HPS250H1 Lecture : notes.doc
Document Summary
Kuhn"s viewpoint on the issue of: how can we obtain absolute knowledge ?) (ie. carrying on from last lecture: In order to be comparable, two competing theories must employ mutually translatable taxonomies. premise two. Competing theories can employ untranslatable taxonomies, i. e. they can be incommensurable. conclusion reached. It is not always possible to compare two competing theories. Scientific experiments are completely interpenetrated by theoretical interpretation, to the point where it becomes impossible to express fact in isolation from theory. Thus, it is impossible to falsify an individual scientific proposition. an example: with the theory: A thread breaks when it is loaded with a weight that exceeds the thread"s tensile strength. There are hundreds of ways to save a theory from falsification. In order to make a proposition testable, we must add many auxiliary hypotheses about working of the instruments, about initial conditions, etc. An individual theoretical proposition has no empirical consequences and cannot be tested in isolation.