Aristotle, Nicomachean - book 1 ch.1-13 and book 2 ch.1-9
12
Pages
154
Views
Department
Philosophy
Course Code
PHL100Y1
Professor
Mark Kingwell
Philosophy
The Virtuous Life
Reading: Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics Books 1-2
Book 1
Chapter 1
•Every skill and every inquiry, and every action and rational choice is thought to
aim at some good
•Therefore good is at which everything aims
•Difference in ends: some are activities, other are products, which are additional to
the activities where the products are by nature better than the activities
•Because there are many actions, sciences, and skills, therefore there are many
ends, e.g. end of medicine is health
•But when any of these actions, skills, or sciences come under some single faculty,
then in all these cases the end of the master science is more worthy of choice than
the ends of subordinate sciences, since these too are pursed for the sake of the
former
Chapter 2
•If what is done has some end that we want for its own sake, and everything else
we want is for the sake of this end; and if we do not choose everything for the sake
of something else, then this will result in the chief good.
•Knowledge of good is concern of the most authoritative science—the science of
politics, because it lays down which of the sciences there should be in cities, and
which each class of person should learn and up to what level
•Political science’s end will be the human good, because it employs other sciences,
lays down the laws about what we should do and refrain from, and its end will
include the end of others
•The good of an individual is desirable, but good for people and city is more
godlike thing
Chapter 3
•Each person judges well what he knows, and is a good judge of this
•In any subject, and the person educated in all subjects is a good judge without
qualifications
•One can gain knowledge only when they are living and engaging in each of his
pursuits according to his feelings.
•Knowledge of the matters that concern political science will prove very beneficial
to those who follow reason both in shaping their desires and in acting
Chapter 4
•All knowledge and rational choice seek good
•Aim of political science: of all the good things to be done, what is the highest—
happiness?
www.notesolution.com
Philosophy
•What is happiness? Masses: something straight forward, obvious, e.g. pleasure,
wealth, honour. Sometimes differ based on situation for same person, e.g. when
he is ill, it is health, and when he is poor, it is wealth
•Plato – way to go was from first principle or to first principle?
•We are known in two senses: known by us, and known without qualification
•Begin from things known by us
•First principle – the belief that something is the case, and if this is sufficiently
clear, he will not need the reason why as well
•Hesoid: person who understand everything for himself is the best, and the person
who needs advice is noble, but person who is neither understand or takes to heart
is a worthless man
Chapter 5
•3 types of life: life of enjoyment, life of politics, and life of contemplation
•Sophisticated men, men of action, see happiness as honour, since it is almost the
end of political life
•Pursue honour to convince themselves of their goodness; seek to be honoured by
people with practical wisdom—to these people, virtue is superior
Chapter 6
•It is best to ignore one’s personal feelings when preserving the truth, especially for
philosophers
•It is sacred to prefer the truth to one’s friends
•Good is spoken of in categories of substance, quality and of relation
•Good is spoken of in that of quality – the virtues in that of quality – the right
amount in that of relation – the useful, in that of time – the right moment, and in
that of place – the right locality, etc
•Therefore no common universal good
•Things which are pursued and valued for their own sake are called good, while
these that tend to be instrumental to these things or in some way preserve or
prevent their contraries are called good for the sake of these
•Therefore things should be called good in 2 senses: things good to themselves,
and things good for the sake of thing good to themselves
•Things good to themselves, those that are sought even on their own, include:
understanding, sight, certain types of pleasure, and honours
Chapter 7
•Good varies b/w actions and skills
•If everything that is done has some end, this will be the good among things done,
and if there are several ends, these will be the goods
•The chief good manifestly is something complete
www.notesolution.com
Philosophy
•So if there is only one end that is complete, this will be what we are looking for,
and if there are several of them, the most complete
•That which is worth pursuing for its own sake is more complete than that which is
worth pursuing only for the sake of something else and that which is never worth
choosing for the sake of something else is more complete than things that are
worth choosing both in themselves and for the sake of this end
•Therefore which is always worth choosing in itself and never for the sake of
something else is complete without qualification
•E.g. happiness is complete without qualification, because we always choose it for
itself and never choose for the sake of anything else, whereas honour, pleasure and
virtue we choose for themselves, but we also choose them for the sake of
happiness, believing they will lead us to happiness. Yet we do not choose
happiness for the sake of these or anything else.
•Self-sufficient: something that which on its own makes life worthy of choice and
lacking in nothing
•The good, or the doing well of a sculptor or any practitioner of a skill, or whatever
has some characteristic activity or action lies in its characteristic activity, so is
said for a human being, if he has a characteristic activity
•Searching for characteristic activity in a human being – rule out life of
nourishment and growth, because we are looking for something that is unique to a
human beings and plants/animals live just like humans do
•Also rule out sentiment, because it is shared by all animals
•Finally life remains, concerned in some way with action, of the element that
possesses reason (of this element, one part of reason in being obedient to reason,
the other in possessing it and engaging in thought)
•If the characteristic activity of a human being is an activity of the soul in
accordance with reason, and if the characteristic activity of anything is the same
in kind as that of a good thing of the same type, e.g. in the case of a lyre-player
and a good lyre-player, the superiority of the good one in virtue being an
addiction to the characteristic activity (e.g. characteristic activity of a lyre-player
is to play, and of a good lyre-player is to play it well), and if this is true, we take
the characteristic activity of a human being to be a certain kind of life, and if we
take this kind of life to be activity of the soul and action in accordance with
reason, and the characteristic activity of the good person to be to carry this out
well and nobly, and a characteristic activity to be accomplished well when it is
accomplished in accordance with the appropriate virtue, then the human good
turns out to be the activity of the soul in accordance with the best and most
complete, where this must be a complete life
Chapter 8
•Goods have been classified into 3 groups: external goods, goods of the soul, and
goods of the body
www.notesolution.com
Loved by over 2.2 million students
Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.
OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!
Leah — University of Toronto
Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.
Saarim — University of Michigan
As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.
Jenna — University of Wisconsin
OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver
Anne — University of California
Description
Related notes for PHL100Y1
