Textbook Notes (362,790)
Canada (158,054)
POLS 3130 (87)

Unit 4 Globe_New_Face_Judicial_Defiance.pdf

5 Pages
Unlock Document

University of Guelph
Political Science
POLS 3130
Dennis Baker

The new face of judicial defiance SEAN FINE - JUSTICE WRITER KITCHENER, ONT. — The Globe and Mail Published Friday, Dec. 13 2013, 10:46 PM EST Last updated Friday, Dec. 13 2013, 10:46 PM EST 16 comments Print AA 233 200 32 1 0 License Justice Colin Westman still remembers when, as a young lawyer who had barely outgrown a pampered childhood in Shawinigan, Que., he first read the pre-sentence reports that contain the life stories of convicted men and women. “It was like fiction,” the 70-year-old father of two tells a reporter in his Kitchener, Ont., office during a morning break from court. “I couldn’t believe the tragic backgrounds of some of these people. From the day they were born, they were behind the eight-ball.” MORE RELATED TO THIS STORY Judges’ opposition to fining criminals under fire from victims’ advocates Judges defy order to impose Tories’ victim-services surcharge Top court to weigh whether Ontario’s sex-offender registry should be public Today, after more than two decades of seeing a steady procession of those people, whom he calls broken souls, in his courtroom, Justice Westman has become one of many in several provinces defying the spirit, and sometimes the letter, of WATCH the Conservative government’s tough-on-crime Video: Inside the agenda. Kingston Penitentiary As of Oct. 24, the government has doubled financial penalties assessed on convicted criminals – $100 per summary offence, $200 per indictable offence – and removed justices’ discretion to waive them for impoverished offenders. The money is for victims’ services VIDEO Video: Justice Minister such as rape crisis centres and witness pledges crackdown on programs. cyberbullying That mandatory charge, and to some extent the government’s broader crime agenda, has run smack into Justice Westman and an independent judiciary. “It’s a sham to say, ‘Oh, we’re going to get you VIDEO money off the backs of these kinds of people,’” Video: Tories promise says the sturdily built white-haired judge, a cyberbullying law in member of the Ontario Court of Justice. “They throne speech don’t even have a method of collecting. It’s embarrassing. And why aren’t victims looked after in our general revenues, if you really have a heart?” The new law may seem small next to others passed by the Conservative government that have limited judges’ discretion. Justices are required to apply dozens of new mandatory minimum sentences. They can no longer use house arrest as an alternative to jail for many crimes, including some non-violent ones. Limits are stricter on how much credit judges can give people for time in jail before sentencing. But the fight over the financial penalties has become a rare, open clash between the judiciary and Parliament. It is about more than making all people who commit crimes pay for victim services. It is about the limits of judicial independence and justices’ right to speak publicly. “I live in the community, too,” says Justice Westman, who was appointed to the bench by Liberal premier David Peterson in 1990. “I’m not just a judge. I think sometimes these things have to be discussed openly. “Those people in the soup kitchens I see in the courtroom, they don’t have a voice. I think I have an obligation to them. These are my brothers and sisters, from a theological perspective.” Justice Westman wears a Christian cross under his judicial vestments. One broken soul Earlier that morning, a 35-year-old woman stood in the prisoner’s dock. She had spent 21 days in jail for violating a no-contact order with her husband. She had spent three weeks in the hospital for complications from diabetes, and had no place to go. Her husband took her in temporarily, and someone reported her to the authorities. She violated the no-contact order a second time. Patiently, Justice
More Less

Related notes for POLS 3130

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.