:.04"50-<:(")0"40:9%0
,"7()-:%,O0P#:0:"0*"2%5)0($0:"05%<"*)(N%0:9-:0<-'-<(:.04"50-<:(")0-),0:"0-,Q#$:0")%$%?40
:"0(:O0+"0*"2%5)$0($0:"0-<:0#'")0-<:(")R0)":0:"0<5#$90:9%(50H$#>Q%<:$0"40'"3%5I0<-'-<(:.0
:"0-<:@0>#:0:"0-<&)"3?%,*%0(:0-),0:"0#:(?(N%0(:04"50")%L$0"3)0">Q%<:(2%$L0H1"$%0STTT/UI
Policy/As/A/Technology/of/Power
1%*#?-:(")$0<"):5"??()*0>%9-2("#5$
P%)%-:90-0?-3@0,%-?$03(:90%2%5.,-.0>%9-2("#5$0
A)2(5")7%):@07-)-*%7%):@0
V#:?()()*05"?%$@05%$'")$(>(?(:(%$0;39"0<-)0,"039-:@09"30:9()*$0-5%0$"?2%,@0
<"7'?-():$@0
F($<('?()()*0-$0-0'5"<%$$
K"?(<.0-$0-0:""?04"50,"7()-:(")0
K"?(<.0-$0-0&%.0:%<9)"?"*.0"40'"3%5
LRK"?(<.09-$0>%<"7%0-07-Q"50()$:(:#:(")0"40B%$:%5)0-),0():%5)-:(")-?0
*"2%5)-)<%@0")0'-503(:90":9%50&%.0"5*-)(N()*0<")<%':$0$#<90-$0L4-7(?.L0-),0
L$"<(%:.LL0H89"5%0-),0B5(*9:0STTW/XI
LR=$0<#?:#5-?0:%6:$@0-$0<?-$$(4(<-:"5.0,%2(<%$03(:902-5("#$07%-)()*$@0-$0)-55-:(2%$0
:9-:0$%52%0:"0Q#$:(4.0"50<"),%7)0:9%0'5%$%):0R07",%?$0"40$"<(%:.LH89"5%0-),0
B5(*9:0STTW/0WI
89"5%0-),0B5(*9:@0+9%0=):95"'"?"*.0"40K"?(<.
GGGB9-:0($0-#$:%5(:.CCC
Anthropology/of/the/Present
+9($0<-)0<5%-:%0 #)():%),%,0)%*-:(2%0<")$%Y#%)<%$04"50:9%0:-5*%:0'"'#?-:(")
M(%3%,0-$0)":9()*0():%5<"))%<:%,0;->$:5-<:0'%5$'%<:(2%0
D-)0<5%-:%0#)():%),%,0)%*-:(2%0<")$%Y#%)<%$0
Z$$#%$0$#<90-$0#)%7'?".7%):0"50'"2%5:.0-5%05%),%5%,0:%<9)(<-?@0-),02(%3%,0()0
($"?-:(")0"40:9%0<"):%6:$03(:9()039(<90:9%.0"<<#5
!($:"5(<-?0'"?(<.0($0%-$(%50>%<-#$%0(:0($0<?%-50 39-:0<"7%$0:"*%:9%5
8:#,.0:9%0<5%-:(")0"4@0(7'-<:$@0-),0-''?(<-:(")0"40'"?(<.0:"04"570-)0-):95"'"?"*.0"40
:9%0'5%$%):
G$9%0?(&%$0:%570L-):95"'"?"*.0"40:9%0'5%$%):L
8%-?09#):()*0()0[%34"#),?-),J\->5-,"5/0>-5>-5(<0"504%%,()*0."#504-7(?.
+3"0$<-?%$0"40AZ0()0KAZ0;,"%$)]:07-::%5039%5%0."#0?(2%0:9%5%0-5%0)"0Q">$0
-).39%5%@0<"$:0"40?(2()*0($09(*90
D9-)*()*05%:(5%7%):0-*%
8#>$(,(N%0#)(2%5$(:.0%,#<-:(")0
D-)0."#0:9()&0"40-).0'"?(<(%$0:9-:07(*9:0(7'-<:0$"<(-?05%'5",#<:(")0$:5-:%*(%$C
Ethnographic/Example:/Post;Confederation/Newfoundland/
F($<"#5$%05%'%-:%,0()0'"?(<.0:%??$0."#0:9%02-?#%$0
+9%"5(N()*0'"?(<./0E"#<-#?:@089"5%0-),0B5(*9:@01"$%0^0#$()*0:3"0'"?(<.0'5"*5-7$0-),0
$:-:($:(<-?J9($:"5(<-?0()4"57-:(")0:"0,%:%57()%0:9%(50(7'-<:0")0<"):%7'"5-5.0
[%34"#),?-),0-),0$"<(-?05%'5",#<:(")0'-::%5)$0
P%::%50-<<%$$@0,")]:09-2%0:"0?(2%0")0$#>$($:%)<%@0<-)0'-5:(<('-:%0-$0$&(??%,0
?->"#5%5$0()03-*%0%<")"7.
=45(<2(??%0-$0-0*"",0%6-7'?%0"409"30:9($03-$0(7'?%7%):%,0>#:09#5:0:9%0-<:#-?0
'%"'?%0(:03-$0(7'?%7%):%,0")0
Z,%"?"*.0->"#:07",%5)(N-:(")0;?%)$0'"?(<.07-&%5$0-),0*"2%5)7%):0#$%,0
S/05%?"<-:(")0()(:(-:(2%$0;*5"#'0"40:95%%
_/0[D=1K0-),0+=`80;#$%,0:"0:5.0:"05%:5-()0?->"#507-5&%:04"??"3()*0<",0
7-5&%:04-??
=5:%4-<:$
D")<%5:%,0%44"5:0:"05%<5%-:%0 [%34"#),?-),0()0?()%03(:90L7",%5)(:.L0H!"30($0:9($0
<"7'-5->?%0:"0(),#$:5(-?(N-:(")0)-55-:(2%$CI
a%%'0(:0-$0-05%'"$(:"5.04"507")%.0;,")]:03-):0'%"'?%0$%::?()*0:9%5%0
D"#?,0)":0>%<"7%0-).:9()*0>#:04($9%50
K%"'?%03%5%0?%4:0>%9(),04"50:9-:05%-$")0;:9-:03-$0:9%0$%::?%7%):0$:5-:%*.0
E($9()*0*5"#),$0;4(5$:0<"7%04(5$:0$%52%
M(%3%,0>.0<"?")(-?0():%5%$:$0-$0-)0(7'"5:-):0$(:%0"405%$"#5<%0%6:5-<:(")b04"57-?0
$%::?%7%):0*5-):%,0:"0'5"7":%0<"?")(-?0():%5%$:$
D-)-,(-)0*"2%5)7%):03%):0()0:"05%?"<-:%@0>#(?,0()45-$:5#<:#5%0
K%"'?%0<-)0,5-3045"709%-?:90<-5%@0AZ
K%"'?%0$:(??0<"):%$:039%:9%50[\0$9"#?,09-2%0Q"()%,0D-)-,-0;*"",0:(7%@0"50?"$()*0
(),%'%),%)<%0
[%34"#),?-),0Q"()%,0D-)-,-0()0STUTb0$9"5:?.0-4:%5@0:9%0'5"2()<%0<-7%0#),%50-0
5%)%3%,03-2%0"40'5%$$#5%0:"0L7",%5)(N%L0:9%(50%<")"7.
P".$0^04-:9%5$@07-?%0&()0()09-52%$:
B"7%)0^03"5&03(:90."#)*0<9(?,5%)@0*(5?$0
\")*09($:"5.0"40'-:<93"5&0$#>$($:%)<%039(<90:9%0();$9"5%04($9%5.03-$0-0&%.0<"*039(<90
()<?#,%,04"5-*()*@0?(2%$:"<&
c%<9-)(<-?0$"?(,-5(:./0$-7%0$&(??$%:0-),0-<<%$$@0'%"'?%09-2%0$-7%0$&(??$0-),0?(2%0:9%0
$-7%03-.0
V5*-)(<0$"?(,-5(:./0
K#$9%,0'%"'?%0"440"40:9%0?-),0:9-:0:9%.05%?(%,0")04"50$#>$($:%)<%
K5%;<")4%,/0A<")"7(<0:5-)$(:(")d0^0'5(2-:(N-:(")0"40?-),@0-::%7':$0:"0-::5-<:0(),#$:5.0
87-??0>%,5""70<"77#)(:.
A<")"7(<0,(2%5$(:.@0$&(??%,03-*%0?->"#5%5$0$"<(-?0"5*-)(N-:(")0'-::%5)$0?(&%0
7%:5"'"?(:-)0P5(:-()
K""50)%34(%$0?(2%07"5%0,(*)(4(%,0?(4%
M(%3%,0[\0-$0()%44(<(%):0-),0-$0-0$(:%0:"0>%0(7'5"2%,0:95"#*90'5"*5-77()*
=4:%50Q"()()*0D-)-,-0^0,%2%?"'7%):0'5"*5-77()*0:"0'5"7":%0L7",%5)(:.L0()0-)0
%<")"7(<0$%)$%
Kicking/and/Screaming/Into/the/21st/Century/
A,#<-:(")
E5"70$%-$")-?
8'%<(4(<04"<#$0")0$"<(-?0-),0%<")"7(<0'-::%5)$
V&-.0>%<-#$%0:9%.03(??0>%0>%::%50"440")<%0:9%.0*%:0:9%5%
D-)L:0-44"5,0>5()*()*0-<<%$$0:"0()45-$:5#<:#5%0:"0-??0<"77#)(:(%$@0$"0>%*-)05%?"<-:(")0
():"05-),"70$'":$0()0[\0
D%):5-?(N%,0'5"*5-70He0fff0'%"'?%0()0SSg0<"77#)(:(%$I
!"#$%9"?,$05-:9%50:9-)0'%"'?%0>%<-#$%0(:0($0-0$7-??%50)#7>%50
E($9%5(%$0!"#$%9"?,01%$%::?%7%):0K5"*5-70Hh0hU_09"#$%9"?,$0()0SST0
<"77#)(:(%$I
8%<"),0[\01%$%::?%7%):0=*5%%7%):0H_X_09"#$%9"?,$0()0_U0<"77#)(:(%$I0
+95%%05%?"<-:(")0'5"*5-7$039(<90>%<-7%0*5-,#-??.07"5%0'5%<($%J<"):5"??%,0
P.0:9%0:(7%0$%<"),0-),0:9(5,0'5"*5-7@0."#0")?.03%5%0-??"3%,0:"07"2%0:"0<%5:-()0
<"77#)(:(%$0
D9"(<%0;>#:0)":05%-??.0;:9($0($039-:0<"),#<:0"40<"),#<:0($0
+5.()*0:"0<5%-:%0$9(4:0:"0"5*-)(<0$"?(,-5(:.0;%2%):#-??.0,(,09-''%)0>#:0)":0)"30
HgfL$0;XfL$I
K""50'?-))()*0^0)":0-,%Y#-:%0-<<%$$0:"07%-)$0"40$#52(2-?0"#:$(,%0"40:9%03-*%0
?->"#50%<")"7.039(<903-$0)":0,%2%?"'()*0-$0%6'%<:%,0 ^0'""509"#$()*0-<<%$$
8:5#<:#5%$0<"#?,0)":0->$"5>0-??0:9%0'%"'?%0%6'%<:%,0
c-5*()-?(N-:(")0"403"5&%5$0?(&%0`%"5*%
K5%2("#$?.0;4-7(?(%$03"5&%,0:"*%:9%50:"0$#52(2%@0:9($0($0-0$9(4:0()0,.)-7(<0
K5%$#7':(")0:9-:04%7-?%0-),0<9(?,0?->"#503-$0)":0)%<%$$-5.0:"0$#52(2-?0
+9%03(??0:"0(7'5"2%C
+5.0:"0$%%0-??0<")$%Y#%)<%$
+9%$%0'%"'?%0,(,0)":0:5.0:"07-&%0>-,0,%<($(")$0;9"3%2%50(7'"5:-):0:"0$%%039-:0($0
>%()*0()<?#,%,J%6<?#,%,0()0:9%0'5"<%$$0:"0<5%-:%0 :9($0,%<($(")
=>$"5>%,03"5&%5$0,($'?-<%,0,#5()*05%?"<-:(")$
K%"'?%0>"#*9:0():"04($9%5(%$0;*"2%5)7%):0*-2%0?"-)$0:"0-<<%$$07%-)$0"40
%7'?".7%):0;'5"2(,%,0-#:")"7.0
A<")"7(<0'5"$'%5(:.
STWfL$0;efL$0^0K%<&4"5,/04#5:9%50,%2%?"'7%):0"404($9%5.@0*5-):()*0"40?"-)$04"50()0-),0
"44$9"5%0^0'""50%)2(5")7%):-?07-)-*%7%):
D"#?,0)":04($90D",0-).7"5%0
STT_@0STTh0;'5":%<:(")0"40["5:9%5)0D",0$:"<&$0:95"#*907"5-:"5(#7
Responding/to/Moratorium
\-5*%$:0?-."440()0D-)-,(-)09($:"5.0
STT_0^0_f0fff0?-."44$b0STTh0^0gf0fff0()04($9%5.@0UW0fff0$#''"5:0(),#$:5(%$0?-(,0"44
1%:5-()0'%"'?%@0>#(?,0)%30%<")"7.@0'-5:(<('-:%0()0%<")"7.0%?$%39%5%
V(?0$-),$0>%<-7%02%5.0-::5-<:(2%0:"0'%"'?%0-:0:9($0:(7%
`5"$$0#),%5%$:(7-:(")0"40:9%0$#''"5:05%Y#(5%,0"405%$(,%):$
["5:9%5)0D",0=,Q#$:7%):01%<"2%5.0K5"*5-70H[D=1KI0-),0+9%0=:?-):(<0`5"#),4($90
8:5-:%*.0H+=`8I
What/Does/Newfoundland/Teach/Us
\(0-5*#%$0:9-:0
i".087-??3"",@0P5(-)0K%<&4"5,@0-),0D-)-,(-)0*"2%5)7%):0"44(<(-?$0>%?(%2%,0()0
7",%5)(:.0-$0:9%03-.04"53-5,0-),0:9%.0,%$(*)%,0'"?(<.0:"04-<(?(:-:%0()0:9-:0
,(5%<:(")0(,%"?"*.
i#$:0>%<-#$%0-)0%<")"7(<0,%2%?"'7%):0$:5-:%*.03"5&$0()0")%0'?-<%0,"%$)L:0
7%-)0(:0<-)0>%0#)(4"57?.0:5-)$'?-):%,0:"0-)":9%5
+-)(-0\(@0L+9%0B(??0:"0Z7'5"2%L
Z:0($0<?%-50:9-:0:9%0*"2%5)7%):0"44(<(-?$03%5%0)":0<")$(,%5()*0:9%05"?%0"40)");
7-5&%:0'5-<:(<%$0"40:9%0?")*;:%5707-)-*%7%):0"40:9%0<",0$:"<&0
K-.()*0-::%):(")0:"0$"<(-?05%'5",#<:(")0'5-<:(<%$07-::%5$d
The$State$
+#%$,-.@0 E%>5#-5.0_@0_fSX
SS/hU0=c

Only pages 1-2 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

!"#$%&%%'()*
+#%$,-./01%2(%304"50%6-7
89"5:0-)$3%50;<9"(<%
=>"#:0-''?.()*0:%57$0;&%.0:%57()"?"*.@0#$%0'5"'%5?.0()05%$'")$%0:"0-)$3%5$0
+9#5$,-./0A6-7
=)<%$:"5$0-),0:9%(50'"3%50()0?(4%
B"7%)0-5%09-2()*0:5"#>?%0()0:9%(50?(4%
B5(:%0'-'%50")0:9($C
D-7>",(-0E-<:"5(%$0-5:(<?%0
=)$3%5%,0)%6:0<?-$$
B9-:0($0-08:-:%0-),0!"30F"%$0(:0B"5&C
Governmentality
=<<"#):->(?(:.0"40'"'#?-:(")$0;<"#):@07%-$#5%@0:-60'%"'?%0
!"303%0$9-'%09"30'%"'?%0-<:0
