Class Notes (836,370)
Canada (509,757)
Classics (1,714)
CLA160H1 (318)
J.Ramsay (17)
Lecture 12

Lecture 12

6 Pages
39 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Classics
Course
CLA160H1
Professor
J.Ramsay
Semester
Winter

Description
Myth Criticism • Deep roots needed for mythology Evolutionary Pscyhology • Applies principle of evolutionary biology: how the human mind evolved • What purpose did human traits serve? • Art and literature is the part of evolutionary psychology that is important to mythology • Mythology rooted in fundamental human nature Literary Darwinism • Apply the evolution or art and lit to see how myths are rooted in human evolution • Why do we tell stories in the first place? Why do our stores take the form they do? • Human conflict shaped by evolution Iliad in terms of Evolutionary Psychology • Robin Fox: looks at Trojan War and other stories as phenomenon of male bonding • Excluding females • Heterosexual bond between man and woman, as man with the husband and father is in fundamental conflict with male bonding • Applies to Bro code! • Fox looks at the women int he iliad as disabling females, threatening the male bond (this is a universal type) • CompareAchilles and Patroclus to Gilgamesh and Enkidu • Enikdu is a savage counterpart to keep him tamed • They form a bond, and enkidu turns him from a tyrant into someone more ‘civilized’ • But Enkidu must also be civilized by Gilgamesh by exposing him to female sexuality • Enkidu is setting all the animals Gilgamesh tries to capture, and he tells the stalker, Enkidu to go take a woman • As a result of his relations he becomes less phsycially ferocious and intellectually more mature • This makes him ripe for comradeship with Gilgamesh - no logner a brute • And the prostitute actually points to gilgamesh as his new comrade • Animals now turn from him as a result of his humanizing experience • In another version the prostitute asks him why he is hanging out in the wild and not in civilization/ she tells him to go be friends with Gilgamesh • This woman’s advice leads to male bonding which is at the heart of the epic, so clearly no conflict there • How does this play out in the Iliad? • Patroclus is more an elder brother figure for achilles - he looks out for him] • Patroclus is a sort of moral compass - he humnizes achilles • Male monding is what makes him human, but not the only thing • What es does patroclus encourage? Why does briseis mourn patroclus? • Patrcolus tried to change Briseis from a war prize to a wife - this must be looked as a process of humanizing him • Achilles is incomplete without a real, permanent female companionship • There does not seem to be a strong opposition (again) between mal bond and heterozesual bond • Gottschall • Blames the women • Sexual competition for women is at the root of male male conflict • This is seen in a bunch of different mammals • “parental investment gap” how much time effort is given ti bring an offspring intot h world • Amale can theoretically have a vast number of offpsirng • Male paternal care is a deeply rooted human trait so they don’t throw their sperm aroudn willy nilly • Takes a long time to turn an egg into a baby • So when you have a situation where the male can reproduce a whole lot and hte female is limited you get permiscious males and choosy females • More males wnat to mate than there are available opportunities • This leads to competition, for “previous resource” of fmeale reproductive cpacitypppp • Direct competition • Indirect competition as well feeds into the same goal: increasng reproductivr success • Even when you think youa ren’t seeking women (for example, seeking status) you’re still seeking women • This darwinian competition between men for female reproductive cpaacity conditions everthing in the iliad • Gottschall argues that high status chieftans likeAgamemnon asically participating in polygny • Female mortality: female infanticide was often practices. Unsure if this happened in homeric times but reasonable to assume • Speaks of “Homer’s missing daughters” • Homer mentions loads of sons, but no daughters • The sons are more cared for and asked after • Sexual selection • Women chosiness leading to macho butch warriors • This is why trojansn and greeks fight over Helen • Basically vicious cycle of fighting over women • The problem is: in the iliad how tdo the Greek and trojans present their conflict? The TrojanAnswer • Trojan elders say she is super pretty, and thus reasonable tofight for beautiful women • As they are super 3 function, they value helene’s beauty and thus sex GreekAnswer • Menelaus has the mot reason to be fighting for a woman is actually a backseat driver • The leader isAgamemnon, adn Odyssesu advises • Agamemnon says that they have suffered dishonor and shame • Odysseus thinks it is disgraceful • Thats what the greeks fighting for • The trojans think the war is abotu helen but more it is about honor • If sex is meant to drive the greeks we don’t reall see them displaying 3 fucntion desires • Sex is used as a weapon • Sex is a a road to status , not status a road to sex • The WIFE of a trojan, not just ny trojan woman • If it were just a trojan woman it woudl confiem Gotschalls theory • But sex has nothign to do with desire, it is a weapon • Revenege-rape • Achilles andAgamemon about sex: • Agamemonon bullies Chryses dad with threat of sex • Humiliatng sacrifice • Briseis is at the heart of conflict • Agamemnon takes her away from achilles to humiliate him • ButAchlles gives no sign he is interested in actual sexual relations with Briseis • He took away the toy but doesnt want to play with her himself • Briseis does not prompt sexual conflict: agamemnon does not ha
More Less

Related notes for CLA160H1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit