Comparative Politics Today Notes Chapter 6.doc

10 Pages

Political Science
Course Code
Kaare Strom

This preview shows pages 1,2 and half of page 3. Sign up to view the full 10 pages of the document.
Comparative Politics Today Notes Chapter 6: Policymaking: a pivotal stage in the political process; the point at which bills become laws or edicts are issued by rulers. - Before understanding public policy, we must know how decisions are made Constitution and Decision Rules: • A constitution establishes the basic rules of decision-making, rights and the distribution of authority in a political system. Sometimes it’s a specific document, sometimes not. • Rule of Law: people can only get punished for violating the laws and the government can’t take actions that aren’t authorized by the law. The constitution is the supreme body of laws in this type of political system • Decision Rules: the basic rules governing how decisions are made. Constitutions have these. They affect political activity because they determine what political resources are valuable in influencing decisions and how to acquire and use these resources. Inclusive rules can protect against hasty decisions and decisions against minorities. The less inclusive the rules, the easier it is to reach a policy, but certain interests may be ignored. Decision rules in hierarchies neglect those below the ruler, as their vote is the only one that counts, which makes policymaking easy and fast, but may ignore other interests. The inclusiveness of the decision rules shapes the outcome, no matter what. • It’s important that decision rules in a democracy are transparent and stable. If not, then the people will not know what to expect from their government, which can lead to conflict and ultimately a breakdown of the government. • Policymaking gets the public’s interests and sets them into laws, and the constitution establishes rules on how to go about doing that. Making Constitutions: • It’s a fundamental political act; it creates or transforms decision rules. The creation of or amendments to a constitution are usually brought on by some violent break (war). • Britain does not have a constitution, reflecting their gradual and peaceful political change • Many new political experiments and political systems have been introduced in the past decades since WWII, especially with developing countries. Democratization has been an increasing trend since then. Democracy and authoritarianism: • Democracy: rule/govern by the people. People can participate in politics, elect leaders, have political parties and influence political choices. • Authoritarian regime: military councils, hereditary families, dominant political parties, and the like choose policymakers. Citizens are either ignored or pressed into symbolic assent to the government’s choices. • The basic decision rules vary on three dimensions: o The separation of powers among different branches of government o The geographic distribution of authority between the central (national) government and lower levels, such as states, provinces, or municipalities o Limitations on government authority Separation of government powers: • Separation of powers: prevents an unchecked executive or legislature • There are two different kinds of regimes: Presidential and Parliamentary o Democratic presidential regime: provides two separate agencies of government – the executive and the legislative – separately elected and authorized by the people. o Parliamentary regimes: they make the executive and legislative branches much more interdependent. Only the legislative branch is directly elected. The Prime Minister and the Cabinet emerge from the legislature. • Confidence relationship: the relationship between the Prime Minister and the majority parliamentary that allows the Prime Minister to call new elections when there is a vote of lack of confidence, which would force him and the cabinet to resign. This makes them interdependent on each other. • Prime ministers can be voted out of office at any time, either by a no-confidence motion or by defeating a confidence motion. Confidence motions are normally brought on by the Prime Minister attached to a bill, making the parliament choose between the bill or the gov’t. Therefore, they do not experience as much division in politics. • Semipresidential: Mixed between a presidential state and a parliamentary state, where the president and the parliament are separately elected, but the president also has the power to dissolve the legislature. Many new democracies are of this type of regime. • Most theorists favor the British form of parliament because it can result fairly stable governments responsible to public will. The US democratic system is often criticized for being a divided government. • People are arguing more for a parliamentary proportional representation system, because democracies are more susceptible to breaking down with social conflict • Presidential systems provide practical advantages of presidential systems with significant executive power, and also give the president a significant amount of power. It puts more effective checks on the power of the majority in the legislature. Geographic Distribution of Government power: • Federal systems: it’s caught in the middle between confederal systems and unitary systems. It’s where central and local units each have autonomy in certain public policy spheres. Most states in the world are unitary, with only 18 being federal, but those that are federal tend to be the biggest and most powerful politically. There are many aspects of a federal system: o It may help protect minorities in a divided society o They can experiment with different policies o People can choose the policy environment that best fits their preferences o While promoting choice and diversity, it does it at the expense of equality, treating certain citizens better than others o Centralized party control may overcome apparent regional autonomy • Under the Articles of Confederation, the US was confederal, where all power lies with the states. • The central government rarely change in a unitary government Limitations on government power: • Constitutional Regimes: a type of system where the powers of government units are defined and limited by a written constitution, statutes, and custom • The courts are CRUCIAL to limiting government power • Judicial Review: where high courts rule on challenges that other units of government have exceeded the powers allocated by the constitution. But this can often be ineffective due to lack of overcoming executive power. • Some other constitutional regimes have independent courts that protect persons against the improper implementation of laws and regulations, but cannot legally overrule the assembly or the political executive. • Most democracies either have medium-strength or strong judicial reviews • All written constitutions provide for amending procedures. An amendment cannot be too easy to make for it may jeopardize important constitutional protections, therefore, some arrangements in the constitution may not be amended. Some vary on complexity for amending the constitution, with the UK being the easiest and the US being the most difficult procedure. • Constitutions may concentrate or disperse government power along several dimensions, creating a checks and balances system and in some cases eradicating tyranny. Checking the top policymakers: • One challenge of government is to control the excesses of top political leaders, giving a way to get rid of a certain leader if need be. The way to do that in a Democracy is by impeachment, which can be used on any incumbent, and involves three components: o Impeachable offenses are usually identified as presenting unusual danger to the public good or safety o The penalty is removal from office (sometimes with separate criminal penalties) o Impeachment cases are decided by the legislative but require more than ordinary majorities a
More Less
Unlock Document

Only pages 1,2 and half of page 3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.