Textbook Notes (368,802)
Canada (162,170)
LAW 603 (76)
Chapter 14

Chapter 14.docx

7 Pages
185 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Law and Business
Course
LAW 603
Professor
George Ellinidis
Semester
Fall

Description
Chapter 14 – Special Contracts: Negotiable Instruments Introduction  Cash can be inconvenient and dangerous (bulky and usually impossible to recover if lost) o Essential feature of cash: it is currency o Person becomes owner of cash by honestly paying for it o If someone steals $1000, does not own cash, but if buys a stereo with it, the storekeeper who is unaware of the theft, now owns the cash and it cannot be retrieved  “nemo dat quod non habet” – no one can give what they do not have. If you trade stolen car for neighbour’s boat, victim may recover value of car from neighbour, even if neighbour acted honestly  Negotiable Instrument – consists of a contract that contains an obligation to pay money o You decide to buy a car, and writing a cheque for it creates a new contract o If bank does not honour cheque, dealer can sue either on the sales contract, or on the cheque itself  Easier to prove the existence of a negotiable instrument rather than the existence of a sales contract  Obligation conditionally discharged once cheque given to dealership  Cheque is a type of contract  Differences between normally governed contracts and cheques: o Consideration – cheque is enforceable only if it is supported by consideration – something of value must be given in exchange  Normally, consideration cannot consist of a promise to perform an obligation that is already owed to the same party, but this does not apply to cheques  Presumes that consideration was given by every person whose signature appears in the negotiable instrument o Privity – anyone who holds a cheque can sue on it  Normally, a contract can be enforced only by someone with privity (someone who participated in the creation of the contract)  If instead of cashing the cheque, the payee sells it to someone it owes money to, that third party can sue you on the cheque o Assignment – contractual obligations can be assigned to a stranger  A person who receives a contractual obligation through an assignment takes is subject to the equities  Assignee cannot be in a better position than the assignor  Negotiable instrument represents a compromise between a simple contract and money o More valuable than money because it is negotiable and can be easily transferred from one party to another in a way that may remove any defects o It is a contract that is intended to eventually result in the payment of money  Major risk: non-performance o Easier to sue on a negotiable instrument rather than simple contract  Enforcement is necessary in either event  Coins and bills never worthless, have value in themselves The Bills of Exchange Act  Canadian Parliament introduced Act in 1890 o Intention: increase economic efficiency by providing business people with a comprehensive set of rules regarding non-monetary payments o British Parliament released act in 1882 o Much less flexible than Sale of Goods Act  Simple and provides default rules, even if not all rules are accepted, it stills falls within the Act o Contains many rules that a contract must satisfy, if not met, Act not applied o Difference arises because sale if goods normally involves only 2 parties, while negotiable instruments are designed to be freely transferred amongst many people  Contracts for negotiable instruments and sales of goods have both been codified  Does not refer to certification – procedure based on American banking law Type of Negotiable Instruments  Bills of Exchange Act covers cheques, bills of exchange and promissory notes  Five requirements must be met for the Act to apply: o Signed and Written o Parties Identified – must be possible to immediately identify who is required to make the payment o Certain Sum of Money – must deal entirely with the payment of money, not delivery or performance  Must be able to calculate amount of money by simply looking at it (may not involve the payment of interest ) o Time of Payment – must be able to determine when it can be turned to cash o Unconditional Obligation – must be possible to immediately know exactly what payee is receiving  Each requirement serves the goal of certainty  A negotiable instrument must tell a complete story  Document that does not meet those requirements may still be a valid contract, but will not fall under the Act Cheques  Cheque – created when a person order a bank to pat a specific amount of money to someone  Most common form of negotiable instrument  Drawer – person who “draws,” or creates the cheque  Drawee – the bank that is ordered to pay the money  Payee – the person who is entitled to receive the money from the bank  Relationships: o Drawer and Payee – 2 contracts exist: first is the sale of goods agreement and the second is the cheque itself  By writing cheque, drawer is fulfilling his obligation under the sales contract by ordering the drawee to pay the payee o Drawer and Drawee – bank promised to honour cheque and pay as long as it appears in the correct form and drawer has enough money in the account  If bank improperly refuses to pay, it could be held liable to drawer for breach of contract o Payee and Drawee – Payee does not have a relationship with the bank  Payee cannot sue bank if it refused to pay the cheque, would have to sue drawer on either the cheque or the sales contract  Since bank does not owe any obligations to payee, bank may use slightly different rules from those set out Postdated Cheques  Postdated Cheque – dated in the future  Drawer may deliver cheque, but does not want it cashed until later  Bank is only allowed to debit account if it acts in accordance with his instructions  Usually used if a contract requires installment payments (rent, car lease, etc.) Staledated Cheques  Staledated Cheque – when payee does not seek payment within a reasonable time  Usually 6 months after the date on the cheque  Payee could sue drawer on either the cheque or sales contract o Payee has 2-6 years to sue drawer, or it becomes unenforceable Overdrawn Cheques  Overdrawn – when the drawer’s account does not hold enough money to satisfy it completely  Also referred to as NSF – Non-Sufficient Funds  Bank may still honour cheque, and then seek repayment from drawer o Even if bank honours cheque by mistake  If drawer knows that account does not have sufficient funds, he can be charged with the crime of False Pretenses Counterdemanded Cheques  Bank can deal with a customer’s money only if it has that person’s authorization  Counterdemand – when a customer orders a bank to refuse payment on a cheque o Also referred to as “Stop payment Order”  By counterdemanding, drawer is removing bank’s authority to deal with his account  Limitations: o Banks will not normally accept a counterdemand unless the drawer gives that order in person, and cheque details are given in full  Details required so incorrect stop payment is not placed o Many bank contracts include a term that allows a bank to debit a customer’s account if counterdemanded cheque is honored by mistake  Bank may have to sue payee if it wants to recover payment made by mistake  Bank would sue under restitution under action of unjust enrichment  Bank cannot sue in contract because it does not have a contract with payee  Cheque is automatically counterdemanded if the bank is notified that the drawer has died before the payee receives payment Certified Cheques  There is no guarantee that a cheque will be cashed o It is a promise to pay, but not all promises are kept  Certification – when a drawee bank promises to honour a cheque o Usually stamped “Certified” and dated o Fee charged for certification o Courts consider it “something equivalent to money” o Funds withdrawn from drawer’s account and placed in a “suspense account” until cheque is presented for payment and can be honoured  Cheque can be certified by payee or drawer  Once cheque is certified, drawee owes and obligation to payee o If bank does not honour cheque, payee can sue bank  Bank cannot hide behind its own error, must fulfill its promise o If certified by mistake, and account is overdrawn, bank must still honour cheque  Certification ensures cheque cannot become counterdemanded o Bank may allow a certified cheque to be counterdemanded if the drawer is willing to provide indemnification by promising to provide compensation to the bank if it is sued o If cheque is certified by drawer, it can be cancelled and the funds returned to the account if the cheque has not been delivered to the payee Bills o
More Less

Related notes for LAW 603

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit