Textbook Notes (368,795)
Canada (162,165)
POLS 3130 (87)
Chapter 7-12

Morgentaler v Borowski Ch. 7-12.docx

7 Pages
193 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Political Science
Course
POLS 3130
Professor
Dennis Baker
Semester
Winter

Description
Chapter 7 Joe Borowski o Appointed to cabinet in 1969 - Minister of transport and minister of Public Works - Together held largest budget o Known for honesty and hard work - Didn’t take bribes or like corruption o He became a “hero figure” for NDP 1970 o His stubbornness almost brought down the NDP - Responded the “opposition can go to hell” and wouldn’t apologize therefore kicked out of the House of Commons - This made the NDP members mad Abortion issues o Started by accident - Canadian hospitals were making arrangements for Canadians to get legal abortions in USA o He believed abortions were morally wrong o He accidentally locked out a women’s liberation group when they were invited into visit the ministry - Claimed it was for safety reasons, but no one believed him - During apology he further insulted them by saying “its impossible to insult any abortion group” 1971 o He resigns on principle - What was the point in being a member of the House unless you could speak your mind o Continued to sit as an independent member ‘till 1973 when he was defeated o He believed the NDP lost its initial goal - Economic issues, not abortions 1973 o He spearheads a new pro-life group. In Manitoba - Started in a basement with influential men who wanted to remain homeless o Foundation received donations but these were not tax deductible donations 1975 o He goes to jail Chapter 8 o Supreme court of Canada (1875- 1949) - First 100 years thought of as a joke filled with drunks - Worked in shadows of the JCPC - It lacked responsibilities, influence and prestige that a nations “final court of appeal” normally had - Even after JCPC was dispended it still had problems - Provinces feared courts with federally appointed, by federal government without provinces input - At first Minister conferences were the preferred setting for fed- provincial disputes= unwritten conclusion - It was hard for the SC of C to protect constituently entrenched rights o “Warren Court” - Named after its chief justice - It was the well renowned court of the USA - It helped deal with racial segregation in the South, Diefenbaker bill of rights (1960) - Written rights -Problem; enacted as federal statue not constitutional amendment, therefore lacked higher law - Can the SC of C over rule a statue that conflicted w/ bill of rights or would this violate parliamentary supremacy 1970’s o The problem was solved the courts would not be able to do this. The tradition of parliamentary supremacy won. o Therefore the SC denied itself the power - Follows way of English (less intrusive) not Americans Henry Morgentaler o On trial at SC for violating the abortion previsions of the Criminal Code and Morgentaler also put on trial Canada’s abortion laws (2 cases in 1) o SC - Allows interviewer status to both parties - Does not usually do this (2 time) o Laskin Scandal - PM Trudeau appoints French judge over English judge with more experience (and it was out of truth) as chief justice of Canada - This judge agreed w/ both major political issues (Federalism and 1960s Bill or Rights) o This was good news for Morgentaler because this meant the judge was sympathetic to his case (“Laskin factor”) o Also put SC in centre of nations Political life for first time 2 Options o Would SC over rule Quebec Appeal courts ruling and set Margentater free or order a new trial o Follow the American path and declare Abortion law invalid under the Bill of Rights o Morgentalers lawyer tried to get a judge recused but it failed o From this point forward SC found itself involved in a lot of Political, Federal and Provincial battles Chapter 9 o Morgentaler - In huge amount of dept - SC rules 6-3 against him - New feces 18 months in jail Chief Justice Laskin - Says this is because Canadian Bill of Rights was not intervened in the constitution - Would be reformers began to call for a constituently enriched Bill of Rights Morgentaler o Goes to jail and does not like it o The debate continues to continue on w/ out him To protect Trial by Jury o If an appeal court found that a jury’s a equality was caused by an error in law they could order a re trial but never convict on their own Morgentaler o Was tried against in Quebec for 5 other charges - Offered a deal but refused - Found not guilty but Jury - Defense of necessity o Goes to court of appeal again -This tie he wins - Now original case gets re tried, on the grounds that the section 45 had been denied but defense of necessity was still on the table o Section 251 of the Criminal code is o longer enforceable in Quebec -Rise of liberal minded people in Quebec that Stemmed from the free sexual relations movement in the 60s o Became judges US juries in this case - Meaning Juries opinion VS actual law o Quebec became the only province that allowed abortion clinics—Very Catholic o OM Tredeau did not want to reopen issues even through legally it was not right- the issue had become to sensitive and wanted to maintain Ottawa- Quebec relationship Chapter 10 o In 1978 - Got pro life lawyers to see if it was possible to launch a lawsuit against abortion laws - It was possible to stop the funding of abortion clinics- he therefore tried it o Meets a lawyer named Morris Shumiatcher - Apparently he is the best - He designed the “right to life” constitutional challenge - Acted as a badge of credibility of Borowski - He was now more respected -Very smart man - Graduated with master and doctorate of Law - Youngest lawyer appointed Kings - Served as CCF ministers legal counsel -
More Less

Related notes for POLS 3130

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit