Week 4 October 1, 2012

5 Pages
88 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Woodsworth College Courses
Course
WDW101Y1
Professor
Dena Demos
Semester
Fall

Description
Week 4 October 1, 2012 Legal Consciousness -separation of law from people, it is out there far beyond us, above society. -we need to take it off the mountain, put people back in Where Does Law Come From? -law is not contaminated from people, sense of purity, above us, separated from us-Official version of law law as unaffected and unperverted law on a mountaintop - separation = justice? -we started to look at law as a web in a society, helps us to structure our lives, law tells us what to do- sounds like morality, however the official version of law tells us that it should not count any values and morals. -different societies produce different perception of law. -defining features of Canada-Canada is multicultural, democracy –fair and equal participation, democracy helps to think about substantial equality. law as part of society - context - law as it is lived different societies produce different kinds of law Capitalism and Democracy --> ongoing TENSION-> Capitalism based on inequality , Canada has 2 great defining ideas, produce electricity .undercurrent that goes in law all the time. Law is good and bad depending on how you look at it. Natural Law transcendence - universal morality everybody shares core believes, a divine natural order-a set of universal moral principles they assume that the moral principles can be discovered by the “correct” exercise of intellect - reason/rationality. so if you think hard you can come up to it?? In context that does not work. Who is obedient? Obedience to the law is the virtue. (you are a good person) obedience as virtue? What if you cant obey the law? What if there is a special circumstance? Or a choice? In law an interplay between CHOICE and CONSTRAINT-you are either an actor, who is making the choices, or a victim. Problematic dichotomy. the search for truth – power, where the truth come from?? We need to move from idea that law is based on different morals. One way to deal with it is to take values and ideas out of it. When we pretend there is no dominant values, other with different values suffer Legal Positivism (revisited) Judges have to be impartial. They use certain test, based on what is legally relevant. It is an attempt to make decisions rationally. Separating ideas from morality. In theory it sounds good. Effect- of keeping certain ideas and morals values system, beliefs, hidden, but alive. facts not values - rational decision making separation of law from morality result? Law and Morality Law is just when is based on positivism-in theory. In practice… Morality is something that is often vague, but law is something to be specific. Morality depends on circumstances, but law depends on the set rules. Law is not open to many moral discussions. law and morality work together - somehow... morality is vague, law is specific morality as relative - shared universal moral code? morality as uncertain, complicated, contested/challenged, just as law we think of it being contested law has to balance the interests - choice/constraint? Individual vs society, democracy vs capitalism we can track how certain ideas keep filtering through society. freedom, equality, dignity order law as a filter, instead of saying law ha values, say law acts as a filter, only small things get through it. Only particular ideas get stuck in it and only some come out of it. Whether it based on haves or have not’s? Law and Justice Law is very slow and difficult to reform law and social change - collective consciousness, rigidity/hard to reform-> injustice what holds society together? Critical Analysis not a critique of shortcomings or failings conditions of knowledge-where idea come from. Track how knowledge flows through the law. track the creation and dissemination of knowledge - flow of power context dynamic the lived experience of law Legal Consiousness-Ewick and Silbey knowledge or awareness of law and its potential “ordinary” people idealized version of law - law as a shield frustration wi
More Less

Related notes for WDW101Y1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit