LINGUIST 1A03 Lecture Notes - Lecture 7: Free Variation, Vocal Folds, Joule
Document Summary
No since vowel length in the word doesn"t change the meaning of the word. Yes it is because in most contrast where you use it, you have a meaning in the difference. Some variation is meaningful and some variations are not. If you have two sounds different from each other, if the difference between those 2 sounds lead to a different meaning in a given language, than those 2 sounds contrast in that language. Example: [f n] fan and [v n] van is a phonetic difference in voicing. The phonetic difference leads to a substantial difference in meaning. If two sounds are contrastive in a given language then they are considered two difference phonemes in that language. It"s a mental category of phonetically similar sounds and gives them the same label. There may be a phonetic variation within that phoneme, but because that variation is not meaningful, it is not contrastive, don"t treat those segments as different phonemes.