Study Guides (248,540)
Canada (121,617)
History (276)
HIS102Y1 (53)
Quiz

Elizabeth and Protestantism

6 Pages
105 Views
Unlock Document

Department
History
Course
HIS102Y1
Professor
Jennifer Mori
Semester
Fall

Description
Elizabeth and Protestantism • Political/monarchical account of reformation vs popular culture and belief aspect –how ppl’s beliefs change; what took place in churches; how did they experience this change from 1530s • Elizabeth easily the most successful tudor monarchs – ruling the country; keeping the love of subjects (at a cost – never married); lack of heir problem didn’t go away with Henry • She died in 1603 – passed to James Stewart/Stuart of Scotland • French name (allies of Scots) • Relationship b/w Elizabeth and James is tenuous – her aunt, Henry’s sister Margaret had married into Scottish royal family in 1503 • So James is Margaret’s great-grandson • By beginning of 17 c., Tudors have run out of protestant heirs – big issue • So Stewart family is suitable b/c they are guaranteed to keep church of England on protestant path set by Elizabeth • Her political advisors esp. last chief minister, Robert Cecil, played a very important part in transferring of monarchical power from Elizabeth to James • This is b/c Elizabeth kept ppl guessing about her ultimate intentions as she aged to ensure power remained in her own hands – but created confusion • James’ transition into throne was not so clear to subjects of England at the time • Elizabeth – smarter than Mary; better political survivor • She had to put up with much uncertainty and hardship before coming to throne: bastardized by her father, illegitimate following Edward’s birth – first in henry’s affections; rules of royal inheritance – boy trumps • Illegitimacy later revoked by henry b/c another 3 marriages after death of Seymour, there were no more male kids • And apparent that it was sensible to put mary and Elizabeth back on the throne b/c kids were not materializing • Elizabeth and mary were never sure where they stood in their father’s eyes • Elizabeth was trusted by mary even though she had a closer relationship with her rather than Edward – e.g. she was put under house arrest under mary’s reign; her servants were paid spies; Elizabeth had to manage herself with care so not to spark off accusations/suspicions of treasonable behaviour • Elizabeth has to combat the patriachalism/discriminatory gender beliefs of the time – weak monarch b/c she was a woman • She overcame these obstacles by; not marrying; on ability and intelligence e.g. how she dealt with the matter of religion • Installation of new protestant church – new acts of supremacy and uniformity had to be passed • First one – all acts of supremacy make monarch official head of church of England • But Elizabeth’s act was different from Edward’s and henry’s b/c she didn’t act as much of a policy-maker for the church • Unlike henry VIII and Edward, she saw her role as a custodial one; a more super-intending one than managerial – hands off with dealings with church; left decision-making to arch-bishop and bishops • This is sensible b/c they don’t have theological training; respect of clergy; not a good realm to meddle in; above conflicts that might arise – can be a mediator b/w warring religious groups; shielded from hostility to unpopular changes in religious policy • She was a conservative protestant – kept ornamented silver plates in private chapel (reminiscent of catholic religious ritual and commitment –so conservative views); she disliked married priests; • But despite these personal views, she wanted to keep crown distant from theological disputes • So 1563 39 articles of religion that the church of England gets are moderate; compromise religious settlement; tries to give something to everybody in terms of the political and religious opinion at the time • Man who master—minded composition of articles is her first arch-bishop of Canterbury, Mathew parker • Extracts from articles – they seem to contradict each other in certain respects – so a moderate settlement • Depending on what kind of protestant you are, you can glob on certain aspects of the articles and prioritize them in your faith/worship • It is a protestant church as salvation by faith lies at core of belief; individual’s relationship with god is clearly placed above relationship with priests or other intermediaries • The catholic mass is decisively abolished – no miracles, transubstantiation • Good works are placed after faith in order of importance (12); good works cannot put away our sins (no indulgences, or buying grace) • Although works are useful; in church or England it is charity or leaving money to church = good works • Problems arise in interpreting article 17 – declaration in favour of predestination and election • Predestination as a belief had not commanded much support in England before mary took throne • But pucture changes over 1550s b/c many protestants fled to other countries to avoid maryian persecutions – refugees in continental Europe (e.g. Geneva – model community for Calvinists) • Church-state; theocracy – church elders or minister cooperate with civilian authorities in governing town • When Elizabeth takes throne, all those refugees return to England • So they are demanding recognition for their beliefs as part of compensation to flee – lost houses, relatives, etc • So this is partly why this article is there • Lutheran persuasion – prioritize #10 on free will • Articles are unclear about role of will and faith actually are in salvation of individual • What exactly are you supposed to be doing to get to heaven? This is deliberate – must fuse protestants of different theological backgrounds under one umbrella • Elizabethan church has been called a broad church – b/c that is what it represents • Only the literate or middling sort does theological doctrine matter – debate is vehement e.g. robes priests should wear; how ornate/rituals – sensuous = Catholicism • Puritans see cathedrals as inappropriate edifices for worship of god • Ordinary ppl don’t really care about this; they have gone through bewildering set of religious changes since 1530s – disappearance of monasteries, introduction of new style bibles and religious services • This was reversed under Mary – papal authority, catholic ritual, latin bibles restored but again under Elizabeth, this was changed • Why does English reformation happen with little bloodshed? – ppl were confused, didn’t know what to make of changes taking place and so stuck to old belief system until Elizabeth came to throne • Date the English reformation – traditional date is original act of supremacy and launching of Henry VIII’s divorce – placing start date 1532-33 • If we are assessing impact of reformation by the number of ppl who genuinely converted to Protestantism you have to start it with reign of Elizabeth – go in at least 5 years so church reform can take hold and ppl can actually start believing; • So we have a significant time hiatus involved • There are middle of the road answers – reformation starts as an elite, educated literate phenomenon in the 1530s with ppl at the top of the ladder and trickles down • But a lot depends on how you see the process of religious change taking place and how much commitment is involved- complicated factors • English clergy didn’t protestant that much – issue of shock; issue of stern messages from Crown that dissent will not be tolerated • Thomas More, lord chancellor of England at time of Henry’s divorce – famous for Utopia, man of great learning, internationally recognized author, strong catholic • Prot
More Less

Related notes for HIS102Y1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit