PHLB09H3 Lecture Notes - Surrogacy, Congenital Disorder, Natalism
Document Summary
Ivf is unnatural but that doesn"t mean we should reject it because everything in medicine is almost unnatural. Should be up to the couplet that separating reproduction and sex will have any harmful consequences to marriage. Better to exist with birth defect than not to exist, justifies too much (in cases where the child suffers every moment) Argues against social justice (better off to adopt than creating another child): rules are not imposed on fertile couples to have children, therefore unfair to refrain infertile couples from having children. Arbitrary distinctions on fertile and infertile couples: should treat them equally, does not view infertile couples should spend money on resources they see fit. ); argues against this view: women don"t give informed consent to have babies because of social pressure, but doesn"t follow that having the option of. Macrolevel concerns on broader views of woman in society etc (ex: whether.