D#?:(2-:(")0"409->(:$0"50G:9%0<"),#<:0"40<"),#<:0HE"#<-#?:I0
A,#<-:(")0$.$:%7@0(,%-$0->"#:0*%),%5@0)":(")$0"4039-:0-04-7(?.0$9"#?,0
?""&0?(&%
D-:%*"5(%$0"<<#55%,@0:9($09-''%)%,0-:0$-7%0:(7%0;,(2(,()*0'"'#?-:(")$04"50
#),%5$:-),()*J7-)-*%7%):0
K-5:0"40:9%0<#?:#5-?05%2"?#:(")$0"<<#55()*0:"0<5%-:%0$'-<%04"50,(44%5%):0:.'%$0"40
%<")"7(%$03-$0:9%05%<"*)(:(")0"40'%"'?%0-$0-0L'"'#?-:(")L039(<90<"#?,0>%07-)-*%,0
:95"#*90,(5%<:0-<:(")0
M("?%)<%0<9-)*%,0;)":0:9%07-()03-.0:"0*%:0'%"'?%0:"04-??0()0?()%0-).7"5%0
E"#<-#?:0;'-()0-),02("?%)<%0
1#?%0($0->"#:0<"%5<(")0-),0<")$%):0
1%<"*)(N%0<-'-<(:.0-$0-*%):$0-),045%%0<9"(<%0;<5%-:%0"5,%50:9-:04-<(?(:-:%$039-:0
<9"(<%$0."#07-&%0
L+"0,"7()-:%0($0:"0(*)"5%0"50:"0-::%7':0:"0<5#$90:9%0<-'-<(:.04"50-<:(")0"40:9%0
,"7()-:%,O0P#:0:"0*"2%5)0($0:"05%<"*)(N%0:9-:0<-'-<(:.04"50-<:(")0-),0:"0-,Q#$:0")%$%?40
:"0(:O0+"0*"2%5)$0($0:"0-<:0#'")0-<:(")R0)":0:"0<5#$90:9%(50H$#>Q%<:$0"40'"3%5I0<-'-<(:.0
:"0-<:@0>#:0:"0-<&)"3?%,*%0(:0-),0:"0#:(?(N%0(:04"50")%L$0"3)0">Q%<:(2%$L0H1"$%0STTT/UI
Policy/As/A/Technology/of/Power
1%*#?-:(")$0<"):5"??()*0>%9-2("#5$
P%)%-:90-0?-3@0,%-?$03(:90%2%5.,-.0>%9-2("#5$0
A)2(5")7%):@07-)-*%7%):@0
V#:?()()*05"?%$@05%$'")$(>(?(:(%$0;39"0<-)0,"039-:@09"30:9()*$0-5%0$"?2%,@0
<"7'?-():$@0
F($<('?()()*0-$0-0'5"<%$$
K"?(<.0-$0-0:""?04"50,"7()-:(")0
K"?(<.0-$0-0&%.0:%<9)"?"*.0"40'"3%5
LRK"?(<.09-$0>%<"7%0-07-Q"50()$:(:#:(")0"40B%$:%5)0-),0():%5)-:(")-?0
*"2%5)-)<%@0")0'-503(:90":9%50&%.0"5*-)(N()*0<")<%':$0$#<90-$0L4-7(?.L0-),0
L$"<(%:.LL0H89"5%0-),0B5(*9:0STTW/XI
LR=$0<#?:#5-?0:%6:$@0-$0<?-$$(4(<-:"5.0,%2(<%$03(:902-5("#$07%-)()*$@0-$0)-55-:(2%$0
:9-:0$%52%0:"0Q#$:(4.0"50<"),%7)0:9%0'5%$%):0R07",%?$0"40$"<(%:.LH89"5%0-),0
B5(*9:0STTW/0WI
89"5%0-),0B5(*9:@0+9%0=):95"'"?"*.0"40K"?(<.
GGGB9-:0($0-#$:%5(:.CCC
Anthropology/of/the/Present
+9($0<-)0<5%-:%0 #)():%),%,0)%*-:(2%0<")$%Y#%)<%$04"50:9%0:-5*%:0'"'#?-:(")
M(%3%,0-$0)":9()*0():%5<"))%<:%,0;->$:5-<:0'%5$'%<:(2%0
D-)0<5%-:%0#)():%),%,0)%*-:(2%0<")$%Y#%)<%$0
Z$$#%$0$#<90-$0#)%7'?".7%):0"50'"2%5:.0-5%05%),%5%,0:%<9)(<-?@0-),02(%3%,0()0
($"?-:(")0"40:9%0<"):%6:$03(:9()039(<90:9%.0"<<#5
!($:"5(<-?0'"?(<.0($0%-$(%50>%<-#$%0(:0($0<?%-50 39-:0<"7%$0:"*%:9%5
8:#,.0:9%0<5%-:(")0"4@0(7'-<:$@0-),0-''?(<-:(")0"40'"?(<.0:"04"570-)0-):95"'"?"*.0"40
:9%0'5%$%):
G$9%0?(&%$0:%570L-):95"'"?"*.0"40:9%0'5%$%):L
8%-?09#):()*0()0[%34"#),?-),J\->5-,"5/0>-5>-5(<0"504%%,()*0."#504-7(?.
+3"0$<-?%$0"40AZ0()0KAZ0;,"%$)]:07-::%5039%5%0."#0?(2%0:9%5%0-5%0)"0Q">$0
-).39%5%@0<"$:0"40?(2()*0($09(*90
D9-)*()*05%:(5%7%):0-*%
8#>$(,(N%0#)(2%5$(:.0%,#<-:(")0
D-)0."#0:9()&0"40-).0'"?(<(%$0:9-:07(*9:0(7'-<:0$"<(-?05%'5",#<:(")0$:5-:%*(%$C
Ethnographic/Example:/Post;Confederation/Newfoundland/
F($<"#5$%05%'%-:%,0()0'"?(<.0:%??$0."#0:9%02-?#%$0
+9%"5(N()*0'"?(<./0E"#<-#?:@089"5%0-),0B5(*9:@01"$%0^0#$()*0:3"0'"?(<.0'5"*5-7$0-),0
$:-:($:(<-?J9($:"5(<-?0()4"57-:(")0:"0,%:%57()%0:9%(50(7'-<:0")0<"):%7'"5-5.0
[%34"#),?-),0-),0$"<(-?05%'5",#<:(")0'-::%5)$0
P%::%50-<<%$$@0,")]:09-2%0:"0?(2%0")0$#>$($:%)<%@0<-)0'-5:(<('-:%0-$0$&(??%,0
?->"#5%5$0()03-*%0%<")"7.
=45(<2(??%0-$0-0*"",0%6-7'?%0"409"30:9($03-$0(7'?%7%):%,0>#:09#5:0:9%0-<:#-?0
'%"'?%0(:03-$0(7'?%7%):%,0")0
Z,%"?"*.0->"#:07",%5)(N-:(")0;?%)$0'"?(<.07-&%5$0-),0*"2%5)7%):0#$%,0
S/05%?"<-:(")0()(:(-:(2%$0;*5"#'0"40:95%%
_/0[D=1K0-),0+=`80;#$%,0:"0:5.0:"05%:5-()0?->"#507-5&%:04"??"3()*0<",0
7-5&%:04-??
=5:%4-<:$
D")<%5:%,0%44"5:0:"05%<5%-:%0 [%34"#),?-),0()0?()%03(:90L7",%5)(:.L0H!"30($0:9($0
<"7'-5->?%0:"0(),#$:5(-?(N-:(")0)-55-:(2%$CI
a%%'0(:0-$0-05%'"$(:"5.04"507")%.0;,")]:03-):0'%"'?%0$%::?()*0:9%5%0
D"#?,0)":0>%<"7%0-).:9()*0>#:04($9%50
K%"'?%03%5%0?%4:0>%9(),04"50:9-:05%-$")0;:9-:03-$0:9%0$%::?%7%):0$:5-:%*.0
E($9()*0*5"#),$0;4(5$:0<"7%04(5$:0$%52%
M(%3%,0>.0<"?")(-?0():%5%$:$0-$0-)0(7'"5:-):0$(:%0"405%$"#5<%0%6:5-<:(")b04"57-?0
$%::?%7%):0*5-):%,0:"0'5"7":%0<"?")(-?0():%5%$:$
D-)-,(-)0*"2%5)7%):03%):0()0:"05%?"<-:%@0>#(?,0()45-$:5#<:#5%0
K%"'?%0<-)0,5-3045"709%-?:90<-5%@0AZ
K%"'?%0$:(??0<"):%$:039%:9%50[\0$9"#?,09-2%0Q"()%,0D-)-,-0;*"",0:(7%@0"50?"$()*0
(),%'%),%)<%0
[%34"#),?-),0Q"()%,0D-)-,-0()0STUTb0$9"5:?.0-4:%5@0:9%0'5"2()<%0<-7%0#),%50-0
5%)%3%,03-2%0"40'5%$$#5%0:"0L7",%5)(N%L0:9%(50%<")"7.
P".$0^04-:9%5$@07-?%0&()0()09-52%$:
B"7%)0^03"5&03(:90."#)*0<9(?,5%)@0*(5?$0
\")*09($:"5.0"40'-:<93"5&0$#>$($:%)<%039(<90:9%0();$9"5%04($9%5.03-$0-0&%.0<"*039(<90
()<?#,%,04"5-*()*@0?(2%$:"<&
c%<9-)(<-?0$"?(,-5(:./0$-7%0$&(??$%:0-),0-<<%$$@0'%"'?%09-2%0$-7%0$&(??$0-),0?(2%0:9%0
$-7%03-.0
V5*-)(<0$"?(,-5(:./0
K#$9%,0'%"'?%0"440"40:9%0?-),0:9-:0:9%.05%?(%,0")04"50$#>$($:%)<%
K5%;<")4%,/0A<")"7(<0:5-)$(:(")d0^0'5(2-:(N-:(")0"40?-),@0-::%7':$0:"0-::5-<:0(),#$:5.0
87-??0>%,5""70<"77#)(:.
A<")"7(<0,(2%5$(:.@0$&(??%,03-*%0?->"#5%5$0$"<(-?0"5*-)(N-:(")0'-::%5)$0?(&%0
7%:5"'"?(:-)0P5(:-()
K""50)%34(%$0?(2%07"5%0,(*)(4(%,0?(4%
M(%3%,0[\0-$0()%44(<(%):0-),0-$0-0$(:%0:"0>%0(7'5"2%,0:95"#*90'5"*5-77()*
=4:%50Q"()()*0D-)-,-0^0,%2%?"'7%):0'5"*5-77()*0:"0'5"7":%0L7",%5)(:.L0()0-)0
%<")"7(<0$%)$%
Kicking/and/Screaming/Into/the/21st/Century/
A,#<-:(")
E5"70$%-$")-?
8'%<(4(<04"<#$0")0$"<(-?0-),0%<")"7(<0'-::%5)$
V&-.0>%<-#$%0:9%.03(??0>%0>%::%50"440")<%0:9%.0*%:0:9%5%
D-)L:0-44"5,0>5()*()*0-<<%$$0:"0()45-$:5#<:#5%0:"0-??0<"77#)(:(%$@0$"0>%*-)05%?"<-:(")0
():"05-),"70$'":$0()0[\0
D%):5-?(N%,0'5"*5-70He0fff0'%"'?%0()0SSg0<"77#)(:(%$I
!"#$%9"?,$05-:9%50:9-)0'%"'?%0>%<-#$%0(:0($0-0$7-??%50)#7>%50
E($9%5(%$0!"#$%9"?,01%$%::?%7%):0K5"*5-70Hh0hU_09"#$%9"?,$0()0SST0
<"77#)(:(%$I
8%<"),0[\01%$%::?%7%):0=*5%%7%):0H_X_09"#$%9"?,$0()0_U0<"77#)(:(%$I0
+95%%05%?"<-:(")0'5"*5-7$039(<90>%<-7%0*5-,#-??.07"5%0'5%<($%J<"):5"??%,0
P.0:9%0:(7%0$%<"),0-),0:9(5,0'5"*5-7@0."#0")?.03%5%0-??"3%,0:"07"2%0:"0<%5:-()0
<"77#)(:(%$0
D9"(<%0;>#:0)":05%-??.0;:9($0($039-:0<"),#<:0"40<"),#<:0($0
+5.()*0:"0<5%-:%0$9(4:0:"0"5*-)(<0$"?(,-5(:.0;%2%):#-??.0,(,09-''%)0>#:0)":0)"30
HgfL$0;XfL$I
K""50'?-))()*0^0)":0-,%Y#-:%0-<<%$$0:"07%-)$0"40$#52(2-?0"#:$(,%0"40:9%03-*%0
?->"#50%<")"7.039(<903-$0)":0,%2%?"'()*0-$0%6'%<:%,0 ^0'""509"#$()*0-<<%$$
8:5#<:#5%$0<"#?,0)":0->$"5>0-??0:9%0'%"'?%0%6'%<:%,0
