Class Notes (809,486)
Canada (493,751)
Sociology (3,203)
SOC201H1 (76)

lect 9.docx

4 Pages
Unlock Document

University of Toronto St. George
Charles Jones

SOC201 Lecture 9 Functionalism  In studying Weber, we have already encountered an ingredient of functionalist reasoning. This is the idea of unanticipated consequences.  The Calvinists’ ‘otherworldy’ concerns ensured their economic success. Their economic success was thus an unanticipated consequence, because they were not actually concerned with gaining monetary wealth.  An example of functionalist analysis: the political machine (Robert K. Merton 1910-2003)  Merton was an American sociologist  Political machine: He referred to political organizations at the city level in the US from the late 1800-1900s that used a system in which politicians exchange favors for votes. (clientelism)  Merton is thinking of places like New York City, Boston, and Chicago, which are all full of polish, Italian, and Irish immigrants. They migrated to America and had low ethnic status. Thus, a politician would go to a polish neighborhood, for example, and do favors for them (i.e. language help, housing permits, provide jobs) in exchange for votes at election time.  Merton argues that this system had 2 unanticipated consequences:  It allowed these immigrants, who were poor, to get welfare without humiliating themselves. The local politician helped them to get by, while saving their dignity.  This occurred because the language used between a politician and his client is the language of friendship. That is, there was a human bond, which prevents them from becoming crassly calculated and promotes a standard of equality.  It provided a mechanism for social mobility for outsiders.  The local politician who was from a ethnically subordinate group was enabled to move up in society  We might see this relationship as corrupt, but Merton is not passing moral judgement. He is solely looking at its positive outcome for society.  The nature of functionalist reasoning (Talcott Parsons, 1902-1979)  What does it mean to explain – one way is to make something unfamiliar to a person familiar by drawing on an analogy. Another is a causal explanation.  The logic of functionalist explanation is to explain phenomena in terms of their consequences. Merton explains the political machine by its consequences for society.  Functionalist thinking is inspired by biology – in the study of organisms, the function of an organ and its contribution to one’s overall wellbeing explains its function. The same is true for social phenomena.  Functionalist reasoning in the sociology of religion (structural functionalism)  Society binds its members together.  Religion must be understood in terms of its contribution to the overall wellbeing of society  Religion binds people in society together  It provides shared values  This enables society to function  Criticisms:  Assumes society is unified by religion  Functionalism holds that society holds people together, but historically, religion has led to conflict. (i.e. bloody wars of religion in the 15 and 1600s)  Assumes different (or no) religious beliefs undermine social unity  In fact, it may be that people of different religions are just as integrated in society and hold similar beliefs. We cannot make the assumption that they do not share the values of society.  Assumes a close fit between religious beliefs and those of society  In fact, religious beliefs can be out of step with those of the rest of society (i.e. catholic church’s ideas on birth control and abortion, Christian beliefs that attack genetic research, Quakers are against military service) What Happened to the Protestant Ethic: Answers from Two American Scholars  Weber makes a very limited contextual argument. He is not saying that wherever Protestants live there will be capitalism. His argument is focused to a certain time period and context and that afterwards the relationship between capitalism and religion loosened.  Daniel Bell, The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism (1976)  He says that the protestant ethic lived on to rural and small-town America  There was a very heavy emphasis placed on morals and social respectability – to work hard makes one morally superior, sobriety and frugality was valued
More Less

Related notes for SOC201H1

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.