Chapter 5.docx

4 Pages
72 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Political Science
Course
POLB80H3
Professor
M.Hoffmann- Universityof Toronto
Semester
Fall

Description
CHAPTER 5: REALISM INTRODUCTION: THE TIMELESS WISDOM OF REALISM Pg. 86 – the idealist focused much of their attention on understanding the cause of war so as to find the remedy for its existence  Ignored the role of power  Overestimated the degree to which human beings were rational  Mistakenly believe that nation-states shared a set of interests - New realist approach replaced idealist approach - Realism taught American leaders to focus on interests rather than on ideology, to seek peace through strength, and recognize great powers can coexist even with different values and beliefs - Raison d’etat is the fundamental principle of international conduct, state’s first law of motion - Survival of state can never be guaranteed, use of force is an instrument of statecraft - The state is the principal actor - Argues that survival requires state leaders to distance themselves from traditional morality - Raison d’etat speak of dual moral standard – one moral standard for individual citizens living inside the state and a different standard for the state in its external relations Pg. 87 – raison d’etat argue that states represent moral force, existence of state create an ethical political community to exist domestically - Realism’s core elements – statism, survival, self-help – classical realist - Since peace of Westphalia, sovereign state as principal actor in international polities (state- centric assumption of realism) - Statism – idea of state as legitimate representative of collective will of people - Outside boundaries, anarchy exist (international politics with no authority above) - Each sovereign states consider them to be its own highest authority and it doesn’t recognize a higher power - Assume all states wish to perpetuate their existence - Self-help – the principle of action in an anarchical system where there is no global government - If states feel threatened, should seek/engage in military arms build0up Pg. 88 – balance of power – if survival of a state or weaker states is threatened by hegemonic state, they should join forces, establish alliance, seek to preserve independence by seeing opposite’s power - Warsaw Pact and NATO ex. of balance of power in cold war - Critics: unable to explain the increase, incidence of intra-state wars plaguing global south  Unable to provide accounts of regional integration, humanitarian intervention, security community in West Europe ONE REALISM, OR MANY? Pg. 89 – periodization of realism: classical realism (beginning with Thucydide), modern realism (First Great Debate), structured or neo-realism CLASSICAL REALISM - Thucydides’ representation of power politics as a low of human behaviour - Human nature explain why international politics is power politics (Hans J. Morgenthau) - Politics governed by objective laws with their roots in human nature - The struggle for belonging Pg. 90 – Thucydides’ explanation of the growth of Athenian power and fear which caused in Sparta  Sparta’s national interest was survival and change in distribution of power represent threat - Athens pursue power to preserve empire - Athen’s leader Pericles was ambitious, fear, self-interest - Machiavelli – all obligations and treaties must be disregarded if security of the community is under threat Pg. 91 – mid-20 century anarchy could be miligated by wise leadership and pursuit of the national interest in ways that are compatible with international order - Acting only of power/self-interest without moral/ethical principles result in self-defeating policies STRUCTURAL REALISM - A struggle for power but not result of human nature - Conflict because of lack of authority above states and relative distribution of power - Waltz structure of international system – organizing principle, differentiation of units, distribution of capabilities - 2 organizing principles: anarchy and hierarchy Pg. 92 – numbe
More Less

Related notes for POLB80H3

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit