PUB2 111 Lecture Notes - Lecture 10: Jean Valjean, Ant-Zen, Indictable Offence

• School: McGill University
• Department: Public Law 2
• Course: PUB2 111
• Professor: Maxime Hebrard

Document Summary

Provocation becomes a tool to examine one kind of available defence, but also to examine how parliament has limited the defence. Part of the defence exists, but the application is rather narrow. I(cid:374) so(cid:373)e u(cid:374)i(cid:395)ue a(cid:374)d e(cid:454)(cid:272)eptio(cid:374) (cid:272)i(cid:396)(cid:272)u(cid:373)sta(cid:374)(cid:272)es the la(cid:449) sa(cid:455)s i k(cid:374)o(cid:449) (cid:455)ou did it (cid:271)ut (cid:455)ou"(cid:396)e hu(cid:373)a(cid:374) a(cid:374)d (cid:374)ot so st(cid:396)o(cid:374)g that you could have avoided it. When it applies, it does not allow for an acquittal but for the accused to benefit from having it labeled manslaughter instead of murder, in turn, a lighter sentence. We do(cid:374)"t (cid:449)a(cid:374)t to adopt all the (cid:272)ha(cid:396)a(cid:272)te(cid:396)isti(cid:272)s of the individual because then we make it a subjective test, but there is a tension in certain cases how to apply an objective standard. Lamer wants to make it an individual assessment. Scc prefers to stay closer to reasonable person. In myran, raises questions where we should consider unique characteristics/circumstances of person and whether they should benefit from the defence.