PHL271H1 Lecture Notes - Lecture 4: Fundamental Justice, Negative Liberty, Assisted Suicide
!"#$%&'(#)%"*#%*+),-$#.*
*
*
/0***+),-$#.*1*-2'34)#.5*#6%*7'"&38-"#34*934'-:*7%$*&-8%($3()-:**
*
;<3#*6-*6)44*4%%=*3#5*
>;<3#*=)"&*%7*4),-$#.*:<%'4&*%'$*436:*?$%#-(#*)"*@3"3&3A**
>;<3#*=)"&*%7*4),-$#.*83##-$:*#%*':A*
*
;<3#*6-*6)44*"%#*4%%=*3#*-B?4)()#4.5*
>;<3#*):*#<-*$-43#)%":<)?*,-#6--"*4),-$#.*3"&*-2'34)#.A***
CD-$4)"5*#<-.*&%*(%"74)(#E*F6%$=)"5*#<-.*&%*"%#*(%"74)(#G*
*
*
D0**H-4-93"#*+36*>*Canadian&Charter&of&Rights&and&Freedoms*
*
*I-(#)%"*J5*
*
KLM9-$.%"-*<3:*#<-*$)N<#*#%*4)7-O*4),-$#.*3"&*:-('$)#.*%7*#<-*?-$:%"*3"&*#<-*$)N<#*"%#*
#%*,-*&-?$)9-&*#<-$-%7*-B(-?#*)"*3((%$&3"(-*6)#<*#<-*?$)"()?4-:*%7*7'"&38-"#34*
P':#)(-0Q*
*
I-(#)%"*R5*
*
KLThe&Canadian&Charter&of&Rights&and&Freedoms&N'3$3"#--:*#<-*$)N<#:*3"&**7$--&%8:*
:-#*%'#*)"*)#*:',P-(#*%"4.*#%*:'(<*$-3:%"3,4-*4)8)#:*?$-:($),-&*,.*436*3:*(3"*,-*
&-8%":#$3,4.*P':#)7)-&*)"*3*7$--*3"&*&-8%($3#)(*:%()-#.0Q*
*
ST%#-*#<3#*)#*):*'?*#%*P'&N-:*#%*)"#-$?$-#*#<-:-*:-(#)%":*
So&this&gives&judges&a&great&amount&of&power.*
*
*
SWhat&would&Hart&and&Dworkin&say&about&what&judges&are&doing,&when&they&interpret&
these§ions&of&the&Charter?*
*
*
@0**U%6*:<%'4&*6-*'"&-$:#3"&*L4),-$#.QA**;<3#*=)"&*%7*4),-$#.*83##-$:*#%*':A*
*
*>V<)4%:%?<-$:*$-(%N")W-*&)77-$-"#*(%"(-?#)%":*%7*4),-$#.5*
*
T-N3#)9-*4),-$#.5**7$--&%8*7$%8*)"#-$7-$-"(-O*#<-*7$--&%8*#%*&%*6<3#-9-$*.%'*(3"*
)"&-?-"&-"#4.*&%*,.*.%'$:-47*C)"&)9)&'34):#)(*:-":-G*
*
V%:)#)9-*4),-$#.*%7*)"&)9)&'34:5*N-"')"-*:-47>&-#-$8)"3#)%"E*#<-*3,)4)#.*#%*N')&-*.%'$*
%6"*4)7-O*3((%$&)"N*#%*.%'$*%6"*?43"**
* * *
