Class Notes (837,605)
Canada (510,370)
Philosophy (1,299)


5 Pages
Unlock Document

Philosophy 2074F/G
Dean Proessel

Freeman, "managing for stakeholders" Humanity argument "To createvaluefor stakeholders, executivesmust understandthat businessis fully situatedin the realm of humanity. Businessarehumaninstitutionspopulatedby real live complex humanbeings. Stakeholdershavenamesandfacesandchildren.They arenot mereplaceholdersfor social roles. As such, mattersof ethicsareroutinewhenonetakesamanaging for stakeholdersapproach." (P.6 4) Social roleargument-social rolein relateto theprinciple. Meansthemanagersis not merely anagent. Thisapproachsolvessomeof theproblemsof thedominant model Thedominant model (stockholder model): Managerial capitalism with shareholdersatthecenter, springsfrom aseparation betweenmanage ment andownership. Increasing shareholder valueis thusparamount. Executiveincentiveplansaretiedto acompany's stock. In other words, it is anormativemodel with too many problemsandexceptions Not Consistent with basic ehics Separation fallacy "X is abusinessdecison" "X is anethical decision" -A businessdecision cannot beseperatefrom ethical decision. Thereis nosuchthing asapurebu sinessdecision. -To seperatebusinessandethical, any act which you might consider abusinssdecision canalsob ecalled asanethical decision. -Theopenquestion argument supportstheseparation fallacy. Theopenquestion argument 1if thedecision is madefor whom is valuecreatedor destryed? 2Whois harmedandor benefitedby this decision? 3Whoserightsareenabledandwhosevaluesarerealizedby this decision? 4What kind of personwill I becomeif we makethedecison? -Someonegot impactednegatively. Theother is thepoint, is all ethical caresabout. Thebusiness decision is all about it. -what kind of personami? Cani live with suchdecision?Cani let my kidsbeimpactedby my de cision?Cani sleepat night?That is what i standfor. I want to set anexamplefor theworld. -Whenyou ask thesefour quesions,anybusinessdecisionsyou madewill involvethe"Others", a ndtherefore, becomseaethical decision. -Thisis something that motivatesFreeman'spaper. -Pg76suggesting all contractersareall equal.-stakeholder model -thewholeidea: weactually have"nexusof contracts"- persueequality -Freemandoesnot buy thepriviligeof shareholder'sidea. Introduction paragraphs: Eachof stakeholder groupsshould betreatedasend, not to betreat asmeansto servicesomeend. To treat all eachstakeholder groupasend, best way to achievethat endis to let themall participat ein thefirm'swell being. -thequestion: "To whosebenefit andat whoseexpenseshould thefirm bemanaged?" At thetimehewrotetheessay, both legally andeconomiclly, this is thecase.That changesin thel awin somesensereflectsthegeneral wishes/wills of thepeople, representation is important. If it i sthewill of thepeople, firmsshould actsmoreonthesocial role to benefit people. Law makers, r eformerskeepholding corporationsinto account, whendoing so. Legal argument -thelaw constrainscorpor
More Less

Related notes for Philosophy 2074F/G

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.