ENG308Y1 Lecture Notes - Lecture 3: Lyrical Ballads, Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité, French Revolution
!"#$%&'()*+(,&''&-(./#0(
○
1",#$-(2/#0
3
456(#&''"$78(%#$69($7(:56(2#67%5(#6;/'<:$/7(=6#6(>'$,6#:"?(6@<&'$:"?(.#&:6#7$:">
3
A/#-9=/#:5(=&9(:56#6(&:(:56(:$06
3
B&''"$78(%#"(./#(:56(67:$#6(=/#'-?(:&C67(<D(6;6#"=56#6(&9(&(-60/%#&:$9&:$/7(/.(
:56(9D$#$:?(/.(:56(D/'$:$%&'(=/#'-(&7-(&9(&(,6&%/7(/.(D/:67:$&'(./#(&(76=(=/#'-(
:/(%/06($7:/(,6$78
3
E.:6#(:56(F7'$85:67067:?(60D5&9$9$78(#6&9/7(*'$:6#&:<#6(%/0$78($7(&9(&'0/9:(
9&%#6-
3
456(B/0&7:$%9(#6&''"(:&C6(<D(:5$9(-60/%#&:$%(#6./#0
3
456(8#6&:(-60/%#&:$9&:$/7(/.(%<':<#6($:96'.
3
!$:6#&:<#6(=&9(/.:67(&(%6'6,#&:$/7(/.(5$85(:56069(&7-(5$85(D6#9/7&869(*
#/"&':"?(&#$9:/%#&%"
○
A5&:(=/<'-($:(06&7(./#(%<':<#6?('$:6#&:<#6?(D/6:#"?('"#$%(:/(678&86(=$:5(:56(
-6%/#<0(&7-(D#/D#$6:"/.(GH:5(%67:<#"(D/6:#"
3
I6%&06(&(D&#&7/$-(:"#&77"(=$:5(0&99(6J6%<:$/79?(.&'96(&%%<9&:$/79
○
!$C6(&(96%/7-(.&''(/.($77/%67%6?(96%/7-(.&''(/.(0&7
○
K$9&DD/$7:067:(=567(2#67%5(#6;/'<:$/7(,6%&06(&(,'//-,&:5?(:56(#6$87(/.(
:6##/#
3
L7(GMNH?(A/#-9=/#:5(&7-(O/'6#$-86(D<,'$956-(:/86:56#
3
!"#$%($9(<9<&''"(&99/%$&:6-(=$:5(:56(06-$:&:$;6?($7:6#7&'(#69D/796?(D&99$/7&:6(
$7.<9$/7
3
456(:=/(-/7P:(<9<&''"(8/(:/86:56#
○
456"(=6#6(&0/78(:56(.$#9:(:/(D<:(:560(:/86:56#
○
I&''&-($9(&99/%$&:6-(=$:5(&(D#$0$:$;6(9$7%6#$:"?(&(7&##&:$;6
3
A6(7/('/786#(5&;6(:56(%/7:67:(:/(&99/%$&:6('"#$%&'( D/609(=$:5(5$85(%<':<#6
3
2/#(:56(D<,'$%?(:5$9(=&9(&(9:#&786(:5$78(./#(:560(:/(,6(#6&-$78?(95/%C6-(
6JD6%:&:$/79
3
Q/(A/#-9=/#:5(=#$:69(:56(R#6.&%6(:/(!"#$%&'(I&''&-9(:/(:#"(:/(<7-6#9:&7-(:5&:(
=5$%5($9(0/9:(6'6067:&'(&7-(<7$;6#9&'(:/(5<0&7(7&:<#6
3
S/$78(/<:($7:/(7&:<#6?(:56(%/<7:#"9$-6(:/(678&86(=$:5(D6&9&7:9?(=5/(<96-(:/(
,6(9667(&9(<7=/#:5"(/.('$:6#&:<#6
3
R8T(UNV(*$7:6#69:6-($7(:56(D#$0&#"('&=9(/.(/<#(7&:<#6(
○
>!/=(&7-(#<9:$%('$.6(=&9(8676#&''"(%5/967>(*BFEK(41LQ(REBESBER1(E(
!W4
○
