Textbook Notes (368,415)
Canada (161,876)
Philosophy (346)
PHI2396 (86)
Dean Lauer (29)
Chapter 17

PHI2396 Chapter 17: Bioethic Note 13 Chapter 17
Premium

3 Pages
37 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Philosophy
Course
PHI2396
Professor
Dean Lauer
Semester
Winter

Description
Chapter 17-Definition & Criteria of Death: It seems to be black and white –easy to define, but it is grey –hard to define DCD-Donation after cardiac death: it is very precious donations for numerous patients out there -but the problem arises that it is hard to define the point of the death and hard to know when it is right to take DCD -ideally, organ harvesting would take place before death for the highest quality organs (fresh & oxygenated) But in practice, it takes place within around 5min - 30mins after cardiac death (distinguishing death is very cloudy) **The best organs are the freshest organs (which are living tissues that degrades fairly quickly without fresh supplies and oxygen)  sooner the access, the better use for transplant like through DCD which usually use of organs that are fresh & oxygenated  Organ viability is time-sensitive & some organ-transplant doctors have been viewed as greedy killers who can’t wait to retrieve organs, or even encouraging death by suggesting opiates (killing analgesic drug)/blood thinners to still live patients **The ethical concern arises from the permission of letting die vs intentional encouragement of death to save another person’s life Permits the intentional killing of innocent life if: 1. Innocent will die anyway & 2. Another innocent life will be saved **In Canada, pronouncing cardiac death for organ donation need doctors to wait at least 5mins after the heart stops beating Traditional heart-lung definition Aka cardiopulmonary, cardiorespiratory, clinical death -For long periods of time, it was thought that the moment of death was based on just heart/lung death until the 1960s Simple layman’s diagnosis (inverse discussion questions on abortion): when life starts, it signals life (quickening) -which was hard to detect long time ago. Now the diagnosis of abortion is easier and it goes same for death which involved the end of movement  It is easy to detect when lung/heart stops, but breathing feeling of the circulation can be mistaken by shallowness  it is just simplest definition of death before medical society boomed which was unreliable & shabby technique Currently we look at much closer at the physiology and psychology. After ww2, there were development of medical science such as heart machine & transplant machine to keep the patients alive even with brain is dysfunctional -this turned the moment of death into a period of ear of death at the same time, life support with the new medical intervention, provided critical means for preserving retrieval of organs **Physicians argued to form a new definition of death, fearing they may be liable (with duty) for a patient’s well-being or fate for removing life-support for organ retrieval under the dead donor rule (organs cannot be obtained after the donor has died)–due to the chance of lawsuits on the physicians Whole-brain death: Harvard Med School ad hoc committee under Dr. H. Beecher proposed that death can be defined as when the entire brain irreversibly ceases functioning. This include: 1. unreceptive & unresponsive to external stimuli/inner need 2. lack of/no movements (breathing, etc.) under continuous medical observation up to 1h 3. lack of reflex action eg. blinking/eye movement –pupil dilation Whole Brain Formation: Breathing vs heart/respiration or brain -the pulse can be shallow or the breathing can be weak without any detail information about the person -if there is still brain functioning and still retrieving the functioning organs  is this criminal?? Or is it audacious?? -required to find new definition of death -There has to be finding electrical functioning -knowing details on brain stem -even with malfunctioning of the brain stem -there can be functioning of the cerebellum  the higher brain death seemed to be the real deal as permanent death Use of EEG for confirmation of whole-brain death - there was whole re-defining of the death of a person through the end of electrical signals within brain  it made doctors even harder to define death, when it dealt with the brain death which has fully functional organs other than dead brain **In Canada one of the whole-brain criteria for death has been practiced since 1968 “A person is dead when an irreversible cessation of all that person's brain functions has occurred” –this was recommended but wasn’t passed down Challenges to the Whole-Brain Formulation Return to the heart-lung formulation: whole-brain death is inessential, secondary since neural activity depends on a healthy circulation of [blood & oxygen] through heart-lung function but the time it takes for the signals to stop is too long for organ retrieval to happen -so there
More Less

Related notes for PHI2396

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit