Topic 8: Religion. Religion.

16 views8 pages
Published on 16 Oct 2011
Topic 8 Religion (Week 8 lecture + NS Chp 13 + SIQ Chp 7)
Sociologists approaches of religion
-- The question of whether god exists is not answerable from a sociological perspective, and is not at
the interest of sociologists.
-- Instead, sociologists deal with:
- Cause and effects of religious affiliation:
- Under what circumstances does religion serves as acts of social stability?
- Under what circumstances does religion serves as forces of social change?
- how does religions differ across people, time and space?
- Origins of religions:
- Why are people religious? Who are more religious than others?
- How are we becoming less religious?
William Jamess quote (see slides)
Karl Marxs quote (Opium of the People)
-- The quote underscores Marxs position in religion and economy;
-- Argues the anesthetic affects of religion: people, particularly the poor, are drawn to religion like
opium to escape their painful economic position;
-- Religion leads people to be passive, submissive, inactive towards unjust social conditions;
-- People will not be motivated to change to current situation.
Divine Control
-- Divine Control: God has determine its influence on the good and bad sides of peoples lives; an
individual’s life lies according to Gods will and Gods plan;
-- In Western culture God intervenes in peoples most trivial daily life; it influences political decisions,
especially in the US;
e.g. Joe Biden on the eve of his US Presidential election, starts his speech by god willing…”
-- different mental representations; given human and gender attributes: master, father, friend, mother,
savior, healer..etc
-- Divine controls have roots in all religions;
-- Some people feel intimate bonds with God, feel God as a conscious being who is omnipotent and
knows everything; God has explicit expectation for everyone much like parents.
SES Socioeconomic Status
-- Socioeconomic Status (SES) of an individual = Yearly Income of the individual + Highest level of
education he/she attained;
-- Indication of ones class;
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-3 of the document.
Unlock all 8 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in
Two theories about why people are religious:
-- Deprivation-Compensation Thesis
-- Demythologization Thesis
1. Deprivation-Compensation Thesis (def-slide)
-- Similar to the Marxs opium analogy;
-- Reliance on an omnipotent, all-knowing God can offset the depressing and worrisome real life, bad
working condition, unemployment, low pay, bad living condition;
-- People of lower SES tend to be more likely to seek out god in prayer, higher level of interaction of god,
feel greater connections with GOD, more belief in the divine control of God;
-- people of lower SES also derive more physiological benefits from being religious; positive health of
mental health
-- e.g. black church is of central importance to the black community who occupy a low class in American
society; the black church, despite for its functions, provides comfort from god, comfort needed to face
the discrimination, economic disadvantages, day-to-day hardship.
2. Demythologization Thesis
-- Higher socioeconomic (SES) status diminishes the belief in the supernatural-mythological orthodoxy of
-- Same outcome as 1 (lower SES = more religious), but for quite different reasons:
-- People who receive more education see life as not controlled by god, but in rational terms by
observable forces;
-- People of high SES report lower level of devotions to God;
Study of the Effect of Prayer on health
-- Dr. Herber Benson in Boston; the study involves 1802 patients and 6 hospitals
-- All patients have similar cordial conditions, all received the same surgery
-- Patients are divided into 3 groups: 1) pray/unknown; 2) pray/known; 3)no pray/unknown;
-- Clever design: effect of prayer because you know it? Or its simply because you are prayed.
-- Prayers are simple and same for every patients;
-- results: - prayers have no effect on recovery.
- 1 and 3 (who did not know): no difference
- 1 and 2 (who did know): 59% in group 2 had complications, while 52% in group 1 had
complications. People who are told of the prayer did worse.
Religious Extremism
-- A term used to describe the actions or ideologies of religious individuals or groups outside the
perceived center of a given religion; or otherwise claimed to violate common moral standards of a
given religion.
-- has no home in any particular religion; no religion has a monopoly of religious extremism;
-- varies across time and space, and across different religious groups;
-- No matter how unorthodox a given set of belief it is, if thats the norm, then it really cannot be called
a religious extremism;
-- e.g. medieval Europe, over 50,000 women burned alive on the charge of witchcraft;
-- The act itself does seem to be sickly and extreme, but its not a case of a religious extremism,
because its common in that religious practice, though it doesnt make it right to do these things;
-- an extreme act IS NOT EQUAL TO religious extremism; should consider the act in the relative context
within the religion;
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-3 of the document.
Unlock all 8 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in
-- Example of religious extremists: The Phelps family and the Westboro Baptist Church
- known for Christian extremely belief and hate towards homosexuals;
- US has become a country of sinners and bound for hell;
- All bad things are acts of retribution that caused by the angry God;
- Most sinned: homosexuals;
- Most western countries are going to hell because they protect homosexuals;
- they assert that their beliefs are decreed by God by reading the Bible literally and taking every
word as a direct communication from God;
-- e.g. video
- Selective, literally biblical tradition “billions of people are killed during the time of Noah; women
who have affairs are killed; homosexuals are killed;
Guest Lecture: Religion and Secularism in the Modern West Brian Carwana;
Central Question: does religion erode in the West?
Leads to the secondary question: How do social structures affect religious beliefs, practices and identities?
-- the structural separation of society into different spheres;
(e.g. education, government, commerce …and religion)
-- Previously, religion in the West permeated all aspects of life
Question: Does Secularism Erode Religion?
The Yes Case Steve Bruce: 4 ways that secularism erode religion
1. Rationalism:
-- Gains in technology and scientific understanding leaves less room in everyday life for explanations
based on divine intervention and the demonic (latter almost disappears);
-- e.g. when you are sick, its because you get a cold, not because you are cursed; and you go to a doctor
for a treatment instead of a priest for prayers.
-- doesnt mean you dont pray anymore; its just less rooted;
2. Diversity:
-- Increased religious and cultural diversity due to new religions and geographic and economic mobility
-- First Step: Protestant Reformation Martin Luther;
-- Cross-religious and cultural diversity; less likely to hold on to exclusive truth; less likely to demonize
other religions;
-- Rise of nation states requiring cultural unity despite growing religious diversity; therefore they opt for
religiously neutral secular spaces;
-- Sate based on citizenship (political identity), not religious identity;
-- e.g. we may be Protestants, Catholics, Hindus, but we are all Canadians.
Unlock document

This preview shows pages 1-3 of the document.
Unlock all 8 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in

Get OneClass Grade+

Unlimited access to all notes and study guides.

YearlyMost Popular
75% OFF
Single doc


You will be charged $119.76 upfront and auto renewed at the end of each cycle. You may cancel anytime under Payment Settings. For more information, see our Terms and Privacy.
Payments are encrypted using 256-bit SSL. Powered by Stripe.