Class Notes (839,476)
Canada (511,349)
Humanities (51)
HUM 102W (25)

07 The Hero and the Heroine - Heracles and Antigone.pdf

6 Pages

Course Code
HUM 102W
David Mirhady

This preview shows pages 1 and half of page 2. Sign up to view the full 6 pages of the document.
HUM102W (Summer 2013) Unit 7 Cherry Fan The Hero and the Heroine: Heracles and Antigone "A plot (mythos) does not have unity... simply because it deals with a single hero. Many and indeed innumerable things happened to an individual, some of which do not go to make up any unity, and similarly an individual is concerned in many actions which do not combine into a single piece of action. It seems therefore that all those poets are wrong who have writtened a Heracleid or Theseid or other such poems. They think that because Heracles was a single individual the plot must for that reason have unity." Aristotle, Poetics 8 1451a Heracles was the greatest of the Greek heroes. Yet because he is mentioned in so many contexts, the roles he plays are many and diverse. It will be important when studying him to distinguish just what the sources allow us to say. Aristotle cautions us against seeing one, unified character. The name Heracles (Hercules in Latin) appears to have something to do with "the glory (kleos) of Hera", (the analogous name for Zeus would be Diocles), but there is really nothing that confirms an original connection to her. In almost all the stories Hera is hostile towards him, hardly the stuff of "glory". We cannot say whether or not the name results from this hostility. Perhaps stories of the hostility resulted from the name. The most succinct picture of Heracles is found in Homeric Hymn 15. It notes his status as a mighty man, his parentage (Zeus and Semele), that he traveled widely, that he committed and endured many reckless things (atasthla) because of Eurystheus, and that he lives now on Olympus (as a god?) married to Hebe (cf. Th 950-5). We long for the details. Why did he do these things for Eurystheus? How did he come to live on Olympus? Perhaps the ordering of the portrayal implies that his living on Olympus is a reward for what he did and endured. That is an inference. What seems clearer is that the portrayal is ambivalent. Heracles both did and endured "reckless" things. Not everything about him is good. The Athenian playwright Euripides wrote an extant play, Heracles, which portrays Heracles killing his wife Megara and their children in a fit of madness induced by Hera, but there is no mention of these terrible events in the earlier poetry. In order to get an accurate idea of how Heracles was viewed in the archaic Greek world, we have to review how he is mentioned in Hesiod and in Homer. No doubt other authors portrayed Heracles in greater detail, but their writings do not survive. We could also make use of vase paintings, but it is difficult to infer too much from them. Birth and Marriage Homer describes the circumstances of his birth in the Iliad 19.95-134. Hera is jealous of Zeus' liaison with Alcmene and lays a trap for him. Zeus has it in mind that Heracles should be a great king, "a man Page 1 of 6 HUM102W (Summer 2013) Unit 7 Cherry Fan who shall be the lord of all them that swell round about" (104). But Hera sees to it that Heracles' cousin Eurystheus is given this honour instead, so that Heracles must eventually labour for him. (This account comes from the lips of Agamemnon, the Greek commander in chief at Troy, who wants to excuse his own folly by citing a case of Zeus' folly. Even if we accept the story, we don't have to accept Agamemnon's inference that Zeus committed a folly. He no doubt wants Heracles to have the opportunity to prove his mettle.) So despite being the greatest of heroes, Heracles is not born to be a king. He is almost a slave. Euripides' Heracles describes the hero's murder of his wife Megara, and Sophocles' Trachiniae portrays his death through the actions of his later wife Dianeira, but Homer and Hesiod are ignorant of these details. Only the Odyssey says anything at all, when Odyssey recounts the women he saw in the underworld: "And Megara I saw, the daughter of Creon, high-of-heart, whom the son of Amphitryon, ever stubborn in might, had as wife" (11.269-70). Deeds Later authors build a great picture of a canonical group of twelve Labours (athloi) of Heracles, together with "side-deeds" (parerga), but there is only a vague picture of them in Homer and Hesiod. The Homeric Hymn tells us that he did and endure many reckless things for Eurystheus. Glimpses of these stories reappear: "... Copreus, who used to convey messages from king Eurystheus to the mighty Heracles. Of him, a father baser by far, was begotten a son better in all manner of excellence." Iliad 15.639-40 A son of Copreus fought at Troy; that's what leads Homer to describe him. Copreus' name is the equivalent of "dungman". Perhaps Homer's negative description of him is based on that. But he must have a bigger story in mind. Copreus travels between Heracles and Eurystheus. Why? Hesiod's Theogony mentions several deeds of Heracles as he dispatches monsters described in Hesiod's catalogue. "Nemean lion, which Hera, the noble wife of Zeus, brought up and made to haunt the hills of Nemea, a plague to men. There he preyed upon the tribes of her own people and had power over Tretus of Nemea and Apesas: yet the strength of stout Heracles overcame him." Theogony 328-31 "... the evil minded Hydra of Lerna, whom the goddess, white-armed Hera nourished, being angry beyond measure with the mighty Heracles. And her Heracles, the son of Zeus, of the house of Amphitryon, together with warlike Iolaus, destroyed with the unpitying sword through the plans of Athena the spoil driver." 314-18 Page 2 of 6 HUM102W (Summer 2013) Unit 7 Cherry Fan "... three-headed Geryon. Him mighty Heracles slew in sea-girt Erythea by his shambling oxen on that day when he drove the wide-browed oxen to holy Tiryns, and had crossed the ford of Ocean and killed Orthus and Eurytion the herds man in the dim stead out beyond glorious Ocean. 289-92 The Nemean Lion, the Hydra, and the "Cattle" of Geryon become three of the twelve Labours, but Hesiod just gives us a glimpse of what appear to be much bigger stories behind each one of them. He doesn't connect any of them to Eurystheus, but Eurystheus' home is indeed Tiryns, where Heracles drives Geryon's oxen. Later authors describe Iolaus as Heracles' nephew, but that information would have to be assumed here. In the Odyssey, Heracles describes in his own words his last labour for Eurystheus. "I was the son of Zeus, son of Cronos, but I had woe beyond measure; for to a man far worse than I was I made subject, and he laid on me hard labours. He once sent me off to fetch the hound of Hades, for he could devise for me no other task mightier than this. The hound I carried off and led forth from the house of Hades; and Hermes was my guide, and flashing-eyed Athena." Odyssey 11.620-26 Hesiod names the hound Cerberus, "who eats raw flesh, the brazen-voiced hound of Hades, fifty-headed, relentless and strong" (311-2). Can we draw any conclus9ions about these early portrayals of Heracles' Labours? With the aid of Iolaus he does them under Eurystheus' directions, which are conveyed by Copreus. They all deal with animals or monsters. Later traditions will characterize them as triumphs over monsters and a domestication of animals to human service. Other References to Heracles In the major surviving works of early Greece, most of which (Iliad, Odyssey, Theogony) you are reading in this course, there are only brief references to Heracles. They all seem to refer to more elaborate stories that have not survived. More importantly, the
More Less
Unlock Document

Only pages 1 and half of page 2 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.