Class Notes (834,334)
Canada (508,490)
York University (35,156)
Social Science (3,019)
SOSC 1375 (193)
Lecture

SOSC 1375 Lecture - Legal Pluralism, Indigenous Perspectives
Premium

by Anu J
3 Pages
147 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Social Science
Course
SOSC 1375
Professor
Olena Kobzar
Semester
Fall

Description
- Aboriginals in jail - Responsibility vs. culpability o Responsibility = responsible for the crime o Culpability = who will be blamed? - Law and society o All societies have laws  Doesn’t have to have a background/basis  Can be unwritten o Laws grow from customs, social behavior and norms  Discriminatory  Emerging from moral panic and societal issues  Law can be regressive in response to fear o Law draws a boundary of acceptable and not acceptable - Legal pluralism = two or more legal systems coexisting together in a geographic area o What is law?  Codified system of rules  Institutions of the state  Courts  Parliament  CSIS  Corrections institutions (prisons, police stations, etc.)  Normative order within a social group  Set of rules, and process through which those rules are enforced - The courts in Canada o 1996: Canadian Criminal Code amended (sec. 718.2e)  Overrepresentation of aboriginal people in jail  Specifically instructs judges to look for alternatives in imprisonment for aboriginal people (to “soften” the sentence) o Jails are inefficient (bad)  Swedish jails give massages and create “better” people (less criminal)  Separate society from the individual  Make better criminals  Criminal networking o Sample case: Gladue (1999)  19 years old, Aboriginal, birthday, pregnant  Though the boyfriend was cheating with the sister  Got drunk, stabbed the boyfriend twice, died  No previous convictions… minor one for drinking and driving  Courts have to decide what to do  Aboriginal women have a high level of re-offending  We should give her a different process than other Canadian women  Fair or not?  YES o According to readings, Aboriginals already face punishment in their communities so they shouldn’t be double-punished o Take into account the circumstances of the individual  She had kids and they would have to put her away  Makes more sense to not send her to jail o Create sense of equality because it would compensate for their differences and their attempts to assimilate with the Western court systems o Canada is multicultural and we should try to be culturally-specific o Not necessarily a lighter sentence, but just a different sentence - Aboriginal laws o Importance of Elders  Source of law in the community  Wisdom, life experiences  Socio-legal system based on elders o Healing: body, mind, spirit  If something was wrong or they did something wrong, they needed to be healed  Important for the person who did wrong, and for their community o Harmony as an overriding principle in disputes and Creation stories  Restoration of harmony is a basic principle  Emerged from original ancestry  Community-based  Lived off the land with the help of the community members  Legal system evolved to have harmony be central to the Aboriginals o “Not Guilty Plea” to a charge for which a person is responsible for  Western tradition:  Not dishonest or disrespectful  Even if you committed the crime, you can plead guilty  Do what you have to do to “win”  Aboriginal tradition:
More Less

Related notes for SOSC 1375

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit