Class Notes (836,862)
Canada (509,935)
Philosophy (540)
PHL105Y5 (123)
Lecture 10

PHL105Y5 Lecture 10: 5.1 Analysis of Berkeley's Master Argument(1)

4 Pages
Unlock Document

Bernard Katz

Berkeley's Master Argument against Material Substance Much of Berkeley’s argument against matter is direcetd against represenational realism, i.e., against the view that we directly perceive ideas but these ideas are caused by external physical substances. But he also argues against the view that we directly perceive material objects themselves. Here is the relevant passage from the Three Dialogues: Phil: . . . If you can conceive it to be possible froany mixture or combination of qualities, or any sensible object whatever, to exist outside the mind, then I will grant it actually to be so. Hyl: By that test, the point will soon be decided.What is easier than to conceive a tree or house existing by itself, independently of and unperceived by any mind whatsoever? I conceive them existing in that way right now. Phil: Tell me, Hylas, can you see a thing which is at the same time unseen? Hyl: No, that would be a contradiction. Phil: Is it not as great a contradiction to talk of conceiving a thing which is unconceived? Hyl: It is. Phil: The tree or house therefore which you think of is conceived by you. Hyl: How could it be otherwise? Phil: And what is conceived is surely in the mind. Hyl: Without question, what is conceived is in the mind. Phil: Then what led you to say that you conceivd ea house or tree existing independently and out of all minds whatsoever? Hyl: That was an oversight, I admit; . . . (Bennett, p. 21). Here Philonous (speaking for Berkeley) contends that we cannot conceive of mind-independent objects, i.e., objects existing unperceived and unthought of. The reas on that we cannot is that in order to think about something, we must ourselves be thinking about it. We can formulate Berkeley’s reasoning as follows: 1 2 1. If we can conceive of a tree existing inde pendently of any mind whatsoever, then wecan conceive of the tree existing unconceived. 2. It is a contradiction to suppose that we can conceive of something that is unconceived. Therefore, 3. We cannot conceive of a tree (or anything else) existing independent and out of all minds. The key idea in this argument is that It is a contradiction to suppose that we can conceive of a thing that is unconceived. The reason that this supposed to be a contradiction isthat in order to conceive of any such thing, we must ourselves be conceiving, i.e., thinking, of it. The problem however is that the phrase we can conceive of a thing that is unconceived is ambiguous: taken one way, it is indeed contradictory; taken in another way it is not. So, Berkeley’s argument rests on that ambiguity. Consider the claim we can conceive of a tree that exists unconceived. This is susceptible of wo possible interpretations: (A) It is possible for us tothink that there is some tree (or other) about which no one is thinking. (B) It is possible for us to think, concerningsome particular tree, that no one is thinking about that tree. (B) is certainly false and contradictory: If we think, concerning x, that no one is thinking about x, then we are thinking about x. Hence, it is impossible for there to be a tree concerning which we think no one is thinking: if there were such aetre it would be one about which someone was thinking and no one was thinking. This would indeed be a contradiction. But it does not follow from this that (A) is false and contradictory. In fact, (A) is exactly what a realist believes, namely, as Hylas puts it, that to exist is one thing, and to be perceived is another. Accordingly, the two premises of the Master Argument are ambiguous. Each is true on one way of interpreting the phrase “we can conceive of a tree that exists unconceived” and false on the other. But there is no consistent interpretation that makes both true. Consider premise
More Less

Related notes for PHL105Y5

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.