O#<%$&'(./#(/<#(<7-6#9:&7-$78(/.(:56(9/%$/*D/'$:$%&'(9%676(.#/0(=5$%5(
/<#(D/6:#"(:&C69($:9($79D$#&:$/7
○
16P9(:#"$78(:/(-69%#$,6(:56(=&"($7(=5$%5(:56(67:#"($7:/(:56(
#<9:$%X#<#&'XD&9:/#&'(67&,'69(<9(:/(&%%699(:5&:(=5$%5($9(&<:567:$%
○
F7&,'69(<9(:/(0/;6(,6"/7-(:56(9<D6#.$%$&'$:"?(:56(%/0D'6J$:$69(/.(9/%$&'(
Y(%$:"('$.6
○
Z/:(./#(69%&D$78(:56(5<0&7(%/7-$:$/7(/#(&7":5$78?(7/:(:/(69%&D6(.#/0(
%<':<#6
○
L:($9($7(.&%:(:5&:(=$:5$7(:5$9(D&9:/#&'(6JD6#$67%6(=6((#6'6&96-($7:/(&(
9$0D'$%$:"?(&7(&<:567:$%$:"($7(=5$%5(=6(%&7(<7-6#9:&7-(:56(
<760,6''$956-?(<7&-<':6#&:6-(8#/<7-(/.(5<0&7(7&:<#6(*7/:(
/;6#%/0D'$%&:6-(,"(6%/7/0$%X0&:6#$&'$9:(766-?(/#($7:6''6%:<&'(
D#6:67:$/79
○
45$9(,6%/069(%/0D'$%&:6-(,6%&<96(:5$9($9(7/:(&7(&-;/%&%"(./#(>56&#:(
/;6#(56&->(:5$7C$78
○
456#6($9(&(-6D:5(&7-(6;67(&(%<':<#&'(06&7$78(:/(:5$9($006#9$/7(=$:5$7(
#<9:$%('$.6
○
Q/(56(:#$69(:/(6JD'&$7(:5&:(:56('"#$%&'*,&''&-9(5&-(,667(&7(6../#:(
3
I/::/0(/.(UNV(*2/#(&''(8//-(D/6:#"($9(:56(9D/7:&76/<9(/;6#.'/=(/.(D/=6#.<'(
.66'$789[>
3
456(D/6:($9(&(0&7(9D6&C$78(:/(067
○
>A1E4(LQ(E(RWF4\>(*6-$:/#9(-$9%<99$/7(3
A$''$&0(A/#-9=/#:5
But$what?$How$do$you$qualify$those$statements?3
R/6:#"(0&"(:&C6($:9(/#$8$7(.#/0(D/=6#.<'(60/:$/7(,<:(=6((9:$''($7(:56(
#6&'0(/.(D/D<'&#(%<':<#6(&7-(9/(D/6:#"(0<9:(,6(#6$876-($7
○
A5&:(=/<'-(/:56#=$96(,6(:56(%5&/9(/.(:56(9D/7:&76/<9(/;6#.'/=(/.(
D/=6#.<'(.66'$78($9(#6$876-($7:/(&(%/56#67:(./#0
○
456(/'-(D#/D#$6:"(/.(5$9(D#6-69%699/#9($9(7/:(&006'6&,'6(:/(:56(C$7-(/.(
D/6:#"(56(=&7:9(:/(=#$:6
○
16(-/697P:(:5#/=(&=&"(:56(%/7;67:$/79(/.(:56('"#$%(/#(:56(,&''&-?(,<:(
675&7%69(:560
○
16(]/$79(:56(06-$:&:$;6(=$:5(D<,'$%'"(&%%699$,'6(;6#96
○
Q5/=$78(:5&:(:56(D/6:($9(9<D6#$/#(,"(95/=$78(5/=(D/6:#"($9(&('6L-(
9:&:6
○
456(D/6:($9(0/#6($7(:/<%5(=$:5(:56$#(60/:$/79(,<:(D/6:#"(:#&$79(:560(:/(
%/7;6"(:5$9(6..6%:$;6'"
○
16($9(60D5&9$9$78(=5&:($9(0/9:(6'6067:&'(:/(5<0&7(7&:<#6
○
1$9(0/;6(.#/0('"#$%&'(D/6:#"(-$9D'&"9(5$9(-69$#6(:/(0/;6(&=&"(.#/0(
$7:6''6%:<&'$:"( &7-(:/=&#-9(D#$0$:$;$90T(16($9(&=(/.(:56(D<#67699(/.(:56(
0/9:(D#$0$:$;6(./#09(/.(/<#(60/:$/79(&7-(9/(:56(D/6:#"(56(%#6&:69($9(
#6D#6967:&:$;6(/.(:56(0/9:(D#$0$:$;6(./#09(/.(6JD#699$/7?(:#&790$::6-($7(&7(
$7:6''6%:<&'( 96::$78T(45<9(D/6:#"($9(7/:5$78(0/#6(:5&7(60/:$/7(9D$''6-(.#/0(
:56(0$7-(/.(:56(=#$:6#(&7-('&$-(/<:(/7(&(D&86T
3
A6(&99/%$&:6(:56(D&9:/#&'(=$:5(&7(6&96(/.(,6$783
Z/:(D&#:$%<'&#'"(6'68$&%(^7/('/99X'/78$78_(*956(-/697P:(:5$7C(56#(9$,'$789((
8/76
3
456"(%/7:$7<6(/7($7(56#('$.6?(-69D$:6(5/=(:56"(-$6-($7(D&$73
Z/:(&(D/60(/.('/99(/#(8#$6.?(:56#6($9(&7($7:6#D'&"(/.(.66'$78(&7-(,6'$6.3
456('$::'6( 8$#'?(=5/(9D6&C9(=$:5(:56(9=66:?(=//-'&7-(&$#
○
Q56(#6D#6967:9(9$0D'$%$:"(&7-(D<#$:"
○
Q56($9(&(,6$78(7/:("6:(:#/--67(-/=7(,"(%/0D'6J$:$69(&7-(.&'96(
%/79%$/<97699(/.(%$:"('$.6
○
456(&-<':(%/79%$/<97699(5&9(&'0/9:(;/"6<#$9:$%&''"(67%#/&%56-(/7(:56(
D&9:/#&'(5&;67
3
O5$'-5//-($9($7:<$:$;6
○
16#(;$6=($9(<706-$&:6-(,"(%$;$'$9&:$/7?(7/:("6:(%/79:#&$76-(,"(
#69:#$%:$/79
○
Q56(#6%/87$969(&(%/7:$7<$:"((=$:5(56#(9$,'$789(=5/(5&;6(-$6-3
Q56(://(5&9(&%%699(:/(&7(60D$#$%&'(=/#'-
○
>456$#(8#&;69((8#667?(:56"(0&"(,6(9667?>
○
E(5$85(-68#66(/.(9D6%$.$%$:"(./#(&7(<067:(:5&:(9<D6#.$%$&''"(96609(
D#/D/9:6#/<9
○
I<:(956(5&9(;6#$.$&,'6(9D6%$.$%$:"
○
>4=6';6(9:6D9(/#(0/#6(.#/0(0"(0/:56#P9(-//#?(X(E7-(:56"((9$-6(,"(
9$-6>
○
Q56(6;67(5&9(<067:9(8#/<7-6-($7(:56(D5"9$%&'(3
Q56(C7/=9(:5&:(:56"P;6(-$6-?(956(<7-6#9:&7-93
L:($9(7/:(M*U?($:($9(V`U(
○
456(#&:$/7&'(D#/%699($9(7/:(5/=(956(6JD6#$67%69( #6&'$:"(&7-(:56(%/56#67%6(/.(
56#('$.6
3
A6((D#6967:6-(56#6(=$:5(0/-69(/.(D6#%6D:$/7(:5&:(%/06($7:/(%/7.'$%:(=$:5(
6&%5(/:56#
3
I<:(:56(%5$'-P9(%'&$0($9(7/:(<7&7%5/#6-
○
Q56(&'9/(#6'$69(/7(-6:&$'
○
Q56('$;69($7(%'/96(D#/J$0$:"(:/(:56(8#&;69(*956(C7/=9(=5&:P9(<D
○
456(&-<':(5&9(%/79%$/<97699(/.(&(0/-6(/.(.$7&'$:"3
A6(E#6(Q6;67(^R8T(UMH_
>Q=66:($9(:56('/#6(=5$%5(Z&:<#6(,#$789a(X(W<#(06--'$78($7:6''6%:(X(b$9*
95&D69(:56(,6&<:6/<9(./#09(/.(:5$789c** X(A6(0<#-6#(:/(-$996%:T>
○
L7(/#-6#(:/(<7-6#9:&7-(:56(7&:<#6(/.(:5$789(=6(5&;6(:/(#6-<%6($:(:/($:P9(0/9:(
6'6067:&'(D&#:9(&7-(:&C6($:(&D&#:
3
>F7/<85(/.(Q%$67%6(&7-(/.(E#:a(X(O'/96(<D(:5/96(,&##67('6&;69a(X(O/06(
./#:5?(&7-(,#$78(=$:5("/<(&(56&#:(X(45&:(=&:%569(&7-(#6%6$;69T>
○
16($9(&-;/%&:$78(&7($7:<$:$;6(D6#9D6%:$;6(/7(:56(=/#'-(*/76(:5&:(-/697d:(
#6@<$#6(0<#-6#$78(:/(-$996%:
3
b&::56=(:5$7C9(A$''$&0(766-9(:/('//C(<D(&7-(966(=5&:(:56(=/#'-($9(&''(&,/<:3
FJD/9:<'&:$/7(&7-(B6D'"(XX(456(4&,'69(4<#76-
1/=($9(/76(:/(=&:%5(&7-(#6%6$;6( :56(:#<6(7&:<#6(/.(:56(=/#'-($.(/76($9(
7/:(#6&-"(:/('//C(,6"/7-(:56(9<D6#.$%$&'\(A$''$&0(9$:9(/7(5$9(/'-(8#6"(
9:/76(&7-(-#6&09(<D(&(#6&'$:"(&''(5$9(/=7(&9($.(>7/76(5&-('$;6-(,6./#6(
e5$0f(,<:(56($9(7/:(#6&-"(:/(966(,6"/7-(:5696(-#6&09(&9(56(-/69(7/:(
=&7:(:/(-69:#/"(&7":5$78(,6&<:6/<9T(L9(9$0D'"(=&:%5$78(67/<85(:/(:#<'"(
#6%6$;6?(/#($9(0<#-6#(76%699&#"(:/(<7-6#9:&7-(7&:<#6\
○
456(<067:($:96'.($9(=#$::67($7(;6#96(*9/065/=($:($9($#/7$%(:5&:(
A$''$&0( &9C9(<9(:/(>%'/96(<D(:5/96(,&##67('6&;69>T(1/=(%&7(=6('6(
.#/0(,//C9($.(=6(%&77/:(#6&-(,//C9\
○
!6&;69(&'9/(,#$78(<9(:/(:56('6&;69(/.(7&:<#6(*=5$%5(9<8869:9(:5&:(=6(
0<9:('//C(&=&"(.#/0(:56(=/#'-(&':/86:56#\
○
L:($9(&''(D&#:(/.(&7(/#8&7$%(5/'6(,6%&<96(=6('6(.#/0(7&:<#6(
&,/<:(man
!
A6(%&7P:(]<9:(,6($006#96-($7(7&:<#6(&7-(,6($7(:/<%5(=$:5(:56(
=/#'-
!
I<:(:56(;6#7&'(=//-(56'D9(<9(&%%699(9/06(D6#%6D:$/7(/.(:5&:(
=5$%5($9(0/9:(6'6067:&'(&,/<:(5<0&7(7&:<#6
!
A6((7/:($7(:56(#6&'0(/.(&(-$9#68&#-(/.(<7-6#9:&7-$78(/#(/.(
6'6067:
!
A6((/7'"(966C$78(:/(@<&'$."($:9(06&7$78
!
>W76($0D<'96(.#/0(&(;6#7&'(=//-(X(b&"(:6&%5("/<(0/#6(/.(0&7?(
X(W.(0/#&'(6;$'(&7-(/.(8//-?(X(45&7(&''(:56(9&869(%&7T>
!
456(/DD/9$78(;$6=9(%/06(:/86:56#(56#6
!
A6(5&;6(&(%/7:$7<$:"(,6:=667(,//C('6$78(&7-(7&:<#6('6$78
○
456(D/6:(=5/(#6%/87$969(:5&:(D/6:#"(,68$79($7(:56(9D/7:&76/<9(
/;6#.'/=(/.(D/=6#.<'(.66'$78(&'9/(C7/=9($:(0<9:(,6(0&-6(
&%%699$,'6?(%/56#67:(*$:(0<9:(,6(#6%/''6%:6-( $7(06-$&:6-(
:#&7@<$':"
!
!6$78?(<7-6#9:&7-$78($9(&'9/(6JD6#$67%6-(,"(:56(D/6:(*0/#6('$;6'"(
9679$,$':"([((8#6&:6#(C7/='6-86(/.(5<0&7(7&:<#6
○
Is$there$an$ironic$meaning$to$the$terms$of$this$debate?3
Lyrical(Ballads(,Lecture(3
b/7-&"?(Q6D:60,6#( GN?(UgGh
GGcGU(Eb
!"#$%&'()*+(,&''&-(./#0(
○
1",#$-(2/#03
456(#&''"$78(%#$69($7(:56(2#67%5(#6;/'<:$/7(=6#6(>'$,6#:"?(6@<&'$:"?(.#&:6#7$:">3
A/#-9=/#:5(=&9(:56#6(&:(:56(:$063
B&''"$78(%#"(./#(:56(67:$#6(=/#'-?(:&C67(<D(6;6#"=56#6(&9(&(-60/%#&:$9&:$/7(/.(
:56(9D$#$:?(/.(:56(D/'$:$%&'(=/#'-(&7-(&9(&(,6&%/7(/.(D/:67:$&'(./#(&(76=(=/#'-(
:/(%/06($7:/(,6$78
3
E.:6#(:56(F7'$85:67067:?(60D5&9$9$78(#6&9/7(*'$:6#&:<#6(%/0$78($7(&9(&'0/9:(
9&%#6-
3
456(B/0&7:$%9(#6&''"(:&C6(<D(:5$9(-60/%#&:$%(#6./#03
456(8#6&:(-60/%#&:$9&:$/7(/.(%<':<#6($:96'.3
!$:6#&:<#6(=&9(/.:67(&(%6'6,#&:$/7(/.(5$85(:56069(&7-(5$85(D6#9/7&869(*
#/"&':"?(&#$9:/%#&%"
○
A5&:(=/<'-($:(06&7(./#(%<':<#6?('$:6#&:<#6?(D/6:#"?('"#$%(:/(678&86(=$:5(:56(
-6%/#<0(&7-(D#/D#$6:"/.(GH:5(%67:<#"(D/6:#"
3
I6%&06(&(D&#&7/$-(:"#&77"(=$:5(0&99(6J6%<:$/79?(.&'96(&%%<9&:$/79
○
!$C6(&(96%/7-(.&''(/.($77/%67%6?(96%/7-(.&''(/.(0&7
○
K$9&DD/$7:067:(=567(2#67%5(#6;/'<:$/7(,6%&06(&(,'//-,&:5?(:56(#6$87(/.(
:6##/#
3
L7(GMNH?(A/#-9=/#:5(&7-(O/'6#$-86(D<,'$956-(:/86:56#3
!"#$%($9(<9<&''"(&99/%$&:6-(=$:5(:56(06-$:&:$;6?($7:6#7&'(#69D/796?(D&99$/7&:6(
$7.<9$/7
3
456(:=/(-/7P:(<9<&''"(8/(:/86:56#
○
456"(=6#6(&0/78(:56(.$#9:(:/(D<:(:560(:/86:56#
○
I&''&-($9(&99/%$&:6-(=$:5(&(D#$0$:$;6(9$7%6#$:"?(&(7&##&:$;63
A6(7/('/786#(5&;6(:56(%/7:67:(:/(&99/%$&:6('"#$%&'( D/609(=$:5(5$85(%<':<#63
2/#(:56(D<,'$%?(:5$9(=&9(&(9:#&786(:5$78(./#(:560(:/(,6(#6&-$78?(95/%C6-(
6JD6%:&:$/79
3
Q/(A/#-9=/#:5(=#$:69(:56(R#6.&%6(:/(!"#$%&'(I&''&-9(:/(:#"(:/(<7-6#9:&7-(:5&:(
=5$%5($9(0/9:(6'6067:&'(&7-(<7$;6#9&'(:/(5<0&7(7&:<#6
3
S/$78(/<:($7:/(7&:<#6?(:56(%/<7:#"9$-6(:/(678&86(=$:5(D6&9&7:9?(=5/(<96-(:/(
,6(9667(&9(<7=/#:5"(/.('$:6#&:<#6
3
R8T(UNV(*$7:6#69:6-($7(:56(D#$0&#"('&=9(/.(/<#(7&:<#6(
○
>!/=(&7-(#<9:$%('$.6(=&9(8676#&''"(%5/967>(*BFEK(41LQ(REBESBER1(E(
!W4
○
O#<%$&'(./#(/<#(<7-6#9:&7-$78(/.(:56(9/%$/*D/'$:$%&'(9%676(.#/0(=5$%5(
/<#(D/6:#"(:&C69($:9($79D$#&:$/7
○
16P9(:#"$78(:/(-69%#$,6(:56(=&"($7(=5$%5(:56(67:#"($7:/(:56(
#<9:$%X#<#&'XD&9:/#&'(67&,'69(<9(:/(&%%699(:5&:(=5$%5($9(&<:567:$%
○
F7&,'69(<9(:/(0/;6(,6"/7-(:56(9<D6#.$%$&'$:"?(:56(%/0D'6J$:$69(/.(9/%$&'(
Y(%$:"('$.6
○
Z/:(./#(69%&D$78(:56(5<0&7(%/7-$:$/7(/#(&7":5$78?(7/:(:/(69%&D6(.#/0(
%<':<#6
○
L:($9($7(.&%:(:5&:(=$:5$7(:5$9(D&9:/#&'(6JD6#$67%6(=6((#6'6&96-($7:/(&(
9$0D'$%$:"?(&7(&<:567:$%$:"($7(=5$%5(=6(%&7(<7-6#9:&7-(:56(
<760,6''$956-?(<7&-<':6#&:6-(8#/<7-(/.(5<0&7(7&:<#6(*7/:(
/;6#%/0D'$%&:6-(,"(6%/7/0$%X0&:6#$&'$9:(766-?(/#($7:6''6%:<&'(
D#6:67:$/79
○
45$9(,6%/069(%/0D'$%&:6-(,6%&<96(:5$9($9(7/:(&7(&-;/%&%"(./#(>56&#:(
/;6#(56&->(:5$7C$78
○
456#6($9(&(-6D:5(&7-(6;67(&(%<':<#&'(06&7$78(:/(:5$9($006#9$/7(=$:5$7(
#<9:$%('$.6
○
Q/(56(:#$69(:/(6JD'&$7(:5&:(:56('"#$%&'*,&''&-9(5&-(,667(&7(6../#:(3
I/::/0(/.(UNV(*2/#(&''(8//-(D/6:#"($9(:56(9D/7:&76/<9(/;6#.'/=(/.(D/=6#.<'(
.66'$789[>
3
456(D/6:($9(&(0&7(9D6&C$78(:/(067
○
>A1E4(LQ(E(RWF4\>(*6-$:/#9(-$9%<99$/7(
3
A$''$&0(A/#-9=/#:5
But$what?$How$do$you$qualify$those$statements?
3
R/6:#"(0&"(:&C6($:9(/#$8$7(.#/0(D/=6#.<'(60/:$/7(,<:(=6((9:$''($7(:56(
#6&'0(/.(D/D<'&#(%<':<#6(&7-(9/(D/6:#"(0<9:(,6(#6$876-($7
○
A5&:(=/<'-(/:56#=$96(,6(:56(%5&/9(/.(:56(9D/7:&76/<9(/;6#.'/=(/.(
D/=6#.<'(.66'$78($9(#6$876-($7:/(&(%/56#67:(./#0
○
456(/'-(D#/D#$6:"(/.(5$9(D#6-69%699/#9($9(7/:(&006'6&,'6(:/(:56(C$7-(/.(
D/6:#"(56(=&7:9(:/(=#$:6
○
16(-/697P:(:5#/=(&=&"(:56(%/7;67:$/79(/.(:56('"#$%(/#(:56(,&''&-?(,<:(
675&7%69(:560
○
16(]/$79(:56(06-$:&:$;6(=$:5(D<,'$%'"(&%%699$,'6(;6#96
○
Q5/=$78(:5&:(:56(D/6:($9(9<D6#$/#(,"(95/=$78(5/=(D/6:#"($9(&('6L-(
9:&:6
○
456(D/6:($9(0/#6($7(:/<%5(=$:5(:56$#(60/:$/79(,<:(D/6:#"(:#&$79(:560(:/(
%/7;6"(:5$9(6..6%:$;6'"
○
16($9(60D5&9$9$78(=5&:($9(0/9:(6'6067:&'(:/(5<0&7(7&:<#6
○
1$9(0/;6(.#/0('"#$%&'(D/6:#"(-$9D'&"9(5$9(-69$#6(:/(0/;6(&=&"(.#/0(
$7:6''6%:<&'$:"( &7-(:/=&#-9(D#$0$:$;$90T(16($9(&=(/.(:56(D<#67699(/.(:56(
0/9:(D#$0$:$;6(./#09(/.(/<#(60/:$/79(&7-(9/(:56(D/6:#"(56(%#6&:69($9(
#6D#6967:&:$;6(/.(:56(0/9:(D#$0$:$;6(./#09(/.(6JD#699$/7?(:#&790$::6-($7(&7(
$7:6''6%:<&'( 96::$78T(45<9(D/6:#"($9(7/:5$78(0/#6(:5&7(60/:$/7(9D$''6-(.#/0(
:56(0$7-(/.(:56(=#$:6#(&7-('&$-(/<:(/7(&(D&86T
3
A6(&99/%$&:6(:56(D&9:/#&'(=$:5(&7(6&96(/.(,6$783
Z/:(D&#:$%<'&#'"(6'68$&%(^7/('/99X'/78$78_(*956(-/697P:(:5$7C(56#(9$,'$789((
8/76
3
456"(%/7:$7<6(/7($7(56#('$.6?(-69D$:6(5/=(:56"(-$6-($7(D&$73
Z/:(&(D/60(/.('/99(/#(8#$6.?(:56#6($9(&7($7:6#D'&"(/.(.66'$78(&7-(,6'$6.3
456('$::'6( 8$#'?(=5/(9D6&C9(=$:5(:56(9=66:?(=//-'&7-(&$#
○
Q56(#6D#6967:9(9$0D'$%$:"(&7-(D<#$:"
○
Q56($9(&(,6$78(7/:("6:(:#/--67(-/=7(,"(%/0D'6J$:$69(&7-(.&'96(
%/79%$/<97699(/.(%$:"('$.6
○
456(&-<':(%/79%$/<97699(5&9(&'0/9:(;/"6<#$9:$%&''"(67%#/&%56-(/7(:56(
D&9:/#&'(5&;67
3
O5$'-5//-($9($7:<$:$;6
○
16#(;$6=($9(<706-$&:6-(,"(%$;$'$9&:$/7?(7/:("6:(%/79:#&$76-(,"(
#69:#$%:$/79
○
Q56(#6%/87$969(&(%/7:$7<$:"((=$:5(56#(9$,'$789(=5/(5&;6(-$6-3
Q56(://(5&9(&%%699(:/(&7(60D$#$%&'(=/#'-
○
>456$#(8#&;69((8#667?(:56"(0&"(,6(9667?>
○
E(5$85(-68#66(/.(9D6%$.$%$:"(./#(&7(<067:(:5&:(9<D6#.$%$&''"(96609(
D#/D/9:6#/<9
○
I<:(956(5&9(;6#$.$&,'6(9D6%$.$%$:"
○
>4=6';6(9:6D9(/#(0/#6(.#/0(0"(0/:56#P9(-//#?(X(E7-(:56"((9$-6(,"(
9$-6>
○
Q56(6;67(5&9(<067:9(8#/<7-6-($7(:56(D5"9$%&'(3
Q56(C7/=9(:5&:(:56"P;6(-$6-?(956(<7-6#9:&7-93
L:($9(7/:(M*U?($:($9(V`U(
○
456(#&:$/7&'(D#/%699($9(7/:(5/=(956(6JD6#$67%69( #6&'$:"(&7-(:56(%/56#67%6(/.(
56#('$.6
3
A6((D#6967:6-(56#6(=$:5(0/-69(/.(D6#%6D:$/7(:5&:(%/06($7:/(%/7.'$%:(=$:5(
6&%5(/:56#
3
I<:(:56(%5$'-P9(%'&$0($9(7/:(<7&7%5/#6-
○
Q56(&'9/(#6'$69(/7(-6:&$'
○
Q56('$;69($7(%'/96(D#/J$0$:"(:/(:56(8#&;69(*956(C7/=9(=5&:P9(<D
○
456(&-<':(5&9(%/79%$/<97699(/.(&(0/-6(/.(.$7&'$:"3
A6(E#6(Q6;67(^R8T(UMH_
>Q=66:($9(:56('/#6(=5$%5(Z&:<#6(,#$789a(X(W<#(06--'$78($7:6''6%:(X(b$9*
95&D69(:56(,6&<:6/<9(./#09(/.(:5$789c** X(A6(0<#-6#(:/(-$996%:T>
○
L7(/#-6#(:/(<7-6#9:&7-(:56(7&:<#6(/.(:5$789(=6(5&;6(:/(#6-<%6($:(:/($:P9(0/9:(
6'6067:&'(D&#:9(&7-(:&C6($:(&D&#:
3
>F7/<85(/.(Q%$67%6(&7-(/.(E#:a(X(O'/96(<D(:5/96(,&##67('6&;69a(X(O/06(
./#:5?(&7-(,#$78(=$:5("/<(&(56&#:(X(45&:(=&:%569(&7-(#6%6$;69T>
○
16($9(&-;/%&:$78(&7($7:<$:$;6(D6#9D6%:$;6(/7(:56(=/#'-(*/76(:5&:(-/697d:(
#6@<$#6(0<#-6#$78(:/(-$996%:
3
b&::56=(:5$7C9(A$''$&0(766-9(:/('//C(<D(&7-(966(=5&:(:56(=/#'-($9(&''(&,/<:3
FJD/9:<'&:$/7(&7-(B6D'"(XX(456(4&,'69(4<#76-
1/=($9(/76(:/(=&:%5(&7-(#6%6$;6( :56(:#<6(7&:<#6(/.(:56(=/#'-($.(/76($9(
7/:(#6&-"(:/('//C(,6"/7-(:56(9<D6#.$%$&'\(A$''$&0(9$:9(/7(5$9(/'-(8#6"(
9:/76(&7-(-#6&09(<D(&(#6&'$:"(&''(5$9(/=7(&9($.(>7/76(5&-('$;6-(,6./#6(
e5$0f(,<:(56($9(7/:(#6&-"(:/(966(,6"/7-(:5696(-#6&09(&9(56(-/69(7/:(
=&7:(:/(-69:#/"(&7":5$78(,6&<:6/<9T(L9(9$0D'"(=&:%5$78(67/<85(:/(:#<'"(
#6%6$;6?(/#($9(0<#-6#(76%699&#"(:/(<7-6#9:&7-(7&:<#6\
○
456(<067:($:96'.($9(=#$::67($7(;6#96(*9/065/=($:($9($#/7$%(:5&:(
A$''$&0( &9C9(<9(:/(>%'/96(<D(:5/96(,&##67('6&;69>T(1/=(%&7(=6('6(
.#/0(,//C9($.(=6(%&77/:(#6&-(,//C9\
○
!6&;69(&'9/(,#$78(<9(:/(:56('6&;69(/.(7&:<#6(*=5$%5(9<8869:9(:5&:(=6(
0<9:('//C(&=&"(.#/0(:56(=/#'-(&':/86:56#\
○
L:($9(&''(D&#:(/.(&7(/#8&7$%(5/'6(,6%&<96(=6('6(.#/0(7&:<#6(
&,/<:(man
!
A6(%&7P:(]<9:(,6($006#96-($7(7&:<#6(&7-(,6($7(:/<%5(=$:5(:56(
=/#'-
!
I<:(:56(;6#7&'(=//-(56'D9(<9(&%%699(9/06(D6#%6D:$/7(/.(:5&:(
=5$%5($9(0/9:(6'6067:&'(&,/<:(5<0&7(7&:<#6
!
A6((7/:($7(:56(#6&'0(/.(&(-$9#68&#-(/.(<7-6#9:&7-$78(/#(/.(
6'6067:
!
A6((/7'"(966C$78(:/(@<&'$."($:9(06&7$78
!
>W76($0D<'96(.#/0(&(;6#7&'(=//-(X(b&"(:6&%5("/<(0/#6(/.(0&7?(
X(W.(0/#&'(6;$'(&7-(/.(8//-?(X(45&7(&''(:56(9&869(%&7T>
!
456(/DD/9$78(;$6=9(%/06(:/86:56#(56#6
!
A6(5&;6(&(%/7:$7<$:"(,6:=667(,//C('6$78(&7-(7&:<#6('6$78
○
456(D/6:(=5/(#6%/87$969(:5&:(D/6:#"(,68$79($7(:56(9D/7:&76/<9(
/;6#.'/=(/.(D/=6#.<'(.66'$78(&'9/(C7/=9($:(0<9:(,6(0&-6(
&%%699$,'6?(%/56#67:(*$:(0<9:(,6(#6%/''6%:6-( $7(06-$&:6-(
:#&7@<$':"
!
!6$78?(<7-6#9:&7-$78($9(&'9/(6JD6#$67%6-(,"(:56(D/6:(*0/#6('$;6'"(
9679$,$':"([((8#6&:6#(C7/='6-86(/.(5<0&7(7&:<#6
○
Is$there$an$ironic$meaning$to$the$terms$of$this$debate?3
Lyrical(Ballads(,Lecture(3
b/7-&"?(Q6D:60,6#( GN?(UgGh GGcGU(Eb