c-5*()-?(N-:(")0"403"5&%5$0?(&%0`%"5*%
K5%2("#$?.0;4-7(?(%$03"5&%,0:"*%:9%50:"0$#52(2%@0:9($0($0-0$9(4:0()0,.)-7(<0
K5%$#7':(")0:9-:04%7-?%0-),0<9(?,0?->"#503-$0)":0)%<%$$-5.0:"0$#52(2-?0
+9%03(??0:"0(7'5"2%C
+5.0:"0$%%0-??0<")$%Y#%)<%$
+9%$%0'%"'?%0,(,0)":0:5.0:"07-&%0>-,0,%<($(")$0;9"3%2%50(7'"5:-):0:"0$%%039-:0($0
>%()*0()<?#,%,J%6<?#,%,0()0:9%0'5"<%$$0:"0<5%-:%0 :9($0,%<($(")
=>$"5>%,03"5&%5$0,($'?-<%,0,#5()*05%?"<-:(")$
K%"'?%0>"#*9:0():"04($9%5(%$0;*"2%5)7%):0*-2%0?"-)$0:"0-<<%$$07%-)$0"40
%7'?".7%):0;'5"2(,%,0-#:")"7.0
A<")"7(<0'5"$'%5(:.
STWfL$0;efL$0^0K%<&4"5,/04#5:9%50,%2%?"'7%):0"404($9%5.@0*5-):()*0"40?"-)$04"50()0-),0
"44$9"5%0^0'""50%)2(5")7%):-?07-)-*%7%):
D"#?,0)":04($90D",0-).7"5%0
STT_@0STTh0;'5":%<:(")0"40["5:9%5)0D",0$:"<&$0:95"#*907"5-:"5(#7
Responding/to/Moratorium
\-5*%$:0?-."440()0D-)-,(-)09($:"5.0
STT_0^0_f0fff0?-."44$b0STTh0^0gf0fff0()04($9%5.@0UW0fff0$#''"5:0(),#$:5(%$0?-(,0"44
1%:5-()0'%"'?%@0>#(?,0)%30%<")"7.@0'-5:(<('-:%0()0%<")"7.0%?$%39%5%
V(?0$-),$0>%<-7%02%5.0-::5-<:(2%0:"0'%"'?%0-:0:9($0:(7%
`5"$$0#),%5%$:(7-:(")0"40:9%0$#''"5:05%Y#(5%,0"405%$(,%):$
["5:9%5)0D",0=,Q#$:7%):01%<"2%5.0K5"*5-70H[D=1KI0-),0+9%0=:?-):(<0`5"#),4($90
8:5-:%*.0H+=`8I
What/Does/Newfoundland/Teach/Us
\(0-5*#%$0:9-:0
i".087-??3"",@0P5(-)0K%<&4"5,@0-),0D-)-,(-)0*"2%5)7%):0"44(<(-?$0>%?(%2%,0()0
7",%5)(:.0-$0:9%03-.04"53-5,0-),0:9%.0,%$(*)%,0'"?(<.0:"04-<(?(:-:%0()0:9-:0
,(5%<:(")0(,%"?"*.
i#$:0>%<-#$%0-)0%<")"7(<0,%2%?"'7%):0$:5-:%*.03"5&$0()0")%0'?-<%0,"%$)L:0
7%-)0(:0<-)0>%0#)(4"57?.0:5-)$'?-):%,0:"0-)":9%5
+-)(-0\(@0L+9%0B(??0:"0Z7'5"2%L
Z:0($0<?%-50:9-:0:9%0*"2%5)7%):0"44(<(-?$03%5%0)":0<")$(,%5()*0:9%05"?%0"40)");
7-5&%:0'5-<:(<%$0"40:9%0?")*;:%5707-)-*%7%):0"40:9%0<",0$:"<&0
K-.()*0-::%):(")0:"0$"<(-?05%'5",#<:(")0'5-<:(<%$07-::%5$d
The$State$
+#%$,-.@0 E%>5#-5.0_@0_fSX SS/hU0=c
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version