Class Notes (920,493)
CA (542,265)
UTSG (45,859)
POL200Y1 (286)
Lecture

Machiavelli Notes - Complete

18 Pages
264 Views

Department
Political Science
Course Code
POL200Y1
Professor
Janice Stein

This preview shows pages 1-3. Sign up to view the full 18 pages of the document.
Machiavelli- The Prince 24/11/10 2:33 PM
Lecture 1: Intro/ Dedicatory Letter
Modernity
Faith in modernity implies faith in a direction, or a process
What does it mean to question modernity? (Modernity or faith)
Modernity forever radicalizes itself
The further down we go; better things will become
Modern view is thought to be the definitive
Semester 1: Modern Thinkers
Semester 2: Ancient Thinkers
1960s
In the 60s modernity was authoritative, but does the authority remain unchallenged?
Modernity/Post Modernity
Liberalism/Marxism (Cuba-N.Korea)
Communist rule in China
Liberal democracy routed communism
Now liberal modernity faces constant strain
No longer are we confident in our liberal modernity (modern global economy)
Mass media, internet contribute to the allure of the third world
Anti-western fanaticism, Marxism
Democracy vs. fascist thought
Reflections of modernity (e.g. Islamic Caliphate)
Jargonistic-we crave progress, as well as fear it
There are many doubts within modernity itself
HOW MANY ARE THE KINDS OF PRINCIPALITIES AND IN WHAT MODES THEY ARE ACQUIRED I
According to Machiavelli there are 2 types of states; Republics and Principalities. He proclaims that he will
only discuss principalities and not states, examining how they may be acquired and governed.
Principalities are either inherited and ling- established or new. So in theyve either been annexed to a ruler
or are used to being free. Hereditary principalities, which are accustomed to being ruled by a prince are
easy to maintain, because tradition of the princes family makes his position stable among the people as long
as he does not make himself hated. Machiavelli tells us of the hardships, acquiring a state presents to a
ruler. In contrast to a republic, which is governed by the citizens, a principality is a princely state
administrated by the prince and his family.
In his note to Lorenzo the new prince, he mentions that republics (conquered by a new prince) are use to
living free, avoiding a discussion on republican government.
Machiavelli strongly favored the republican forms of government himself.
www.notesolution.com
OF HEREDITARY PRINCIPALITIES II & MIXED PRINCIPALITIES III:-
While speaking of hereditary principalities, he says that since it is passed down to family members, any
minimally skilled prince could hold on to it. The challenge however lies in maintaining and governing the
state and its people. He makes several observations in support of his reputation for ruthlessness. On
friendship he particularly mentions that its contradictory not to betray your friends. For every human
being his/her best interest always comes first. Fickleness and selfishness always comes first. We must always
anticipate that others will act in there own interest. Conquering rulers must inevitably injure those they
conquer, concluding that if you must harm them harm them so that they wont retaliate ever. Here
Machiavelli sees the brutality as a part of governing states. Machiavelli believes in using the most efficient
and controlled form of violence
www.notesolution.com
Study Questions for September 17 24/11/10 2:33 PM
The subject of Chapter 2 is of primary interest to what actual or notional reader of
the Prince
?
(Hint: it isnt you or me, unless youre sitting on an hereditary principality that none of the rest
of us knows anything about.) (I do have tenure, but I neither inherited it nor can I pass it on to
my sons.) According to this chapter is that readers entrenched position a safe or an unsafe one?
Will he need Machiavellis advice to maintain his position or could he dispense with it?
Speaking on acquired states Machiavelli says that ruling a new state poses much difficulty for the bloodline
princes rather than ruling the inherited state
Familiarity with the people, and techniques of governing assist in maintaining order among the people and
rulers alike
Hereditary states acquired by fortune are, by the people, preferred to be ruled by a family prince, rather
than a new ruler
Trust and comfort with ways of ruling are factors that enable the people to have such opinions. However,
for the ruler himself; a new principality can give rise to many oddities, for instance; hatred of the people,
challenges in establishing new rule, getting to know the allies, and neighboring states and rulers alike.
Essentially the hereditary prince has an easier time gaining the love of his subjects than a new one
Here I believe thaT Machiavellis ADVICE IS MEANT FOR THE ACTUAL READER OF THE PRINCE, WHO IN THIS CASE IS
LORENZO.
M SUGGESTS THAT LORENZO NEED NOT DO MUCH TO BE WHERE HE IS, BUT TO MAINTAIN HIS POSITION AND HOLD ON THE
PEOPLE AND STATE IT WOULD BE WISE TO ACCEPT MS ADVICE. Lorenzos fortune does not have the ability to rule a
state and not gain the hatred of its people.
In a well constructed book, we would expect Chapter 2 to deal with one subject, Chapter 3
to deal with another. And so it seems in
the Prince
: Chapter 2 deals with how to keep an old
principality, Chapter 3 with how to acquire a new one. So when we get to the first paragraph of
Chapter 3 weve left the (nonexistent) perils of hereditary princes behind us, and Lorenzo
snoozing peacefully on his throne. Weve moved on -- or have we?
King louis xii made five distinct errors
he destroyed the minor powers,
he increased the strength of one of the greater powers in Italy,
he brought in a foreign power,
he did not settle in the country,
he did not send colonies
we havent moved on, this is an example or more like a lesson to new princes
Machiavelli uses examples from his time to teach the more contemporary princes
www.notesolution.com

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
Machiavelli- The Prince 241110 2:33 PM Lecture 1: Intro Dedicatory Letter Modernity Faith in modernity implies faith in a direction, or a process What does it mean to question modernity? (Modernity or faith) Modernity forever radicalizes itself The further down we go; better things will become Modern view is thought to be the definitive Semester 1: Modern Thinkers Semester 2: Ancient Thinkers 1960s In the 60s modernity was authoritative, but does the authority remain unchallenged? ModernityPost Modernity LiberalismMarxism (Cuba-N.Korea) Communist rule in China Liberal democracy routed communism Now liberal modernity faces constant strain No longer are we confident in our liberal modernity (modern global economy) Mass media, internet contribute to the allure of the third world Anti-western fanaticism, Marxism Democracy vs. fascist thought Reflections of modernity (e.g. Islamic Caliphate) Jargonistic-we crave progress, as well as fear it There are many doubts within modernity itself HOW MANY ARE THE KINDS OF PRINCIPALITIES AND IN WHAT MODES THEY ARE ACQUIRED I According to Machiavelli there are 2 types of states; Republics and Principalities. He proclaims that he will only discuss principalities and not states, examining how they may be acquired and governed. Principalities are either inherited and ling- established or new. So in theyve either been annexed to a ruler or are used to being free. Hereditary principalities, which are accustomed to being ruled by a prince are easy to maintain, because tradition of the princes family makes his position stable among the people as long as he does not make himself hated. Machiavelli tells us of the hardships, acquiring a state presents to a ruler. In contrast to a republic, which is governed by the citizens, a principality is a princely state administrated by the prince and his family. In his note to Lorenzo the new prince, he mentions that republics (conquered by a new prince) are use to living free, avoiding a discussion on republican government. Machiavelli strongly favored the republican forms of government himself. www.notesolution.comOF HEREDITARY PRINCIPALITIES II & MIXED PRINCIPALITIES III:- While speaking of hereditary principalities, he says that since it is passed down to family members, any minimally skilled prince could hold on to it. The challenge however lies in maintaining and governing the state and its people. He makes several observations in support of his reputation for ruthlessness. On friendship he particularly mentions that its contradictory not to betray your friends. For every human being hisher best interest always comes first. Fickleness and selfishness always comes first. We must always anticipate that others will act in there own interest. Conquering rulers must inevitably injure those they conquer, concluding that if you must harm them harm them so that they wont retaliate ever. Here Machiavelli sees the brutality as a part of governing states. Machiavelli believes in using the most efficient and controlled form of violence www.notesolution.com
More Less
Unlock Document


Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit